Page 10 — "Die Welt" — No. 21
(continued from page 9)
…in a position to lay before you the debates of this Council of Ministers upon Baron Hirsch's proposals at the founding of the "Ica." Listen to the Russian historian, whom I cautiously abridge.
The plan for the emigration of the Russian Jews to America, which had been laid before the Government by Baron Hirsch at the beginning of the year 1900, appeared to it the best solution of the Jewish question, although doubts were expressed at the time as to its practicability. This project pleased government circles all the more because their own attempts to solve the question in one way or another had remained without result. As the Minister of Finance, Bunge, set forth, the attempts of the Russian Government — to extend or to restrict the liberties of the Jews — moved in a magic circle. Everything it might undertake brought Jewry sometimes joy, sometimes sorrow, but never anything good for the Russian-Christian population.
The Jewish Question — a Christian Question.
Let us pause for a moment at this passage. The Jewish question is thus for Russia a Christian question: how the poor Christians might be helped! In our East End agitation, too, we did not understand this. Our Parliamentary Commission sits not to help the Jews, but to help the Christians. When, therefore, the "Ica" speaks of the solution of the Jewish question in Russia, let us not forget what this question really means: how the Christians can be freed from us; the Jews are a burden to Russia. When Russia pocketed her share of Poland, which she did in three successive instalments, she found millions of Jews among the spoil; she had to take the bad with the good. In the year 1888 the Governor of Kamenetz-Podolsk declared in his annual report that their emigration from Russia would be very desirable, to which the Tsar appended the remark, "and indeed very advantageous." In the year 1890 the Prefect of Police of Odessa proposed that Jewish emigrants be denied the right of returning to Russia after the lapse of a certain time. The Tsar's answer was: "Good!" It is therefore easy to understand, says the Russian historian, with what interest the Government received the proposals of the "Ica" in London to help 3 1/4 million Jews to emigrate in the course of 25 years. For a beginning the "Ica" contemplated sending 25,000 Jews to the Argentine in the year 1892. (As we remember, in the year 1903 there are 4274 there in all.) Thereupon Admiral Tchischatcheff proposed to profit by this stroke of fortune and to organise their emigration in drafts exceeding the annual increase of the Jews. He accordingly moved that the "Ica" be paid 5 R 84 Kop. for every emigrating Jew, on condition that 130,000 Jews be brought to emigrate in the first year, or 650,000 Jews in 5 years. The payments were to be taken every 5 years from the kosher-meat tax. I will not trouble you either with the debate upon this motion or upon an amendment which the Minister of the Interior, J. J. Durnovo, moved to it: in case the "Ica" did not get a fixed number of Jews out, to break with it. The motion fell. But in the same year, 1892, the Minister of the Interior, in agreement with the Minister of Finance, used the kosher-meat fund to help individual emigrants to leave Russia. In such haste was Pharaoh to let the Jews go that red tape was disregarded. Their passports were flung to them without fees, and all the consequences of their evasion of military service were remitted.
Russia and the "Ica."
Owing to the protest of Minister Witte that this might lead to greater losses of revenue, the fact that emigration was to be made as easy as possible for the Jewish emigrants was communicated confidentially to the "Ica" alone. In case such emigrants returned to Russia, the cost of their resettlement was to be borne by the "Ica," which for this purpose was to deposit 100,000 roubles with the Minister of the Interior and keep it constantly made up. In case such repatriations should gain the upper hand, the Government was to put a stop to the activity of the "Ica." On this condition the "Ica" was permitted by the Tsar to begin its activity. This, then, is the situation in Russia. Not a Jewish question, but a problem of the Christians. We are not the bearers, we are the disturbers of the peace. Whether this view is right or wrong, whether we do not give the nations far more than we receive from them, whether Russia, were she to grant her Jews that precious life-blood of trade, free circulation throughout the whole Empire, would not increase her power and feed her starving peasants — that is another question. It is enough that she refuses to adopt this view, that she does not need us, that what she needs is a unity of Church, State, language and blood, which we disturb like others of her races of alien faith and tributary condition.
Russia Wants to be Rid of the Jews.
So far is Russia from needing us that she is ready to pay 12 shillings a head to be rid of us. And how may a people of our strength and of our ancient pride accept so inhuman a position — of thrusting itself upon a people that does not want it, of flinging itself upon everyone's neck and crying: "My brother, I too am a Russian, I too am a Frenchman, I too am a Roumanian"? In France we hear "Down with the Jews!" and in Roumania "Out with the Jews!" Even England and America are beginning to cry: "Thou art no brother, thou art a stranger!" So long as a man has a sound limb he must not beg, and so long as there is a spot on earth, be it even a desert, where we could build ourselves a home, it is our duty to build a home there. Eat onions, so long as it is under thine own roof, says the Talmud. He who has no land is no man (Man!). And an English song says the like.
The good Prince Charlie, the English Pretender, of the house of the Stuarts, wrote on a sheet of paper which is preserved at Windsor: "To live and not to live is worse than to die." That is our situation. I would rather see us die, and there were an end of it.
The Mission of the Jews.
I thank Heaven that at least ten tribes have been lost. That we have a spiritual mission to fulfil among the nations is on a par with the pretension that the "Ica" is a colonisation society. Last week I was at the opera, where the boxes were filled with rich Jews, and I thought of Baron Hirsch's saying: "When a Jew is rich he ceases to be a Jew." The only mission we accomplish is errors. What our preachers and teachers preach is that the mission of Israel is one of submission. By doing nothing they do away with our own ideal, namely the mission of peace and brotherhood over the whole earth that has been talked into us. Let a war break out, and we are the ver-