No. 6 Special Edition. — "Die Welt" — Page 11
I beg you to devote all your powers to this, the most important practical task that we have.
I can only support the resolution of the Minsk Conference of Delegates. The people understand fine speeches, but they also understand fine deeds, and what we must do is to hasten the purchase of land. Only, for bringing about the resolution in this matter a majority of ³/₄ is too much, and a simple majority ought to suffice. Land purchase should be carried on in such a way that the available means are applied to it down to one-fifth.
The question has also been put to me by some of my friends whether one may safely contribute further moneys to the National Fund without having to fear that they might be used for East Africa. I hold it my duty to reassure my brethren on this point, for all the money will be used for Palestine only. (Cries of Bravo.)
Rabbi Scheinkin speaks Yiddish and says that Palestine is thought to be far away and that people concern themselves with it the less (Strong dissent and applause). If, moreover, my district has not contributed so much to the National Fund, it must be borne in mind that it is a poor country. Bender and Podolia, however, have given as much to it as Roumania and Austria together, in spite of the fruitful work of these. Nothing should be taken from the National Fund until the 2 million roubles are fully collected. Political Zionism must have great ideals, but also great financial strength. The fund of the Jewish nation must not be bounded by 200000 L. sterling; it must have millions, and the more it has, the more it will be able to work. As his speaking time has expired, he can no longer bring forward the proposals he wished to make.
Belkowsky, St. Petersburg: I should like to state my position on the motions concerning the National Fund which have been laid before us to-day. It is still impossible for us to express ourselves on the form of the National Fund, for it is still doubtful whether a co-operative society or a joint-stock company or a foundation should be created. I should like to support that point of the National Fund Commission which is to the effect that the drafting of a definitive statute should be submitted to a commission to be elected at this Congress, which is to submit the final statutes to the next Annual Conference for decision.
Further, it is no doubt necessary to dispose of larger capital sums, but we must place so much confidence in our A. C. as to leave it to act at its discretion in the various cases, when it finds the early purchase of land desirable.
Dr. Kahn speaks in Hebrew, then in German: There occurs a point in the statute which provides that the National Fund shall also be entitled to resell territories it has purchased. Against this I set myself with all my strength. What the National Fund has once bought it can not and must not sell, but only lease (Lively assent). I should therefore have brought in a motion which would have led to an alteration by the Congress; but since I have been reassured on this point that the resolution concerning legalisation will not follow at this Congress, we have time in the interval to make a necessary alteration as well, and I beg you to bear in mind that in § 2 alterations and revisions of wording are still to be taken up, and let us hope to appear at a next Congress with a statute much more rounded and better suited to its purpose.
Dr. Schlaposchnikoff speaks in Russian against the wording "Palestine and neighbouring countries"; the activity should remain confined to Palestine and Syria.
Dr. Wortsmann: Dr. Tschlenoff has said that we need not fear that the money of the Jewish National Fund might be used, not wholly for Palestine, but for other countries. I do not, however, consider such a declaration sufficient, and I find it absolutely necessary to take some measures so that the Jewish National Fund may be acknowledged to be used for the purpose for which we created it, and such measures I should like to propose to you.
I do not know which form is better for the Jewish National Fund, whether a co-operative society or a foundation, but there are at all events so-called organistic statutes; that is, when a foundation is established, the founders of the foundation have the right so to determine its purpose that centuries and millennia may pass and no man can alter it. I therefore beg you to determine that the National Fund be destined for all time for Palestine and the adjoining territories.
The purpose should be alterable only unanimously, for we saw yesterday what a majority can amount to. I do not mean to say by this that the majority yesterday created anything un-Zionist, but I only mean to say that yesterday there was a majority for so grave a matter, and votes were cast by people who were voting for the first time (loud counter-cries and cries of: Ridiculous), so that the measure I propose appears necessary.
Chairman: Dr. Nordau, you have not the right to criticise personally the persons and delegates who form the majority; that far exceeds your right as a speaker (cries of applause).
Dr. Wortsmann: If I have offended anyone, I beg his pardon.
I should like to make you one more small proposal. We have a "Golden Book," and I do not wish to vote against the "Golden Book," for it is necessary that we obtain money. But we ought to give it another name.
Dr. Fink: Our President said in his opening speech that he had been in St. Petersburg not merely as a Zionist, but as the representative of all Jewry. Yesterday's vote showed still more that we are in fact acting in the interest of the whole of Jewry (we are talking about the National Fund! National Fund!). It is demanded from various quarters that the National Fund should come into operation as quickly as possible, but it is overlooked that it has proved of little yield. Our having chosen the system of indirect taxation leaves a great gap. We are not in a position to seize the taxable element in such a way that it cannot evade us. It will therefore have to be our care to open new and productive sources to the National Fund. To this end I make you the following proposal: I believe we should issue an appeal to all Jewish communities and Jewish societies of the whole world to pay over 2% of their annual budget to the National Fund (Applause!). It cannot be denied that the National Fund is that institution which enjoys the greatest popularity within the whole of Jewry. Here, contrary to ordinary experience, the new tax will be greeted with rejoicing. Moreover, the rate of 2% is so trifling that every society
