Page 211. — "Die Welt" — No. 4.
Economic Section.
Zionism as a Social Phenomenon.
I. The Class Struggle in Judaism.
(Continuation.)
The political expression of this economic substratum was the peculiar constitution of the Jewish people. Full, unbridled freedom below and a stern, all-governing principle above — a "complete anarchy, whose complement was theocracy" (Wellhausen, l. c. 16).
But in Juda too (I use this name as a collective name for Judæa and Israel) the law of economic life, the struggle for existence — the struggle for one's share of fodder and one's place at the trough, as Werner Sombart drastically calls it — soon began to reveal itself. The eternal drama repeated itself: the stronger stretched and spread themselves, enriched themselves, and oppressed the weaker, the poorer. Even then were heard the warning voices of the prophets, their bitter lamentations, which depict for us in glaring colours the revolution then taking place in the economic life of the Jewish people.
"Woe unto them that join house to house, that lay field to field, till there be no room left, that they alone may possess the land," so cried Isaiah (Ch., 15, v. 8). Does one not seem to hear a modern political economist speaking, who points to the expropriation of the land as the chief evil, the social original sin? And another side of the economic conditions of that day is laid bare for us by the plaintive, elegiac prophet Jeremiah (Ch. 34, vv. 6–16), where he inveighs with indignation and wrath against slavery, which had taken on new forms unknown to the ancient spirit of Judaism, or emphatically proscribed by the Mosaic law.
And it was quite natural. The Jews had entered upon the social stage through which every agricultural society passes sooner or later. But at the very moment when the germs lying in the depths of social life were on the point of developing further and bearing fruit, a heavy misfortune broke upon the Jewish people, which unhinged the whole life of the nation and revolutionised it. This misfortune was the first destruction of the Jewish kingdom by Nabuchodonosor. As is well known, he carried the rich, propertied Jewish families into exile in Babylon, and left in Palestine the poorer, needy folk, who settled upon the now empty soil and took possession of it.
When the restoration of the Jewish kingdom then took place, the conditions had become different. They were not the natural, logical, historical continuation and further development of the earlier economic relations, but a new creation. Once more a process of development in another direction now began in the midst of the Jewish people. Wealth swelled on the one side; on the other, poverty grew. Great landed property assumed new forms and became ever more powerful; the Jewish commerce which arose at that time for this reason created new economic conditions, as is evident from the laws that arose in that period. The introduction of the law of bills of exchange, the regulation of the relation between landowner and tenant, the famous institution of the Prosbule, which constitutes a mitigation of the Mosaic prohibition of lending at interest dating from the times of the agricultural state — all the regulations which were afterwards codified in the Mishnah bear witness that Palestine had ceased to be a purely agrarian state and had become a trading, industrial one.
And once more the social question began to rise in its dark outlines; its features were still blurred, it had not yet found its issue, but it was already in the making. But this time too the Jew succumbed to his fatal destiny, which countless peoples of East and West then shared with him: it was shattered by the Roman colossus. This mighty blow exercised a decisive influence upon the economic structure of the Jewish people as well.
I should like, anticipating a little, to illustrate the economic history of the Jews by means of an analogy taken from the realm of inorganic nature — which is, of course, no explanation, but merely a comparison.
Crystals, as is well known, are formed by the ranging side by side, the juxtaposition, of the molecules of a given substance, which by reason of chemical or physical properties has the tendency to arrange itself in layers in a certain direction and in a certain position. This, however, is the case only so long as the process is normal and undisturbed; but if the formation of the crystal is disturbed by various external causes, malformations arise, hemimorphic (half-formed) or amorphous (formless) bodies. Here the laws of symmetry no longer hold; the system contradicts itself. We meet with this phenomenon in the formation of the socio-economic structure of the Jewish people as well. Lashed by storms through every land, hunted, hovering in perpetual uncertainty of the coming day, not sure of their possessions, excluded from almost every productive occupation, the Jews could not ripen economically; they could not develop a relatively closed, fully evolved social order; they remained malformations, social hemimorphies.
Let us observe the social structure of the Jewish people throughout its whole life in exile. What occupation remained to the Jews after the dissolution of their state? Agriculture, where it was possible, and trade. And here too, as will appear from what follows, there could be no occasion for the formation of classes in the bosom of the Jewish people. Since the land placed at the disposal of the Jews was very small, because the right to hold landed property was granted them only in the native provinces of Palestine and Syria, no great landed property could arise — at least not to the same extent as happened at the same time in Rome, where the system of the latifundia, which, to speak with Pliny, plunged Rome into ruin (latifundia perdere Romam), had already abolished the free peasantry and to the formation of a new class of serfs, the "Coloni," who (recruited partly from the formerly free peasants, partly from the reserve army of the ragged proletariat, which had hitherto lived at the expense of Rome's imperialist greed or of the demagogues who succeeded one another in the struggle for mastery. Since, then, there was no great landed property in Palestine, there was accordingly also no correlate, that is, no proletariat. The same may be said of the other Jewish branch of livelihood at that time, trade.
In the agricultural provinces themselves we see a typical economic life being played out, which
