No. 4. Special Edition. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
…year the Jewish population there increases enormously. The other means were likewise utopian.
They have tried to inoculate us with another culture. Through the schools which the Alliance has founded only one thing has been achieved: that their pupils have cast off Jewish culture while learning merely a little French, German or English; and the trade schools that were founded have, too, so far suffered complete fiasco. As for the colonisation which the Alliance set on foot, Mr. Leven himself has broken the staff over it; he has declared that the Ica wishes only to found model colonies; but it must be remarked that the colonies of the Ica are so far by no means model colonies, and even if they were, never yet has an urban proletariat been led over to agriculture by model colonies. Leven himself says: "We believe in the future and in the triumph of the principles of 1789." If one relies upon that, it is unnecessary to possess a fortune of so many millions, to have so many members, and to publish annual reports. The position of the Jewish people will not be improved by a revolution, and against the policy which the Ica has pursued we must protest energetically. We too shall colonise; for by colonisation alone will all economic, physical, cultural and political questions be settled, and therefore we must see to it that all the forces at the disposal of the Jewish people are employed. In order to colonise we may renounce no help, not even the help of the philanthropic societies. If they refuse us their help, we must appeal to those who gave them their powers, that is, to the members of the societies who appoint the administration of the Ica.
From the figures which the Alliance has published it appears that 8 per cent. of the electors voted for us, the rest for the official list. The Alliance has, however, itself declared that it did not hold the election in various national and local committees. We, on the other hand, did not take the field in this election in most districts and towns. In America, Switzerland, Turkey, Roumania, Bulgaria, and on the coast of the Mediterranean we neither issued a list of candidates nor conducted any agitation. Where our trusted men did work, the majority was obtained. I recall the results achieved in Mannheim, Venice and Mülhausen, where the Zionists actually worked. The Alliance tried everything possible to hold back a Zionist victory; the order came from Paris on no account to communicate the list of members to us. In spite of all this we may be satisfied with the result. What matters for us is that in future we can count not only on sympathies but also on your activity. Therefore the Zionist members of the Alliance must make use of all the rights at their disposal. Let us see to it that the elections take place regularly; let us regularly put up candidates, and then we shall perform an important piece of Zionist preparatory work. I should therefore like, in conclusion, to move the resolution: "The Congress obliges all Zionist members of the philanthropic societies to bring the influence due to them to bear as fully as possible." (Stormy applause.)
President Dr. Herzl makes business announcements, and in particular urgently invites attendance at the Jewish gymnastic display and a view of the sculptor Beer's statue, Schemah Jisroël, and of the "Golden Book."
Dr. Nobel regrets that Mr. Zangwill did after all touch upon the religious question. (Cries of protest and of "Close!")
Zangwill (greeted with tumultuous applause) replies that he had not for a moment had the thought of speaking of religion. But it is the peculiarity of the constitution of the Jewish people that religion and politics are inseparably bound up in it. He had merely wished to consider the political side. He revered Jochanan ben Sakkai, as the one who fixed the principles of the Jewish religion after the destruction of the Temple, exactly as much as any pious Jew. But Rabbi Jochanan's deed was political as well as religious. He claimed it as the right of the critical historian to discuss only its political side, and
he held that, if it is quite beyond doubt that Rabbi ben Sackai saved the Jewish religion, it is just as beyond doubt that he delivered the Jewish people over to 1800 years of suffering. (Great applause.)
President Dr. Herzl, after some further business announcements, closes the sitting at 12¾ o'clock.
Tuesday Afternoon Sitting.
Opening at 5 o'clock. President Dr. Herzl.
Rabbi Dr. Nobel reads the following declaration: The Misrachim and their comrades in the cause hereby enter the most emphatic protest against those passages in Zangwill's speech in which religious problems were discussed in a manner wounding to Jewish religious consciousness. They express the firm expectation that in future the raising of such questions at the Congress will be avoided, since they see in this the first precondition for a prosperous fraternal co-operation of all Zionists. (Bravo! Hissing.)
Zangwill (in English) defends himself on the ground that the speech was not a religious but an economic one. He had by no means wished to attack the Orthodox; on the contrary, he regarded them altogether as his brothers. When he had recalled Ben Sakkai by way of parable, he had been thinking of the one buried alive, that is, the spirit of the Jewish people, which had kept the Jewish people alive. Marin himself had spoken more against Ben Sakkai than he, Zangwill.
The translator of Zangwill's speech delivered in English declares that he is convinced that Zangwill is as grateful to Ben Sakkai for the preservation of Judaism as the Misrachim are (applause).
President: With this the incident is, I hope, disposed of (applause).
Some entries in the Golden Book are read out.
Dr. A. Marmorek: The Standing Committee has instructed its chairman to declare that inaccuracies have crept into the report on the Standing Committee in "Die Welt," though through no fault of the editors. Further: for election to the Finance Committee are proposed G. Kohen, Hamburg; Moses, Frankfort-on-Main; D. Wolffsohn, Cologne; Ginsberg, Riga; Markus, Florence; Jos. Cowen, London; Dr. Katzenellensohn, Libau; J. Veit, Basle; and Isidor Gewitsch, Vienna. I ask that the election be made by acclamation. This is done.
President: We now enter upon the discussion of East Africa.
Dr. Rosenbaum: I will begin at the point where I left off yesterday. First, one remark: in this question I should not like to touch upon that side which works upon our feelings. In the territorial groups the question has already been discussed on all sides.
When I said that we could also send the Jews to America and other countries, I heard "No." With that I agree. We must have Palestine. When the rich Jews, the philanthropists, wish to colonise the poor Jews, it really happens thus: the rich cannot bear to look upon suffering poverty, and therefore they pick out a remote corner of the earth and send the poor thither, so that they may not be seen, so that one need not always feel pity. That we do not want. We want to go together with them.
At the moment when we say that we wish to find a night-shelter for a group of Jews (and a shelter, indeed, for a dark night!), we are the philanthropists against whom we have written and spoken so much. Suppose we could have Palestine and East Africa were offered to us, we should decide unanimously for Palestine. Consequently the question must be put thus: Is it true that we cannot have Palestine? I say yes! Within a foreseeable time, that is, within the time when we need it. I beg you to keep calm, even if I say things at which you would like to interrupt me.
