Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 15 · 8 April 1904
4printed page
scan 4 of 20
Facsimile · scan 4 of 20
Scan of p. 4
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 15

One must above all ascertain what the character of the land will be, and consequently the importance of the lands to be acquired. One must then above all learn whether, by an agreement with the Government, the land might not be acquired by way of concession, without paying the purchase price. Were this last possibility realizable, the founding of an agrarian bank would lose much of its importance.

Under these circumstances, and before these preliminary questions have been decided in a satisfactory manner, it would be premature to discuss the principle of the agrarian bank, and in particular to follow the Russian delegates into the details of the organization of its management. What has been said above suffices to prove the necessity of a serious study of the project of colonization in Asiatic Turkey. It seems only useful to state briefly as well the chief motives which have convinced me that colonization, if it is to be sure of success, must be attempted first of all in the New World, and especially in the Argentine Republic.

If we first take the standpoint of agriculture and of the material conditions of life, it is quite easy to show the superiority of this latter country.

It is well known that agriculture does not prosper in Turkey; the causes of this phenomenon are known as well.

The soil of the Argentine Republic, on the other hand, is of a proverbial fertility; the climate is excellent; in consequence of the financial crisis now prevailing in that country, considerable tracts of land can at present be bought at very remunerative prices; the Argentine Republic is the true land of the future. Hundreds of millions have been spent there up to now on the building of railways, the widening of rivers, the construction of harbours; all this was created at great cost and already exists. The new settlers will profit by these exceptionally favourable conditions.

If we leave aside agriculture and material life and turn to the social life of the colonies, I likewise maintain that the Argentine Republic offers the Jews a point of concentration such as they will hardly find elsewhere. The area of the country is nine times greater than that of France, and the population does not amount even to four millions. Consequently there is room enough, and possibility of development in the future, for an unlimited number of Jews.

At the moment when the Jews emigrate, they must not merely be concerned to find a resting-place and a respite for a few years, but must be firmly resolved to secure peace and stability for their descendants in the future. Are those who wish to direct the Russian emigrants to Asiatic Turkey sure that these emigrants will see a useful result of their labours and the crowning success of their efforts? Do the promoters not fear to expose these Jews to a future not unlike their present one among the Russian persecutors? Have they considered that in this way they are striving to scatter the emigration movement instead of concentrating it?

Now, however, the general idea, the fundamental principle, the starting-point of emigration must in my judgment be concentration.

But, as I said at the outset, if the delegates of the Russian societies insist upon their project, I am entirely ready to place at their disposal both my influence and my active collaboration with the Imperial Ottoman Government.

I wished merely to prove to them the necessity of studying the project exactly and thoroughly, and the superiority of colonization in the Argentine over all the systems of colonization that have hitherto been proposed. This preliminary study is for me a question of such high importance that it takes precedence over all others; it is, moreover, an indispensable condition of my definitive intervention.

* * *

When I had already drawn up this memorandum, I was visited by Monsieur J. Navon, who, as you know, was in communication with Monsieur Erlanger of the Alliance in the matter of emigration to Asiatic Turkey. I spoke with him at great length, and I convinced myself that, although an enthusiastic adherent of emigration to Asiatic Turkey, he would at bottom not hesitate to give the preference to the Argentine Republic, had he not already earlier engaged himself in the other project.

My conversation with Monsieur Navon may be summed up as follows: I showed him the danger one might run if one were to direct the emigration to Asiatic Turkey blindly, and likewise to negotiate with the Government at haphazard, without first investigating most precisely, and on the spot, the localities that might prove most suitable for colonization. Monsieur Navon believes, and I believe he is right, that the Turkish Government, provided that Palestine is renounced, will admit a limited number of Jewish immigrants and cede to them the necessary lands free of charge or almost without payment. For my part I should prefer the purchase of these lands, in order to be master of them.

In short, M. Navon grasps the absolute necessity of first sending a commission of 3 or 5 persons to Constantinople, in order to study thoroughly the question of the lands to be chosen and to negotiate with the Turkish Government.

These delegates would act both in the name of the Alliance and in my own. M. Navon would like it to be done chiefly in my name; I confess that I hesitate a little to give the matter the appearance of proceeding for the most part from me; the reasons for my hesitation I have set forth above. Nevertheless I for my part shall do everything, when it becomes necessary, and, as I have said, shall be sparing neither of my influence nor of my active collaboration.

These delegates would have to put themselves in communication with competent persons concerning the choice of land suitable for colonization; they will have to visit these localities and examine them carefully; they will also find out the best manner of organizing the emigration; in a word, they will have to draw up the plan of a real campaign, as I did for the emigration to Argentina with the help of Dr. Löwenthal.

Finally, after the plan has been settled, they will have to negotiate with the Turkish Government in order to fix the terms of the purchase of land or of land concessions, the duration, the amount of the taxes, etc. This study, which is of great importance, must be made with extraordinary conscientiousness.

It will now be necessary that the delegates and the members of the Central Committee of the Alliance who drew up the minutes of the meeting of 22 July 1891