Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 21 · 22 May 1903
11printed page
scan 11 of 20

No. 21 — "Die Welt" — Page 11

(continued from page 10)

…most hated instigators of the war. The poor people in Kishineff tried to save themselves by setting Russian icons in their windows. That is our history in a nutshell. In moments of danger we hoist the enemy's flag. And nothing is wanting on the way — the icon-sheltered of Kishineff are people specially chosen for crucifixion.

Jewish Nationalism.

It is said that Zionism is opposed to pure Jewish principles, contrary to the principles of our greatest prophets. Why? There were never such nationalists as our prophets — or else there were never such internationalists. They merely perceived that internationalism must have its roots in nationalism, that there can be no brotherhood of nations unless the people are brothers. Before I can have a brother, he must wish to have me for a brother. It always takes two to be brothers. Nationality is the personality of a people. When we have a land of our own, we can begin to talk of fraternisation. It seems rather suspicious from a people without one. It is like a schnorrer talking of Socialism. A fox that had lost its tail would be better able to convince its brothers of the disadvantages of a tail than in the days when it still bore its proud brush. "Be rather the tail among lions than the head among foxes," says the Rabbi. Be rather the tail among nations than the head of gipsies. We are at peace, but a proposal for general disarmament would carry more weight if it came from Germany than if it came from Monaco. If we wish the nations to listen to us, we must above all bring them to respect us. To fulfil the ideals of our prophets we must have a soil of our own. To be able to preach them we must have a platform of our own. To show the world the pattern of a State, we must have a land of our own at our disposal; but we cannot do so in a land where, at the peril of our lives or, what is worse still, of our position in society, we must hang out our neighbours' icons. It is not as though the anti-Zionists were really international, really cosmopolitans; on the contrary, they are local patriots and chauvinists.

Two Measures.

I do not complain of it. It is impossible to belong to two peoples, and the Jews of each country naturally choose the people among whom they live. It is said that the Jews have grown accustomed through 18 centuries to belonging to two peoples, but that is an illusion. So long as they were kept, bodily and spiritually, in the ghettos, they belonged to one people only, their own. As soon as they were released from the prison that sheltered them, they were absorbed by the stronger, richer people and became assimilated in the course of three generations, even where they retained the institution of intermarriage among themselves. It is absurd of the anti-Zionists to preach cosmopolitanism. Mr. Claude Montefiore delivers British war sermons; his sister Ms. Lucas writes a pretty patriotic poem, "Mother England," which is sung in Jewish schools. Nationalism, to be sure, is low and narrow-hearted when it is a question of "Mother Zion," but when it is a question of "Mother England" — ah, that is another matter.

Mother England and Mother Zion.

"For the Jews have heart and hand for our 'Mother England,' and both are thine to-day and for all their life." It is a fine emotion, and England deserves it of us, and our lives are at her disposal. But I do not find this poem higher than our old sentiments: "If I forget thee, O Jerusalem, let my right hand wither." An old Jewish legend makes Jeremiah, after the destruction of the Temple, see a lonely woman sitting on the summit of a mountain, clad in black, her hair unbound. Jeremiah approaches her and asks her: "Who art thou?

She answers: "Knowest thou me not? I am Mother Zion." Five-and-twenty centuries have passed, and still she weeps for her children. But only in the last generations does she see herself cast off by her own children, does she hear her own little ones singing: "Mother England!" Ah, how her poor mind is distracted when she hears some singing "Rule Britannia," others the "Marseillaise," and yonder the "Wacht am Rhein." The one song that lies nearest is the song which we Zionists sing at our meetings, "Hatikwah," the song of the national hope. With three things the word "National" is most particularly associated in England: there is the national bard Shakespeare, and his prophet is Mr. Israel Gollancz; then the Dictionary of National Biography, whose editor is Mr. Sidney Lee; and the National Theatre, "Drury Lane," and its director is Mr. Arthur Collins.

Jewish Despisers of the Jews.

Jews say we could not have a land of our own, but I do not believe that the nationalist talents of these gentlemen would dry up altogether in, say, Palestine. For several generations only a single holiday has been added to the British calendar, and that is Primrose Day. British Imperialism was created by a Jewish statesman, and I do not wholly despair that we are capable of producing fit leaders, even for a country like ours.

While we say that we cannot live together under our own rule, that we therefore stand lower than the Red Indians or the Esquimaux, than the ants and bees, everyone says of us: "Good Heavens, if only these people would hold together, if only they would become conscious of their own power!"

We are held to be a clever people, but that is a calumny. We are clever as individuals, but as a people we stand lower than the Hottentots. If there is one thing of which many a Jew thinks more than he should, it is the Tachlith. "What does it bring in?" he asks. If there is anything the Jewish people has forgotten — it is the Tachlith.

Fleeing from one land to another, putting things off from one day to the next. A good part of our charity consists in sending poor people from Manchester to London, in order then to send them back from London to Manchester. This game of shuttlecock seems to amuse our Jewish Board of Guardians. It lends it the appearance of great activity.

Assimilationist Charity.

A land brings responsibility, no doubt. One would have to fight for it. But now you are the conscripts in Russia, in Germany, in the whole world. In the battle of Kishineff alone your victims, even according to the official figures, were 45 killed, 424 wounded; 700 houses and 600 shops were plundered. The loss of property exceeds 100,000 pounds sterling, which we have to make good. And although I give my contribution, I give it unwillingly, because it is stolen from Zionism and because I feel that the