Page 10. — "Die Welt" — Separate Edition. No. 4.
(continued from page 9)
…perhaps to a body in which, in national questions, we otherwise have no confidence? Are we perhaps to let the assimilationist bodies hold sway? Never.
I turn to the third reason. The gentlemen who say: If we have an autonomy in East Africa, we have given up all hope of Palestine, find themselves in a logical contradiction. The gentlemen say: At the moment when things go well with the Jews, when, that is, the social-economic motive has vanished which presses for a home secured by public law, the striving for Palestine is no longer present. You thereby assert that even now, in the present situation of the Jews in all lands, only the social-economic motive is the driving one for the attainment of a Jewish State. You thereby speak against yourselves. If you wish to be consistent, you must say: Just as the Jews strive towards Palestine not only from social-economic motives, but from romantic moods, from feelings, from tendencies of the heart (applause, dissent), just as there now exists a complex of states of the soul which urges the Jews to turn their attention to the old homeland, so it will also remain in being when a political autonomy of the Jews exists in East Africa.
And now I appeal to the political maturity and to the concern of every Zionist for the situation of our Jewish masses, that we beware of rejecting the matter out of hand, but rather fulfil our bounden duty and obligation and appoint a commission. Nothing is easier than to say no. But we, who wish to create something, now stand before the task of taking this heavy burden, too, upon our backs (applause).
Presidium, Dr. Bodenheimer: I intend to ask the Congress whether it wishes to close the debate, since this wish has been expressed from various sides, although the Congress resolved the contrary a short time ago.
Berger speaks for the closure of the debate.
Buber: I am against the closure of the debate, but move the closing of the sitting and the continuation of the debate to-morrow. We must close for two important reasons: 1. because it would be unfair if the members of the Actions Committee were to speak apart from the other speakers, and to-morrow only influential speakers were to get the floor.
- I consider it inadmissible that this important question should be concluded now in the absence of Dr. Herzl.
Therefore, in the interest of a proper and dignified settlement of the matter, I demand that we close now and continue the debate to-morrow.
Dr. Marmorek: No question has occupied this Congress so much as the East Africa question. Nowhere have we heard so many speakers as on this question. Nowhere are our convictions so firm as on this question. To be influenced is scarcely possible (counter-cries). If Dr. Herzl speaks to the matter to-morrow, it will be solely so that we may learn what impression he has. I beg you to remain until the close.
Rosenbaum: I too was in favour of letting the general speakers finish speaking to-day. But I have now learned that after the general speakers two reporters are yet to speak on this subject. That alters the situation. In other words, it means that the possible effect which the contra speakers would produce is to be weakened to-morrow by the reporters. We wish to state this quite clearly and openly.
The Presidium proceeds to the vote and declares as the result the closing of the sitting. (12¼ o'clock.)
National songs are sung by the delegates in mass chorus before they break up.
* * *
Resolution to the Congress.
The Conference of the English-speaking Delegates acknowledges with deep gratitude the magnanimous offer of the British Government, which affords the Jewish people the opportunity of acquiring a Jewish autonomous settlement in B. E. A.
The English-speaking delegates recommend the immediate formation of a commission, which shall have the right to investigate and negotiate this matter, in order then to render a detailed report to the A.-C., which in turn must lay the result before the Congress.
The Wednesday Morning Sitting
began at 10 o'clock. The first to receive the floor, greeted tumultuously, was Dr. Oppenheimer, for his Report on Settlement.
Zionism is set a task of the most tremendous difficulty. It is to organise a migration of peoples, first, of a magnitude such as the history of the world has scarcely ever witnessed; for it is a question of the expatriation and resettlement of millions of wretched, miserable human beings in the shortest time, whereas the migrations of peoples of ancient times scarcely set as many hundreds of thousands in motion, and whereas the greatest migration of peoples in the world, namely that of the German husbandmen to the United States of America, required more than 80 years to colonise some 14 millions of emigrants. — The second difficulty consists in this, that the territory into which this emigration must for compelling reasons be directed is a comparatively narrow one, so narrow that from the outset a very considerable density of colonisation must be reckoned with, a density of population such as has been able to arise only in the most highly developed civilised states as the result of a long and peaceful unfolding of agriculture and industry. The third difficulty consists in this, that this territory is, in climate, situation of the soil, vegetable production, etc., very different from those countries from which the stream of immigration is to be drawn off. The differences between the extensive agriculture of Western Europe with its abundant watering on the one hand, and the already almost sub-tropical cultivation of the steppe, which needs artificial irrigation, are so many difficulties for Zionist colonisation. The fourth and greatest difficulty lies in the nature of the human material that is to be led away and settled. Here something wholly new in the history of the world is to be accomplished; yes, even Rabbi Ben Akiba would have to admit that here for once his favourite saying becomes untrue; for all the migrations of peoples of the past proceeded either from mounted shepherd-warriors who broke forth from their steppe to seek dominion over serf peasants in the alluvial plains of the rivers, — or from peaceful husbandmen for whom their homeland had for some reason grown too narrow, and who now went forth to win a new home with plough and mattock. But the people which we have to redeem from the most fearful oppression which ever upon
