Page 4. — "Die Welt" — Special Edition. No. 4.
According to Nordau, the most necessary condition for obtaining Palestine was the will of the people; the will of 12 million human beings is a factor with which practical politicians must reckon. This precondition has not come about. On hearing the report of the executive we rejoice when we hear that we Zionists have grown by so and so many per cent. Compared with the non-Zionists we are, after all, only a minority. This will of the people is not yet there. The expression that we are the representatives of the Jewish people can be used only in a philosophical sense. The expression "will of the people" is abstract. Translated, it means: money. We have no money. At the founding of the Bank we scarcely had the sum that was necessary to establish the Bank. We understood the leadership of our leaders otherwise. We believed that we were to create a favourable disposition among the leaders of the nations, so that at the time when we were ready the others too would be won for us. We trembled at the obtaining of a charter, for we were not yet ready. It was said that the charter would be a tremendous means of agitation. That has not come about. Have we no other means of agitation? You will say: will of the people, money. Do we need no will of the people, no money, for East Africa? The idea is that for East Africa we should not take the money from the Jewish people, but go to the Ica. It is wished that our leader be sent to the Ica and to other rich Jews to beg. Our leader was received kindly by the Ica. What were the results? The same as with the others. The Ica holds fast to its method: every sympathy, but no money. So in the one case as in the other we must continue our work and follow Dr. Nordau's counsel. Our work is to create a will of the people, to deepen Zionism, to carry on agitation, or: "the organisation." I will not now enter into how we are to do this.
But our task is to hold fast to our ideals and to obtain those means which are necessary for the attainment of the ideal. We truly cannot have Palestine so long as we have no will of the people, that is, many Jews who are ready for sacrifice, and so long as we cannot promise the Turkish Government and the Turkish people advantage in the present. We have no reason to say that anything has failed. Dr. Herzl's undertaking could not yet succeed. That speaks in no way against future successes.
Now I will discuss a few more practical proposals. I have heard the opinion expressed that it would be ingratitude on our part were we unwilling to accept a proposal that is offered to us in so humane a spirit. I am no diplomatist, but in certain matters we may surely hold a diplomatic opinion. The magnanimous English people will take it ill of us that we treat this question in this hall according to our own judgment? That is not correct. We are filled with gratitude towards the English people. But we also have a Jewish people. In the optimism called forth by its sufferings, it will unquestionably believe that the Congress has promised it something which it is also bound to keep. If the next Congress brings nothing, an immense disappointment will arise, for which we cannot take the responsibility upon ourselves. What will the people say? Palestine, no! El Arish, no! East Africa, probably no! Motions must not be put merely in order that something may be said. The Presidium moves the appointment of a commission. Against a temporary commission here at the Congress I have nothing to object, but I do not agree to a standing one. Motions are put that the Congress should, through Dr. Herzl, hand the matter over to other Jewish institutions, for example the Ica. In any case we shall make ourselves ridiculous if we pass resolutions about what the Ica is to do. I recall the resolutions passed in Odessa about what the Ica in Paris was to do. Let us not repeat these instances once more! It has been proposed to institute a general Jewish congress. People say: "As a Zionist I must say this, as a Jew otherwise." This is a dangerous saying, which I combat, meaning that we form a party among the Jews in which the party interests contradict the Jewish ones. With that we have violated the whole Basle Programme, not in its letter, but certainly in its inner meaning.
Sulzberger speaks in English.
Dr. Nordau translates. Mr. Sulzberger recommends the acceptance of the proposal for the East African colonisation (applause). In England there live at present 110,000 Jews among 40 million inhabitants; that sufficed to bring about the appointment of a commission unfavourable to alien immigration. In New-York there live 540,000 Jews. Do you believe that if this number increases in the next twenty years as it has in the last twenty, a movement against the immigration of undesirable aliens would not arise in America too? He for his part rejoiced in the character and strength of the immigration hitherto; but he was not the representative of the opinion of most American Jews. For many, the burden rolled upon their shoulders by the growth of the immigration of poor East European Jews is so immense that it threatens to crush them. And what would it mean if the gates of the United States were closed to the Jews? One of the great deeds of American diplomacy last year was the note of the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs, Mr. Hay, to the Roumanian Government, making representations to it concerning the treatment of the Jews. It contained fine, unforgettable words. But the foundation of this note was apprehension at the increased immigration of Jews into America.
Do not build too firmly upon the unshakable good will of the United States. If an opportunity offers itself to you of finding another shelter — for all the world, take it. Before I am a Zionist, I am a Jew, I am a man. (Applause.) As a Zionist, as a Jew, as a man, I say: If you have the opportunity of saving human beings, do it, for all the world. If you reject the generous offer of the English Government, do you then believe that any government in the world would ever again lift a finger to save a people that will not save itself, that slams the door which is opened to it? (Great applause.)
Dr. Herzl, President: The following motions on the order of business are before us:
Motion of Dr. Pasmanik: Since the East Africa question has already been discussed in detail in the various territorial groups and is therefore precisely known to all, I move that general speakers be chosen, namely ten, each of whom may speak for only 15 minutes.
Motion Schnelling: The speakers entered for the East Africa question shall choose general speakers.
Motion Amrein: Since enough has already been said about East Africa in the various territorial groups and various resolutions have been passed, the speaking time shall be limited to 20 minutes.
Motion Cohen: The speaking time is to be limited to 5 minutes.
Motion Friedemann: The speaking time is to be limited to 5 minutes, that of the general speakers yet to be chosen to 10 minutes.
Dr. Trietsch: It would be entirely out of place to limit the speaking time on what is surely the most important question of the Congress.
Jakobsohn likewise speaks against limiting the speaking time.
Hch. Rosenbaum: A full debate on this question of principle is absolutely necessary. He moves, however, that each territorial group choose one speaker pro and one contra, with unlimited speaking time.
The President remarks that the limitation to 5 minutes' speaking time gives many more speakers an opportunity to speak, and that the essence of even a very great idea can be expressed in 5 minutes.
A vote is then taken.
