No. 39. — "Die Welt" — Page 9.
(continued from page 8)
…settle as colonists, under the ordinary conditions, in some uninhabited district of the Protectorate. It would, however, be unwise on the part of the Foreign Office to depart from the standpoint of neutrality and to assist in the founding of a semi-independent, alien Jewish State or commonwealth in East Africa or Uganda. Such experiments are permissible in immense territories such as the United States or Brazil, but they are dangerous in a confined country like East Africa, which is already in part inhabited by warlike native tribes. I shall never forget the end of Dr. Hertzka's insane "Freeland" scheme in East Africa. The colonists who had resolved to remain became lawless freebooters, who robbed the natives, provoked wars among them, exterminated the game in defiance of the laws, and caused Sir Arthur Hardinge, then High Commissioner for East Africa, the greatest possible annoyance. Happily one of the worst of them was killed by an inspired rhinoceros. But the negro population naturally holds the British Government responsible for the conduct of all white men within the British Protectorate.
The "Times" is altogether hostile towards Zionism in general and towards the East African scheme in particular. As early as 28 August it wrote in a leading article: "We do not wish to speak slightingly of the men who have devoted themselves to the somewhat indefinite cause of Zionism. Even if they do not attain precisely the goal towards which they strive, they already do their people good by bringing great masses together for noble ends, by coming to their aid with far-sighted policy, and by defying persecution with steadfastness. Optimism, it is said, is a fundamental trait of the Jewish character. But it must be an optimism heightened to delusion that ignores the enormous difficulties which stand in the way of Zionism. The financial difficulties are very serious . . . . . And then there are political difficulties as well. Many are for Palestine, but that is in the possession of Turkey . . . The natural migration is from poor countries to richer ones. Every scheme to reverse this relation must fail . . . If the chosen State is to be somewhere in Africa, the Jews will gravitate towards Cape Town, Durban or Mombassa, perhaps even to Egypt . . . They will seek out the centres of trade and of wealth . . . An experiment may well be made in East Africa, even though it will meet with great opposition, but Zionism had better cease, perhaps for ever . . . ."
In its leading article of the 7th inst. the "Times" again turns against Zionism and against Zangwill's arguments. It looks very optimistically upon the future of the Jews in England and says: "The pious Jews who dwell in England remain sectaries, just as the Quakers are; outside their sectarianism they have the same interests as their other fellow-citizens in the world-wide Empire. A small Jewish State in East Africa, restricted in its sphere of activity by the English Government, but in many respects self-governing, would prosper or fail according as it succeeded in bringing Jewish abilities to bear there. Uganda would offer no sufficient scope for talent and enterprise . . . It would be very desirable that they (the poor Jews) should be helped to emigrate to some country, Uganda or elsewhere, but it is very doubtful whether one ought to help to promote a mass emigration and to set up a separate little State or a separate commonwealth. Were there unanimity of opinion within the people itself, the experiment with the State might be ventured, despite the doubtful prospects of success; but since this unanimity is lacking, the essential element of success is lacking. The readiness of the British Government to procure land in Uganda might be turned to account for a 'legitimate' and less ambitious attempt at colonisation . . ."
Mr. Lucien Wolf replies in the "Times" of the 10th inst. to Zangwill's criticism:
Mr. Zangwill is mistaken when he explains my hostility to the East African scheme by saying that I have "not the faintest understanding of the new forces which are developing within Judaism." It is precisely because I have recognised all too clearly the bearing of the new Zionism, because I feel that its doctrine harbours a great danger for the Jewish people, that I have raised my voice against the scheme. What is its doctrine? Mr. Zangwill carefully avoided formulating it throughout the whole of his eloquent address of Saturday, but the Zionists at Basle were not so reticent. Here it is in a few words, as it was pronounced by Dr. Max Nordau amid the applause of the Congress on 24 August: "I claim it as a great merit of Zionism that it has put an end to this hypocrisy of contentment and this comedy of gratitude . . . We are not content. We hold a fundamental change in our situation to be a vital necessity. After the humiliating experiences we have had with our attempts at rapprochement with other peoples, we have bethought ourselves of ourselves, and we wish to live out our lives after our own fashion, in our own right, upon our own soil."
If that were mere rhetoric, I should attach no importance to it. In the heat of battle many a man says much that it never even occurs to him to carry out when the hour of responsibility strikes. But the Zionists' deeds are just as senseless as their words. They have obtained from His Majesty's Government a promise to further the scheme of a colonisation whereby a Jewish settlement would be founded in a British colony on the basis of self-government, "with," to quote Mr. Zangwill, "Jewish Home Rule, Jewish nationality and a Jewish Governor." I can hardly conceive a greater setback in Jewish history than this scheme. It is not unreasonable that Jews who are denied their due and rightful place in the national life of the peoples, as in Russia or Roumania, and against whom the more liberal countries, too, are being closed, should dream of the revival of an independent Jewish State on the hallowed soil of Palestine. If I have sometimes poured a cold-water douche upon it, it was for the reason that I doubted the practicability of this dream and, in view of the terrible consequences of the fiasco of Sabbatai Zevi in the 17th century, did not wish to be an accomplice in a disappointment which must surely bring demoralisation in its train. But I have always maintained that if, through some political upheaval in the East of Europe, it had become possible to secure the Holy Land for a Jewish State under the protection of the Powers, then the entire Jewish people, despite the difficulty, would be bound to strain all its forces in order to settle the unassimilated Jewish population of Europe in such a State and to let it prosper politically and socially. That, however, is not the scheme which lies before us. The starting-point of the present-day Zionists is not the political situation of the unemancipated Jewish communities of Russia and Roumania, but a capitulation before the calumnies of the antisemites . . ." After he has put forward the lengthy arguments of the theorists and practitioners of assimilation, which culminate in the sentence: what will our Christian fellow-citizens say, he concludes as follows: "Now if there were any prospect of making the East African colony the seat of the political independence of all unemancipated Jews, with an emigration en gros into a legalised home within a measurable time, I should not be so disquieted; but that is not the case. The whole substitute is that some 800 Jews — not from Russia — are to be settled in the neighbourhood of Uganda at a cost of 240,000 pounds sterling. Can there be greater levity? I have been told that my task is a thankless one, since the Zionists are idealists. I am already weary of this song of idealism . . . In the present scheme of the Zionists there is nothing of this idealism (which rests upon reality) . . . I therefore believe very earnestly that the sound sense and the public opinion of the Jewish people will not be on its side . . ." (We hope that Mr. Lucien Wolf will continue his fight against Zionism. Through his arguments, which positively provoke every thinking Jew, he is developing into the most vehement agitator for the movement. The Editors.)
