Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 39 · 25 September 1903
10printed page
scan 10 of 20
Facsimile · scan 10 of 20
Scan of p. 10
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 10. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 39.

The "Daily Chronicle" (London) devotes long and detailed articles to the Congress, in which it takes up a position on the burning questions. Thus it says in an article of 26 August last: "Mount Zion or East Africa? That was the alternative put yesterday to the great Zionist Congress at Basle. We do not believe that a settlement in British East Africa was seriously proposed as a permanent substitute for Jerusalem. The Zionists remain true to their ideal of the return of a great part of the Jewish people to the Holy Land . . . British East Africa is not on the road to Zion; it has not the local and historical attraction of El-Arish on the Sinai Peninsula, but if a fertile and healthy district could be found in East Africa, it would be possible to live there, and life under British rule is happily different from life under Turkish or Russian. What sort of colonists the mass of the shamefully ill-treated Jews in Russia and Poland would make, if they settled as a body and worked for themselves, is another question, which was certainly taken into consideration before the proposal was made. But we do not doubt that the colony will quickly fill up if the Zionists, with their mighty number of members and sums of money, seriously accept the proposal."

In another article the same paper says: "In these conferences (concerning East Africa) it became clear to every observer that the Jew possesses the faculty of dreaming, and however he may otherwise appear to us, once he holds the blue-and-white Zionist flag he is devoted head and heart to his ideal. It must be said that through this offer (of England's) Zionism underwent a hard ordeal by fire and came forth from it clear and shining, strong and believing. No one had hitherto known the real depth of the Zionist ideal; every face at the Congress proved that the ideal has penetrated to the very marrow of these Jewish delegates."

After the adoption of the vote for the East Africa Commission the same paper wrote: "The acceptance of the English Government's offer at the Zionist Congress is not, as one might suppose, the sacrifice of the ideal to the pressing demands of hard reality. For East Africa is only a provisional home, although, as may well be possible, the Zionists may content themselves with it without realising the dreams of a final restoration of the nation in Palestine. It is an experiment which the Western Jew, who is for the most part content with his adopted nationality, wishes to make with his oppressed brethren of the East. But that does not yet mean that the dream of the restoration of Palestine has been abandoned. The need of a place of refuge for the homeless Jews, who cannot wait for the results of Zionism, was urgent, and the Congress rightly felt that it must not let such an opportunity pass by. It is curious that it was precisely the Russian delegates who opposed the proposal with the greatest bitterness; history, however, teaches that the best soil for enthusiasm is suffering and persecution. The British offer was made, as we surmise, for two reasons. The stream of Jewish immigration into England is not exactly a blessing for England, and yet England cannot divest herself of sympathy for the unhappy immigrants. At the same time there is a piece of land which is almost wholly uninhabited and suited to European colonisation. An energetic white population is needed to bring its hidden treasures to light . . . And if the enthusiastic Zionist sees in the scheme only a meagre substitute for the national home in Palestine, which is the highest dream of his people, still the prospect of a State administered by Israel itself for Israel must be agreeable to him, a thing which Judaism has not seen since the destruction of the Temple."

*

The London illustrated paper "Black and White," in its number of 12 September, carries an illustrated article on the East Africa question and holds that, whatever attitude one may wish to take towards Lord Lansdowne's policy in this matter, one must always also bear in mind the interests of British citizens. This is borne out by a letter from Mombasa, from Mr. W. D. Young, the well-known resident of Mombasa:

"To the few Britons who have settled in British East Africa and have spent all their goods and chattels in this beautiful adopted country, it has always seemed strange and painful that the Foreign Office has taken no definite steps to make our new possession known to the British people throughout the whole world, and has devised no means of facilitating the colonisation of great stretches of this fertile land by Great Britain's own children. At the outset it was supposed that the Home Government would hold back only until the Uganda Railway should be completed, and in default of a better explanation we inclined to this view.

Now, however, the Uganda Railway has for some time been a fait accompli, and when the settlers urged the Government to take decisive steps to help the inhabitants of the country — then the Foreign Office did take a step, but in a quite unexpected direction.

The scheme of handing the country over to alien Jews struck us like a heavy blow. It would be so great a misfortune that one cannot believe at all in the carrying out of the scheme. The Foreign Office will meet with the unanimous protest of Great Britain's own subjects in British East Africa. It has been said that the very name of East Africa is already painful to the British taxpayer. The building of the Uganda Railway line swallowed up six million pounds, and the less the public at home read about this country, the better. That is decidedly an injustice and a deplorable attitude. There ought to be a change, and quickly. If we take into consideration the whole country from the coast to the Victoria Nyanza, only the first 200 miles on the one side and the shore of the great lake are unfit for the British colonist and labourer. From Makinda, 207 miles in the interior of the country, and for about 400 miles farther, the region is indescribably beautiful. The fertility of the soil is wonderful and the climatic conditions are excellent in every respect. There is not the least exaggeration in this assertion. It is in truth an ideal country, which Great Britain ought to keep for her own subjects. Colonists from Australia and South Africa have come to East Africa to explore the country; they were specialists in cattle-breeding and dairying; they travelled through the whole country and declared it better than all the countries known to them: but the amount of 'red tape' and the land laws compelled them to seek other fields of colonisation. When the Briton at home reads about the little-known parts of Africa, something like the following picture involuntarily presents itself to him: 'A boundless plain of sand, a scorching sun, a single palm, a lion and a negro!' But in reality it is far from being so.

British East Africa is one of the most beautiful countries in the world. Well wooded and watered, with grassy plains miles long on which countless herds of game graze. Apart from the coast and lake districts, the heat is not at all so tremendous, and in comparison with the plains of India these localities are even good. From Makindu to Nairobi and over the Mau Escarpment into the Loudiane plains (which Sir Harry Johnston calls the plains of Paradise), the climate is an ideal one. In the matter of agriculture the possibilities are unlimited, as regards quantity as well as quality and variety. There is nothing that could not grow in this country. The few colonists here grow the best potatoes in the world, and an organisation is being planned to secure the South African markets for this product, and it is South Africa that is striving for this. Some time ago the British cotton manufacturers organised an expedition to explore the cotton-producing countries. Why did they send no expedition to British East Africa?

They could have the finest cotton here, as much as they wished. During Mr. Chamberlain's visit last December he expressed the view that British East Africa could stand unrivalled in the production of grain and cotton. To the outsider it would appear that the Protectorate is governed directly from home, and that the local authorities have no power to enact laws on their own authority or to grant concessions which would further the welfare of the country. His Majesty's Commissioner, Sir Charles Eliot, is decidedly popular and esteemed in the country. And if the powers granted him left him a free hand, British East Africa would soon be on the ri-