Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 34 · 21 August 1903
31scan
of 36
Facsimile · scan 31 of 36
Scan of scan 31
English · AI translation, checked against the German

(continued from page 30)

...tinue on the way, and to them one can also say everything. So it was in our intention when we convened this Congress, and we believed that we should have nothing else to report than the breakdown of negotiations and the failure of long-prepared attempts. Things, however, turned out somewhat otherwise.

Since we were assembled here for the fifth time, I have again twice had the honour of being summoned to Constantinople by His Majesty the Sultan. Both times, however, in February as in August 1902, the negotiations remained without result. I could, of course, enter into nothing that would have been incompatible with our Basle Programme; in particular, a scattered, disconnected colonisation in various parts of the Turkish Empire could not satisfy our national needs. From all these arduous negotiations it emerged only that His Majesty the Sultan continues to preserve a friendly disposition towards the Jewish people. This is certainly gratifying and valuable, but practically it brings us no further. Since, then, the kindly disposition of the Sovereign is given, as well as the undoubted advantages which the Turkish Empire would derive from it, the obstacle had to be sought in the attitude of the principal Powers interested in the East, notably Russia. For from Germany we had no opposition to expect, after the unforgotten sympathy which the German Emperor manifested towards us. When in the year 1898 I had the honour of being received in Jerusalem with a Zionist deputation, His Majesty assured our movement of his goodwill. An Emperor's word is not to be twisted or quibbled over. From England, too, no hostility was to be feared, and events which I am now about to report confirm this.

After the failure of the last negotiations in Constantinople, and in view of the growing distress, we were obliged to seek other ways. Accordingly, in October of last year, I put myself in communication with several members of the British Cabinet and submitted to them the proposal to grant us a land concession for the Sinai Peninsula, in order that we might found a settlement there for our people. Both the Ministers, to whom I should like here to express my warmest thanks, and the high officials of the British Government competent in this matter received me with the greatest goodwill and courtesy. It was intimated to me that, as the territory in view was Egyptian, it would be necessary to negotiate directly with the Egyptian Government; but the English Government generously placed its recommendation at my disposal and expressed to its representative in Egypt, Lord Cromer, its hope that the plan would be taken into favourable consideration by him and by the advisers of His Highness the Khedive. The British Government suggested to us that, as a preparatory step, we should arrange for the dispatch of a commission of experts, which was to examine the tract of land as to its fitness for settlement and the prospects of its colonisation. In order to obtain the consent of the competent Egyptian authorities to the dispatch of the commission and their support for it, our representative, Mr. Greenberg, furnished with letters of recommendation from the English Foreign Office to the Egyptian Government, proceeded to Egypt at the end of October.

Lord Cromer and the Egyptian Minister for Foreign Affairs received him very kindly, and after some negotiation gave their consent to the dispatch of the commission. They also permitted a representative of the Egyptian Survey Department to join the commission as a member. The commission was thereupon formed and consisted of Messrs.:

Engineer Kessler, Architect Marmorek, Colonel Goldsmid, Engineer Stephens, Professor Laurent, Dr. S. Soskin, Dr. Hillel Joffe, and the Egyptian Government representative Mr. Humphreys.

The commission arrived in Egypt at the end of January and set out for the Sinai Peninsula at the beginning of February. Meanwhile our representative, Mr. Greenberg, left England and went again to Egypt in order to submit to Lord Cromer and the Egyptian Government the draft of a charter for a tract of land on the Sinai Peninsula. After long negotiations our negotiator received from the Egyptian Government a letter in which it declared its agreement with the principle of the proposed charter. This provides for Jewish self-government for the tract of land in question and grants municipal rights for the whole of the territory conceded, on the condition that the commission dispatched should make a favourable report, one which would convince the Government that the settlement of the Peninsula is practicable.

The commission returned to Egypt at the beginning of March, and I travelled there myself in order to meet it. I submitted various proposals to Lord Cromer and the Egyptian Government, but, as I was obliged to return to Europe, I entrusted the further negotiations to a member of the commission that had been sent out.

Protracted negotiations followed, which, however, as I have to report with regret, had the result that the Egyptian Government declared itself not in a position to go further into the matter, since the expert opinion was to the effect that it was impossible to supply the Pelusian plain sufficiently with water, and that therefore the settlement of El-Arisch or of any other part of the Peninsula could not take place. When the members of the British Government with whom I had previously been in communication had learned of the expert advice given to the Egyptian Government and of the decisions to which it found itself compelled, they at once proposed to me, in place of the former, the grant of another territory for the purpose of Jewish colonisation.

The new territory has not the historical, poetic-religious and Zionist value which the Sinai Peninsula would still have possessed; but I do not doubt that the Congress, as the representative of the Jewish masses, would receive this new offer too with the warmest gratitude. The proposal signifies an autonomous Jewish settlement in East Africa with a Jewish administration, a Jewish local government and a Jewish chief official at its head, all, of course, under British sovereign supervision. When this proposal was made, I did not feel justified, in view of the condition of Jewry and the necessity of finding at once some means of improving the situation as far as possible, in doing anything else than obtaining permission to submit the proposal to the Congress. In order, however, that the matter should possess a sufficiently tangible interest for us all, it was necessary to bring the proposal into a form which would have regard to our national aspirations, so dear to us all. Our representative therefore conducted for some time detailed negotiations with the members of the British Cabinet and with the heads of departments, which made favourable progress.

I should not wish to anticipate the views of the Congress as to the policy which the Zionist movement intends to pursue towards these proposals; but although, as a matter of course, the Jewish people can have no other final goal than Palestine, and although, whatever the fate of the proposal may be, our views