No. 4, Special Edition. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
President: As the result of the vote cannot be exactly determined, he decides against limiting the speaking time to five minutes. The motion to limit the speaking time to 10 minutes is then carried.
Dr. Wortsmann: We must be grateful to our leader, Dr. Herzl, for what he has done since the last Congress. He has done more than we can ask of him. But that does not yet entail the acceptance of the East Africa project. I want clarity to be established on this question. Dr. Nordau told us yesterday that we must go on working for Palestine, that we should not scatter our forces, and he ended by saying that we must be for East Africa. That is a glaring contradiction. It would mean collecting money for the National Fund and selling shares of the Jewish Colonial Bank in the morning, and in the afternoon for the East African bank. Whoever knows Jewish life must say: a Jewish autonomy with a Jewish local government in East Africa is a blessing for the Jewish people. But if, as Dr. Nordau has said, we wish to found a "night shelter," then we must try to furnish this night shelter as well as possible. It is characteristic, and I should like to say sad, to turn Palestine into East Africa within 24 hours. We are told that we must be grateful to the English Government; yes, from the heart. But let us not forget that if we send millions of Jews to East Africa and found a civilised state there, the English Government too will have cause to thank us. I beg to be understood as speaking here against East Africa. At the Zionist Congress you will not see me for East Africa; that would be treason to the shekel-payer, to the Zionist. I propose that a commission be elected on this question, and that a vote by name be taken, so that the Jewish people may know who is for East Africa and who is for Palestine. (Lively applause.)
Lewin (Jargon) opposes the election of a commission; he regards it as the first step towards the acceptance of the East Africa project. We want Palestine, not a night shelter. We want to have Dr. Herzl in Palestine, and Nordau too. We have the assurance in the oldest book in the world that we shall receive our land; we do not wish to give it up, be it only for 10 years. We do not wish to give Dr. Herzl, who is dear to us, a single hour for another movement. We are jealous of him. He shall be our President as long as there is a Zionist Congress at all, and should there be many who turn to other movements, we wish to remain true to ourselves as pure Zionists.
Dr. Pasmanik. I believe that this is the most tragic moment of the Sixth Congress, and not merely of the sixth, but of all the Congresses hitherto. One must see, observe, this inner struggle which is going on in each one of us; how hard it is for everyone to reach a decision on this question.
When we were elected to the Congress, we knew nothing of the East Africa question. Nor do we know now what our electors think of it. Have we the right to decide the question without having consulted the electors? Where are the democrats, and those who call themselves democrats, who will not defend this principle? I wish to appeal to my electors. I take the standpoint of a true democrat.
A second point is the immense political significance of this offer. For the first time we have been treated as a political factor.
Let us make use of this moment. Let us not condemn the offer out of hand.
The only right decision will be this: we elect a commission which shall acquaint itself with the question as exactly as possible, but which shall not have the right to decide. Then the question shall be discussed by the whole Zionist world. And if it is necessary, we shall have a Congress in 6 months, in 3 months. We have indeed waited long already, we can wait a little longer
I believe that if we then decide, in whatever sense it may be, it will be a decision of the people. (Great applause.)
Temkin speaks in Russian: He heartily thanks England for the offer, but he must state that from the Sixth Congress onward our leaders have shown more attachment to the Jewish-State ideal than to Zion. And yet the bare rocks of Palestine are dearer to him than lands full of milk and honey. If we accept Africa, we must bid adieu to the moral support of Europe for our ideals. No one will afterwards take account of our feelings. Further, the following practical considerations must be taken into account:
-
We have few people. And there will certainly be a split into a party of the "pure" and one of the "problematical" Zion.
-
We have little money. And the money that has hitherto been raised for Palestine would be needed elsewhere. For long periods we should have to forgo the contributions of the National Fund for Palestine. He proposes that this motion (East Africa) be accepted neither now nor ever hereafter, and that our activity be directed towards where the eyes of the Jewish people are turned, towards Zion. (Applause.)
Dr. Friedemann: I have heard a great many words to-day. They all moved in the direction of saying that we are about to betray the Basle Programme. The Germans, Austrians, Italians, English and Americans, who two days ago announced to you through my mouth that they are in favour of appointing a commission, are just as good Zionists and know the Basle Programme just as well as the others. (Applause. Dissent.)
There was a great deal of sentiment in the speeches. But in Europe politics are made not with the heart but with the head. Temkin's politics are the politics of sentiment, not of the head. It is not true that the Africa project contradicts the Basle Programme. Those who have been somewhat longer in the movement know that the very first Zionists were much in doubt whether Palestine should be put into the programme at all. (Commotion.) We do not wish it to be resolved here that we emigrate to East Africa, but that a reasonable proposal be reasonably considered before it is rejected. It has been said that if we undertake anything in East Africa, we injure the national idea. But under all circumstances we keep Palestine as the final goal. Why are you opposed to a generous offer being — examined, in courteous form? It has also been said that the Ica might help. Very well! But if it does not, things may go as with the man who is told: I will give you no bread; you have rich relations. When they too gave him none, he starved. Millions of Russian, Roumanian and Galician Jews languish in despair, and you would dismiss a great project in this way? (Cries of "Close!" — Great applause.)
We desire merely a commission. This
