No. 1 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 9
(continued from page 8)
…not in any way prepared according to plan; they arose, rather, from a far more harmless cause — from hatred of the Jews.
But it is not only this extraordinarily soothing balm that is offered to the Jews as the outcome of the Kischinew trial; from the mouth of the public prosecutor there sounds yet a second message of hope: one day the hatred of the Jews will vanish, but for the present "the antipathy is a very powerful and deeply rooted one." For the present, then — that is, in the coming decades — the Jews will have, in the event of any excesses, the infinitely precious consolation that the outrages do not have their origin in any out-of-the-way motives, but solely in hatred of the Jews.
Since hatred of the Jews is thus put forward, so to speak, as an extenuating circumstance, we may perhaps be permitted to remark that the same extenuating argument could, for that matter, equally be urged if a premeditated organisation of the excesses were admitted. For one may with good right maintain that the hypothetical "intellectual" arrangers of the murders were likewise "only" inspired by hatred of the Jews when, for the trial of some experiment or other, they assigned to the Jews of all people the part of laboratory animals. It is therefore evident — if we must indulge in hair-splitting theory — that the antithesis drawn by the Kischinew public prosecutor between planned organisation and hatred of the Jews cannot be sustained.
If we must indulge in hair-splitting theory! That is indeed the bitter satyr-play after the tragedy. The days of Kischinew are followed by a trial in which, with pilpulistic dialectic, the fundamental problem is treated at great length whether a bandit requires a "higher" intellectual stimulus for the commission of murders, or whether he is able to draw the necessary enthusiasm from the depths of his own heart. And the last day of the proceedings then brings the precious final link of this inquiry in the philosophy of law: the establishment of the antithesis in principle between "organisation" and "hatred of the Jews." And as the closing chord there follows a sentence which, consistently enough, contents itself with two maximum penalties — penal servitude of seven and five years respectively.
Will the unhappy father of the murdered young Baranowitsch, one wonders, know how to value in sufficient measure the enrichment of his knowledge of the philosophy of law which accrues to him from the trial? r.
North America and the Russian Jewish Question.
The correspondent of the "Morning Post" cables from Washington: Should there be a renewed massacre of Jews, diplomatic relations between Russia and America would become so strained that their rupture would be possible. The American Jews are firmly convinced that a fresh attack upon their co-religionists in Kischenew is imminent, and have petitioned Roosevelt to seek to prevent the atrocities by representations. The American consuls at the various Russian stations have been instructed to report. President Roosevelt has so far not seen occasion for active measures, since no outbreak has yet occurred. But the Jews hold out the prospect, in the event of any further outrage, of such an upheaval of public opinion that the President would have to intervene drastically. The Cabinet dealt with the Jewish question in extraordinary session, and the British Government will be informed that America will join in any representations that may be made. ("Neue Freie Presse.")
Dreyfus.
The fate of this man holds the Jews in suspense as the fate of whole nations otherwise does. When elsewhere the hatred of the Jews proved stronger than the law, the Jews took note of the narrowness of peasant judges and consoled themselves. But Paris is the heart of civilisation. The French are chivalrous and humane. The whole of Jewry's little bit of power laboured feverishly. And then, after all, this fall from grace of justice, because it concerned a Jew. The march of truth for Dreyfus, which Zola so proudly announced, became a supplicant's pilgrimage to ministerial palaces, and a miserable pardon put a provisional end to the brutality against an innocent man. A very few, who are friends of Dreyfus because they are enemies of his clerical enemies, have now reopened the Affair and carried through a fresh revision, probably with a favourable issue. The masses no longer demonstrate; antisemitism has spent its fury. But in France, as everywhere, it has grown quiet and deep. A strong Government can venture there, as in Germany too, to snatch a single victim from it, the more so when its friends demand it. But the spirit of the masses will know, as everywhere, how to indemnify itself. — Herewith the reports:
Paris, 24th December. At to-day's sitting of the consultative Revision Commission the reading of Mercier's report was continued. It gives a very detailed account of all the phases of the Dreyfus trial, and supports the motion to assent to ex-Captain Dreyfus's application for revision in particular by the following three new facts, which in the sense of the law appear as grounds for revision:
First, Gribelin, the well-known archivist, has testified that his evidence before the court-martial at Rennes, in which he asserted that he had surprised Colonel Picquart at the War Ministry studying the secret dossier on the carrier-pigeons with the advocate Leblois, was false. Picquart, he says, had before him only the administrative carrier-pigeon dossier, to which he was entitled, since he was obliged to obtain the advice of a lawyer on the administrative dossier. Colonel Henry, he says, had induced Gribelin to give this false evidence. Among the grounds for revision enumerated in the law there is cited in a prominent place: "False testimony given in the earlier proceedings."
The second ground for revision is the letter of the late German Ambassador, Prince Münster, to Josef Reinach, in which Prince Münster expressly declares that Schwartzkoppen had assured him that he had been in communication with Walsin-Esterhazy and had never known Dreyfus. This "letter" was not known at the time of the trial at Rennes; it therefore appears as the new documentary evidence required by the law for a revision, which in this case is of particular importance, since the court-martial too condemned Dreyfus as the author of the bordereau. The Court of Cassation had indeed established in the earlier proceedings that Walsin-Esterhazy had written the bordereau and carried it to the embassy in question. But since the court-martial of Rennes nevertheless condemned Dreyfus on account of the bordereau, the letter of Prince Münster comes into consideration as a new piece of evidence that the military judges erred.