No. 4, Special Edition. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.
(continued from page 6)
…what is being proposed to us, a new illusion has been created for the people.
Why have we still comparatively few Zionists? Our idea is so clear and so compelling, but many forces simply do not work with us because they have illusions.
The distress is colossal, and our people has known no rest since it left its home. Therefore we have made a central point, the first sentence of our programme, which states that we strive to create a publicly and legally secured home in Palestine. That is what characterises Zionism. Our programme and our ways are clear, and we cannot depart from them. But we know that there are obstacles, that the way is hard, and so I turn to you, and in particular to our honoured leaders. We shall wait, and wait long, until the moment comes which stands in our programme and here upon our banner. We hope that, since the magnanimous British people has declared its readiness to help us, it will also understand our love of our homeland. We beg our leader: "Go before this people and tell them that Zion is our home, and ask that this nation give us assistance to this end."
Dr. Fink (Vienna). The many arguments against East Africa have glanced off him entirely. On the one hand the mass misery in Russia is lamented; on the other, a danger to idealism is feared. Which is easier to bear? The ruin of millions of human beings, or the possible weakening of an ideal? But even the latter is not to be feared, for he who loses his Zionist ideal never possessed it. The revival of Zionism shows that ideals celebrate their resurrection even on this earth; but those who have died in misery do not rise again. Did he know that the millions of the disfranchised and the enfeebled were in favour of rejecting the East African project, he would at once uphold that standpoint. But would it mean a strengthening of the movement if we came to our people and told them: We have brought you "ideals" from the Congress?! (Commotion.)
In politics one must reckon with facts and not with ideals. The Zionists are reproached with making words and shrinking timidly from deeds. Now we are placed before a deed, and we really tremble!
The East African project does not collide with the Zionist ideal, and he calls Jewish history itself to witness to this. We stand before our first essays in politics and must watch how others do it. France laid claim to Alsace in vain; has she on that account renounced the idea of colonisation on the whole?!
Kohan Bernstein. We do not wish to pursue a sentimental policy, but a real policy, and to consider the project from a purely political standpoint. There are two reasons, juridical and political, which make it necessary to take a position.
When I heard of this project for the first time, I had the feeling that every hungry man, every thirsty man feels: Only give me bread and water! But we are here not only as the guardians of an ailing Jewry; we are here to study the organism thoroughly, as good physicians. One does not ask a sick man what prescription one should write for him. In England and America family physicians keep journals in which they enter when the members of a family are well and when ill. We have such a book, Jewish history, and must constantly hold to this guiding line.
When I saw the martyrs of Kishineff, I felt, besides my grief, pride as well. I saw how Jewish iron becomes steel. Misery makes us Jews strong, not weaker. Therefore I give you the counsel not to accept compromise projects for our distress. I propose to you that a resolution be heard which the Russian delegation has adopted, and I recommend you to adopt it. I believe that we shall act with political wisdom if we do so. The resolution of the Russian delegation, which was adopted in a vote by 146 votes against 84, reads: "The Congress recognises the great political import of the magnanimous offer of the English Government, which proposes to permit the Zionist Organisation to found an autonomous Jewish colony in East Africa, and requests the A. C. to convey the warmest thanks of the Jewish people to the Government of the mighty English nation. Since the Jews remain true to the Congress, to the fundamental principle of Zionism, and see the goal of the movement in the creation of a publicly and legally secured home in Palestine alone, we regret that the Zionist Organisation cannot occupy itself with this project." (Lively applause.)
Dr. Gronemann: Although I speak for the commission, I nevertheless find, among all the words spoken to-day, only one word, from one of the previous speakers, against which I raise a protest. It has been said that we are first Jews and then Zionists. That is not true. Judaism and Zionism are for us identical. It cannot be that we could be for something as Jews and against it as Zionists. So it is too with East Africa. The touchstone is our programme. That which is offered us must be either our goal or the means to that goal. The goal is not offered us. Is, then, that which is offered us fitted to bring us nearer to our goal? That I should like to answer in the affirmative. Not from the standpoint that we would thereby be working against pauperisation. We wish not merely a night shelter, but a workshop for the Jewish people. Dr. Rosenbaum has said that there existed in Zionist circles a great fear lest the Charter be granted before we were ready. Why are we not ready? We can create model farmers and found schools. One thing we lack: we cannot create model citizens. We must have a vast school for the Jewish people, in which the Jewish people learns to live out its political life (Applause). That we must wait for the attainment of our goal, we know. The only question is where and how we wish to wait, whether as oppressed bondmen or as free, upright citizens (Applause). A Zionist who forgets his programme is not worthy to be called a Zionist (Applause). Or is there anyone who holds the view that Zionism is nothing but the reaction against antisemitism, nothing but a product of fear, that only those who are in distress have come to Zionism? The very opposite is the case. That we shall show even in the best and fairest days, when we are able to live out our national life. From there the model citizens will go forth, those who form a stock. There can be no talk of danger to our programme. Is it a danger if for some time we can come together and live politically, can at least give ourselves up to the illusion that we have reached our goal? Are we here anything other than an image of the
