Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 21 · 22 May 1903
9printed page
scan 9 of 20

No. 21 — "Die Welt" — Page 9

My "unofficial" report shows how fantastic is the hope of the "Ica" of solving the Jewish question in Russia. Officials in uniform mingled openly with the rioters, whose leaders belonged to the best classes, and who included the "intelligentsia" and even students of theology.

The police arrested only Jews who sought to defend themselves. The police and the soldiers took part in the plundering. Two lieutenants violated and killed a Jewess before the eyes of their soldiers. Where the Jews tried to hide themselves by displaying Christian icons, the police drove them out, where they were maltreated and crucified. The Jewish carters who dared to carry the wounded to the hospitals were butchered — in a country which belongs to the Red Cross League. The Governor telegraphed to St. Petersburg on Sunday morning for instructions, but stopped all private despatches thither. On Monday morning, after horrible scenes had been enacted, a Jewish deputation succeeded in reaching the Governor and demanding of him effective measures of protection. He answered lightly that he could do nothing, for he had as yet received nothing from St. Petersburg. They begged to be allowed to remain in the courtyard. He ordered that they be driven out of it. The answer from St. Petersburg came only on Monday evening. In the meantime the fashionable people of Kishineff went out driving to look at the sport. The Christian president of the Chamber of Artisans in Kishineff expressly defended the rioters, on the ground that they had believed they were acting in accordance with orders from St. Petersburg. In the official report itself we read that the events at Kishineff produced disquiet among the Jews in many other parts of the Empire and led them to form societies for their own protection; the Minister of the Interior declares the formation of such self-defence societies inadmissible. That is the country within whose borders the "Ica" hopes to solve the Jewish question. It can be solved there very simply, for, as Madame Nowikoff very kindly told me lately, it is there a religious question, not, as elsewhere, an economic one.

Another Solution of the Jewish Question.

Let the Jews become Christians.

That was all. It seemed to me that there was another solution, that the Russians should become Christians. But both, my solution and hers, are equally impracticable; one need only ask why the "Ica" shrinks from carrying out the policy expressed by Baron Hirsch. "Is there any hope of better days for the Jews in Russia?" asks Mr. Lucien Wolf. And the Baron answers: "None whatever!" None whatever, so long as Jews are Jews and Christians savages. None whatever, so long as every Easter brings back the terrible accusation of the Jewish crucifixion. And when I say: Then let the Russian Jews be brought to Palestine by the Hirsch millions, Mr. Wolf and Dr. Gaster declare this a policy of robbery. Robbery! Who will say that the real robbery was committed upon the martyred Jews of Kishineff, who might long since have been helped to emigrate! "What! Go under the Sultan's rule?" people cry. "What, remain under the rule of the Tsar?" I answer. "So you would treat with the murderer of Christians!" Mr. Wolf exclaims in alarm. Well, Mr. Wolf may quietly leave the Christians to look after themselves. Lord Landsdowne said on the same day in the House of Lords: "More murders have been committed by the Macedonian Committee than by the officials of the Turkish Government," and "Brutalities are the ordinary method of extreme political struggle in these unhappy lands."

Was Baron Hirsch against Zion?

But Baron Hirsch was not against Zion. I can only say that the facts do not speak for it. Against Zionism he was not hitherto, for at that time it was as yet unborn in its political shape. Mr. Lucien Wolf says he was against Palestine; Mr. Elkan Adler, who also knew him, says he merely feared that Palestine would fall back into Russian hands. A Christian, Mr. Fred Shaler of Falmouth, wrote to me that he himself had subscribed 100 pounds sterling towards the founding of the "Ica," on the assumption, which he had drawn from conversations with the Baron himself, whom he had met on board ship, that the Argentine was only a preparatory field for Palestine.

I might have doubted this story had he not sent me 50 pounds sterling with the words: "Let another attempt be made; perhaps it will succeed better, perhaps!" I bought him 50 shares of the Jewish Colonial Bank in the hope that this attempt would succeed better.

At this point we have also the testimony of our invaluable interviewer, Mr. Lucien Wolf. For in March 1892 the interviewer of the "New Moses" interviewed the "New Joshua," as he himself entitled his interview with our friend Colonel Goldsmid. The Colonel had just come from Buenos Aires. He regarded the Argentine as the necessary school for Palestine. "The Jewish question will never be solved," said Colonel Goldsmid, until a Jewish State guaranteed by the Powers is founded in the Land of Israel. Last not least, the fact has been brought to light by our friend Mr. Bentwich that Baron Hirsch signed a petition for Palestine which was laid before the Sultan.

Baron Hirsch's Doubts about the Argentine.

But even if appearances spoke for a different view on the part of Baron Hirsch, it would not have grieved me. For before he died he began to despair of the Argentine. He was not wedded for ever to one plan. Those who stood nearest to him said only that he was a man of restless imagination and effervescent spirit. Only one thing was fixed with him: his purpose to save Israel. He suffered unconsciously from the bad plan; he suffered consciously from the want of fellow-workers. Zionism gives him a good plan; Zionism gives him myriads of fellow-workers, the Zionist societies in every corner of the earth. He who wills the end wills the means. And there is no other help for saving Israel. The "Ica" sets itself the task of proving that Baron Hirsch would not have received modern Zionism with open arms. And all that it can prove is that he was against Europe, against Russia, against the country which contains the majority of the Jews.

Will the Russian Jews be Allowed to Emigrate?

But will Pharaoh let the Jews go? That, I admit, is a weighty objection. Fortunately I have here too a testimony, a testimony which proves that Baron Hirsch's plan was more comprehensive than I had believed, more comprehensive even than he expressed it to Lucien Wolf. You know that the Russian Government is directed by a Council of Ministers over which the Tsar presides. Autocratic as the Russian Government is, it has not yet attained the irresponsibility of the "Ica," and so the minutes of this Council of Ministers are published. Therefore I am