Page 6. — "Die Welt" — Special Edition. No. 4.
(continued from page 5)
…will render a proper report at a next Congress or at a small Congress, and you yourselves will have lost nothing but a rash act, if to-day you suddenly and without examination reject an offer which has been generously made to you and which may yet contain within it the seeds from which good may grow for the Jewish people. (Applause.)
Prof. Belkowski recalls the first Congress and asks what has happened since that time to justify a change of standpoint. We heard of the fruitless negotiations with Turkey. Is the assertion justified that this fact excludes the hope and prospect of an eventual agreement with Turkey? He does not believe so. For the solution of this question depends not on individual States but on our people. That is not a matter of feeling, but the expression of a historical necessity which must find its end in the national solution. There is no better place than this tribune from which to proclaim it. The generous offer of England is not to be underrated, but one must not lose time over this project to the detriment of the historical moment. The offer itself proves that all the Powers take an interest in the question, and if this offer, which does not have our national sympathies, is declined, England will certainly not refuse us other means towards the national solution of the question! He pleads for the concentration of all forces upon the original programme!
Dr. Katzenellensohn. We have much to learn from our honoured President. I take one phrase out of his speech, where he said that he was there not only as a party man but also as a Jew.
Gentlemen, so we too must judge this question not only as party men but also as Jews.
It has been proposed here to appoint a commission and to deal with this question without having first asked the shekel-payers. The delegates should first go and ascertain the opinion of the shekel-payers, and meanwhile seriously investigate and examine the question.
If I can say anything new on the question, it is because I live in a town which is the chief point of the emigration, in Libau.
I do not wish to call forth a mournful mood here in the Congress by describing the situation of these unhappy emigrants. That would be too sad. I wish only to point out a few things quite briefly.
From time to time one reads in the Libau newspaper that such-and-such a steamer has sailed for America with 200 Jews and 300 horses. I must point out this sad fact so that one may see from it how these people are treated. Three years ago, in Libau, six persons were suffocated on one such transport. That is the situation of these people who are seeking a night shelter!
They wander about aimlessly. Some of them never reach the goal at all, for they are sent back; and of those who do get there it has been said that some Jews welcome them, and some Jews do not.
Now, you will probably ask how large is the number of people who are looking about for a night shelter. I have collected exact data. It was about 40,000 two years ago, and over 100,000 in the first half of this year.
The number of people looking about for an asylum grows with every day.
In the year 1899, 2000 Jews passed through Libau; in the year 1903, in the first half alone, 5767. Now, when we already have 100,000 people who are going out and do not know whither, when we see this number, we must ask ourselves: what is to become of these people? The greatest question of the Jewish people is expressed in a few words: it is a people scattered and dispersed among the most diverse nations.
Shall we go on working at this work of dispersion? Shall we permit it when, on the other side, there exists the possibility of creating a better existence, a home? Shall we simply lay this question aside without examining it? What would be said of us in 30 or 40 years if it were said that the Congress would not examine the offer of a Government which wished to offer us a land? That we cannot answer for.
Now they fear that this will harm the Zionist movement.
On that point I should like to reassure you; it will even be of great use to us.
I can only call out to you from a full heart: in voting, remember these hundred thousand human beings who are now going out into the world without plan or goal. Create for them, if not a home, at least a place where they can live together, and above all, consider and examine once more. The delegates must first turn to the people, and the next Congress shall give the answer. In any case, may resolutions be taken for the welfare of Jewry and for the welfare of Zion!
Dr. Tschlenow. I must say that a very grave drama is being played out in my soul. I feel that there is something in the depths of my heart, something which seems holy, inviolable, which is being touched and wounded in this Congress. Is there really a danger to that which we hold holy? Let us hear what our beloved leaders have said.
Do they think for a moment of forgetting Zion, or do they wish to give us something in place of Zion? No, they maintain that our strivings and our labours for Zion will find a strengthening. They maintain that they will create for us a place where we may gather our forces and prepare the way for Zion.
I do not believe that anyone will succeed in putting another land into our programme in place of Zion. What stands upon our banner remains for ever our sanctuary and our watchword. (Applause.)
In drawing up our programme we were well aware that the attainment of our goal is bound up with great difficulties. Zion is the land that we love. Zion stands before all the lands of our choice. But there are many other important considerations as well. We said to ourselves: we must have a centre which must always remain a field of attraction for our people. We must have a place which will always draw our people to itself.
We further said to ourselves: we do not think that the whole people will go to Zion; we shall create a home only for a part of the people, but this home will have authority over the whole people.
There is only one land which has this authority for our people, and that is Zion — no other land in the world! (Lively applause.)
Therefore we have not a moment's fear that Zion can be exchanged for anything else. In
