Die Welt · Vol. VII, Separate Edition · 26 August 1903
14printed page
scan 14 of 16
Facsimile · scan 14 of 16
Scan of p. 14
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 14 — "Die Welt" — Special Edition. No. 3

(continued from page 13)

…monides could not do without — which were thenceforth to take the place of the free exercise of their national personality; and so too the rotten flesh by which Ben Sakkai deceived the Jewish guards with the smell of a corpse has proved itself the omen of that ill odour in which his unhappy people was thenceforth to stand in foreign lands. Ben Zakkai did indeed save Judaism, but at what a price! And even his spiritualisation of the Jewish religion was no complete work. Judaism was not, through him, loosed from the soil, as it was through the disciples of Christianity.

Although in the fifty years after the destruction of the Jewish State Judaism won a multitude of adherents in the East, in Asia Minor, and especially in Rome, the religion nevertheless threw away this opportunity of forfeiting its national basis. Whether from political prudence or from inner conviction — enough, Ben Sakkai let the ancient territorial conceptions stand, only that they took on cultural forms. Thus the stony Ghettos, in pilpulistically pious poems, thanked the good God for the gathering in of ears of corn that had never swayed in the field, and for fruits that had never blossomed. The former Temple sacrifices were replaced by prayers, but only for the time, until the Temple should be rebuilt. The conception of actual blood-sacrifices was by no means blotted out; such sacrifices were merely put off to later times. Since it possessed no gold, Israel was to pay in paper. But an unlimited circulation of paper, as is well known, produces unhealthy conditions, and the moment is now come when Judaism must gain a sound basis if it is not to go bankrupt. It is the merit of Ben Zakkai that he, as it were, Palestinised the prayer-book and kept alive the hope of a native soil; but Judaism cannot live for ever upon withered leaves and the husks of reality. Agriculture was converted into culture. This archæological policy, however, will receive its historical justification only when we shall once more have converted culture into agriculture.

Even the Hebrew language, which surely forms the chief organ of Jewish culture to-day, would undoubtedly have to become artificial, — except where, as in Palestine, it is the real language of daily intercourse, — were not the Hebrew journalists reviving it afresh by the introduction of neologisms. Had there been a country whose language was Hebrew, that language would differ as deeply from the language of the Bible as the language of Byron from Chaucer, or of Schiller from that of the mediæval Minnesingers. To speak classical Hebrew to-day means to speak dead Hebrew. In the present stage of Zionism, culture can produce only hothouse flowers, not such as unfold in the open air.

Who could venture to predict how, upon a Jewish soil, the "Ruah Hakodesch" will move, what the Bathkol will proclaim? From the economic standpoint — and I may here consider no other standpoint — I would remark that it is no mere waste of strength when our youth creates a culture which, owing to the profound changes that the attainment of a Jewish native soil would bring about, must in a short time become obsolete. The splintering of forces even signifies a weakening of the endeavour to acquire this very soil, which would after all be the surest and swiftest idea for creating that Jewish culture after which they so eagerly strive. We suffer a further economic loss when our forces are set directly against one another in a war of cultures. The dispute over which cultural tendency is to prevail upon the native soil which we have yet to strive to win — this dispute, which endangers our cause altogether, reminds me of the poor pedlar in the "Thousand and One Nights," who in his thoughts sells his first basket of porcelain and with every further basket disposed of sees his profit rise. Now he dreams himself so deeply into his happy vision that he reaches the point where, in possession of a splendid palace and of many beauteous houris, he quarrels with his favourite, the Sultan's daughter, and, in giving her a push, overturns the basket too, which holds all his dreams of wealth and glory.

From an economic point of view, even a part of our religious orthodoxy, which is indeed the culture of the pious, likewise means a loss of strength, however highly its moral worth may be rated. When children who in a Jewish land would as a matter of course already be lisping Hebrew are artificially taught the Hebrew language, that means overburdening human beings. Indeed, all this exotic activity within Judaism may be characterised economically by the supplying of convicts or hospital patients with kosher food. Upon a Jewish soil the food would, as a matter of course, be kaschir. Our cultural work, like the Kaschire, is an artificial product in a milieu that is by nature very trefa. Here the plainest difficulty confronts us — that of creating Jewish-cultural milieus in places where only a minority of the inhabitants is Jewish. It is all the more difficult since the Jews wish, after all, to enjoy all the cultural and political advantages of their foreign surroundings. For, unlike our Israelitish half-brothers the Gipsies, we do not live outside the bounds of the civilised world, but in the very midst of it. There are indeed countless Jews who, through standing so long upon their heads, have so far lost the natural point of view that they see everything upside down, and when one tells them that they ought to stand upon their feet like men, they cry out: Oh, how unnatural! These are the people who have so far forfeited their natural standpoint that they rather regard it as an advantage for the Jews that the choice among so many fatherlands stands open to them, while they seemingly need take upon themselves the responsibilities of none.

This recalls a Talmudic figure of the 3rd century, that of Jochanan bar Napacha, the most eminent of the Amoraim, who had lost father and mother in his earliest childhood and used to say that he ought really to be grateful for this misfortune, since it would not have been possible for him to fulfil the duties of filial love strictly and exactly as the Law requires. Or will you perhaps permit me, since I am after all confined to the theme of charity, to compare the argument that it is better for us to possess no land of our own, since we then have nothing to administer and nothing to lose, with the one advanced by a child of my own creation, the King of Schnorrers. This illustrious man, so proud of his long line of ancestors, was asked for his daughter's hand by his satellite ad latus Jankele. But the King of Schnorrers had discovered that Jankele worked at times, and was alarmed at the thought of entrusting his daughter's happiness to a man whose income rested upon so insecure a basis as work. Work, he remarked, was never secure; there were times of ebb and then again times of activity. Branches of trade would rise and decline again. Even wealth was