Page 12 — "Die Welt" — Special Edition. No. 6
(continued from page 11)
…and every congregation can easily bear it. But in this way we shall have opened to the National Fund sources which will prove productive not merely for a time, but will flow constantly. The smallest and poorest communities will be the first; the great ones will at first hold back, it is true, but in the long run they will not be able to maintain a refusal, for otherwise they could not stand before the judgment of history.
If we adopt this proposal, we shall in the shortest time so set the National Fund on its feet that it can take up its functions.
Diesenhof (Jargon). To-day we have resolved that the National Fund shall remain for Palestine only. If the money of the National Fund is used at once for the land of Palestine, we shall be certain that it will find no other use. Some think it a crime to buy land before we have the public-legal security. On the contrary, however, it is better to acquire land even before that moment, because we shall then not be able to buy it all at once at a single stroke. It is therefore the first duty to purchase land in Palestine even now. At least half or ³/₄ of the money we ought to invest in this even now. The objection that one cannot yet buy because the National Fund is not yet legalised does not hold, because even after the legalisation of the National Fund in Europe its right to purchase land in Palestine is just as slight. By Turkish law it is, after all, only permitted to purchase land in a specific name. Then we can buy it even now in the name of the directors or of the board of supervisors of the Bank. That they are foreigners is no obstacle. While we are speaking here, this question is already being debated by the Congress in Palestine. We do not wish to wait until the board of supervisors resolves upon it; the whole Congress can take this resolution even now. Meanwhile the soil of Palestine is already being bought up by others. Of this we must think. The Jewish workers in Palestine who would like to have land and have none could best be supported in this way. We should therefore invest as much money as we now have at our free disposal in Palestinian land (Applause).
Dr. Pasmanik: If you wish to know how the National Fund Commission has worked, I could tell you how hard it was to bring it together. Now it has finally put forward a hastily cobbled-together motion which offers no solution. We should have to come to this: that a commission is not elected with an imperative mandate, that the commission also fulfils its duty completely, that it is a working commission.
As regards the question of the purpose, I believe that in this respect we should abide by the project. I, a decided Yes-sayer on the East Africa question, am an equally decided champion of the idea that land in Palestine should begin to be purchased at once (Lively applause). For me East Africa and Palestine are no contrast, no antithesis, but a synthesis. The one must be united with the other (Applause). In this respect I should insist that we ought not to wait until we possess 200,000 pounds, but should proceed at once to the purchase of land, and that we should not leave it to the A. C., but the Congress as such should resolve upon it. You must be clear about the import of your resolution. One cannot merely buy land. In Turkey it means at the same time: to colonise. For under Turkish legislation uncultivated land may be taken away from its owner. If you buy land in Turkey and do not cultivate it for a number of years, you must either begin to cultivate it or you give the official baksheesh. (Dissent). I mean to say by this that if you decide for land purchase, you should bear in mind that you are also pronouncing at once for colonisation.
President Dr. Herzl: Certain details are better reserved for the committee.
Dr. Pasmanik: I make the formal motion and address myself especially to yesterday's majority. What is at issue here is not verbal hair-splitting. I address myself to the Yes-sayers and beg them to vote unanimously that land should be purchased in Palestine at once with the money of the National Fund (Applause).
President Dr. Nordau: Two motions lie before us for voting:
a) Motion Vogelsohn: Closure of the debate without hearing the further speakers.
I draw your attention to the fact that under our rules two-thirds of the votes are necessary for adoption.
The motion is rejected.
b) Motion Schermann: To close the list of speakers.
The motion is adopted.
Dr. Menczl: It would be worth the trouble to go into the legal exposition of Dr. Farbstein and Dr. Marmorek. I refrain from discussing it before a larger plenum. Yesterday a Russian speaker said: we do not snatch at momentary successes. That is right. Why are we snatching at momentary successes here? The only one who took up an opposing standpoint was Scheinkin. This I must accept. If it is to be a National Fund, the sum is set far too low. That is shown by the example of the Bank. Do not forget: the National Fund is the people's own self-help. From it the proletariat is to be relieved. I should therefore be in favour not only of not lowering this limit, but even of raising it considerably. We should bring it about that we are in a position to buy land, but not to lease it further. By Turkish law one can buy land for three years without cultivating it. The opening of activity I would postpone to a time when we have 500,000 pounds.
As an Austrian delegate I reply to the reproach of Mr. Scheinkin: the Russians have raised more than so and so many countries together. I live in a town where the Roumanians and others passing through cost us ten times as much as we can do for the National Fund. So the Western Europeans, too, are doing their duty! I move that we shall vote that the National Fund may begin its colonising activity only when it has 500,000 pounds.
Kotljar speaks Jargon: The sale of stamps will not grow larger through introducing several values. The National Fund would increase more quickly if the money were put to use at once; the public likes to see the money applied. The »Golden Book« partly misses its purpose, because not only great men are inscribed, but everyone who gives the sufficient sum. I propose that in future, apart from specially deserving men, only societies be inscribed.
Schnell: Dr. Kohan-Bernstein has proposed that every Zionist should hand over 2% of his annual expenditure to the National Fund. The poor
