No. 7, Special Edition. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
...be, but we should also give free rein to private initiative.
Trietsch proposes industrial colonisation to us. Now such a colony might well produce goods, but for want of good commercial connections, capable workers, etc., it would not find the necessary market. Altogether, Herr Trietsch's whole plan aims at a small organisation, whereas Herr Oppenheimer has a great colonisation in view. The error in Herr Oppenheimer lies in his wishing to make the whole colonisation into an experimental rabbit.
Auerbach-Berne: For one thing, Herr Oppenheimer was plainly concerned in his report to show us how, under abnormal circumstances, one can work towards a single point and succeed in founding a commonwealth on a large scale. His object was to show how he would make out of a people of traders a people rooted in the soil, and how an old, degenerate people can be brought to new life. That Herr Trietsch will never achieve with an industrial colonisation. If Herr Trietsch would be so kind as to procure us drinking-water at El Arisch, we should be grateful to him; but if the drinking-water is not there, it would go ill with the whole affair.
Dr. Pasmanik thinks that the error of Oppenheimer's report lies in his wishing to make our people into an experimental rabbit. In my opinion, however, the main features of the plan are so framed as to inspire us with confidence that a settlement raised upon such a foundation is as firm as one founded by the old method.
I believe that Dr. Oppenheimer has shown that private initiative is to suffer no curtailment in the settlement, and when Dr. Pasmanik demands that the furtherance of private initiative is the main thing, Dr. Oppenheimer has sufficiently emphasised that ample room is given to it as well. I will not go further into the main features of Oppenheimer's plan. I believe it was necessary to point out to an opponent who had entirely neglected these great features that this was no opposition to arguments of such significance and scope as those which Oppenheimer brought forward.
Fritz Sontheimer: (A voice: I moved that the speaking time be shortened.
President Dr. Bodenheimer: Herr Sontheimer is the last. A vote on this point is therefore superfluous. I must express my regret that we are discussing this most important question, or one of the most important, at the Congress before so thin an attendance as is customary in the German Reichstag.
Fritz Sontheimer: Dr. Oppenheimer believes that we must begin the colonisation in Palestine with an agrarian colonisation; Herr Trietsch says, with an industrial one. I think that the truth lies in the middle. One must begin with agrarian colonisation, if only for the reason that industry is not well possible in a country where agriculture is too little represented. On the other hand, an industrial enterprise is also necessary alongside agriculture, so that agriculture may find a secure market.
The first and most important thing is always agriculture. I should therefore recommend that one begin with agriculture, but follow up with industrial development as soon as possible.
Further, I am of the opinion that one must hold unconditionally to co-operative working and must on no account permit private enterprise; if men are not equal there, the one will extend his private enterprise to the detriment of the other. Co-operation offers, after all, the greatest advantages in many respects, and precisely in a country that is being newly opened up. It is further to be seen to that the individual member of the co-operative receives as small an area as possible to cultivate. I think much more of intensive than of extensive methods. Private enterprise must cease; only co-operative working may exist.
President Dr. Bodenheimer: As no further speakers have put down their names, I close the debate on this point.
Trietsch: I wished to put right some points in which I have been misunderstood. I did not oppose Oppenheimer's great principles because I am in favour of them. For our particular case I preferred industrial colonisation. I said: one can begin industrially. I never said that El Arisch was good land.
Auerbach: "Gigantic successes," you said.
Trietsch: I am not prejudiced in favour of an El Arisch idea. Had you followed the development of my affairs, you would know that I have also already advocated Cyprus and other places. It has been objected .....
President Dr. Bodenheimer: But none of these are corrections of fact!
Trietsch: I only wished to make sure that I should not be misunderstood. Herzl's "Altneuland" was mentioned with praise.
Auerbach: Not by me, but by Dr. Oppenheimer.
Dr. Werner: Herr Trietsch, you have misunderstood Herr Auerbach. Herr Auerbach said that Dr. Herzl in "Altneuland" has the institutions arise entirely in Oppenheimer's sense. He was therefore not concerned to speak of the more or less extensive practical carrying-out of the reform of Altneuland.
Trietsch: That is something else. Then I have nothing further to remark.
Some business announcements are further made.
Close of the session: 1.10 o'clock.
Friday Afternoon Session.
Opening of the session: 4 o'clock.
President Dr. Herzl (greeted with applause upon his entrance): As the Standing Committee has not yet finished its list of nominations, I shall first have the organisation discussed. I further announce that the Austrian Landsmannschaft has had the Sixth Congress inscribed in the Golden Book. (Applause.)
Dr. Friedemann: The Organisation Committee did not consider itself competent, just before the close of the Congress, to undertake numerous and sweeping alterations of the Organisation Statute, but was of the opinion that a thorough revision must unconditionally be undertaken at a later time. We have confined ourselves to a few main points.
Nothing has been changed in the first nine paragraphs. In § 10, "the work of the Congress"
