Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 3 · 16 January 1903
12printed page
scan 12 of 20
Facsimile · scan 12 of 20
Scan of p. 12
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 12 — "Die Welt" — No. 3

In any case the answer touches too much upon the surface of the question and does not penetrate to its essence, and it would therefore be permissible to take up afresh the question of the relation of Zionism to Marxism and to look it more deeply in the face. Above all we must compare and examine the foundations, the sociological premises, of both tendencies.

The teaching of Social Democracy rests upon the premise that in every society there are classes which stand in definite economic relations and economic opposition to one another, and find themselves in an open or latent antagonism among themselves. "The whole history hitherto is the history of class struggles" — so run the famous words, of fundamental significance, of Karl Marx in his "Communist Manifesto".

When we speak of classes in the sense of the Social Democratic theory, we must define the concept of class exactly, in spite of, or perhaps precisely because of, its having become a commonplace and familiar in everyone's mouth.

The concept of class, as Marx has given it, admits of two explanations. According to the one, namely the simple, vulgar one, a class means a certain number of persons who stand on the same economic and cultural level, enjoy the same political rights and occupy the same position in the State. It was in this sense that the older French Socialists spoke of classes — a Louis Blanc, Fourier, Proudhon (who, though an individualist, was nevertheless a Socialist in his conception). This definition, which is really an idem per idem, is a mere statement of facts, of given conditions. It is an empirical, fluctuating concept, which presupposes nothing, and which can also lead to no theoretical, sociological results; and for that reason the whole social doctrine of the French Socialists led to no consistent explanation of history, to no construction of a unified view of the world.

A different meaning was acquired by the word class among the German philosophers of history, and most markedly in Marx. Already Hegel said in his "Philosophy of History": "The general diversity of the particularisation of civil society is a necessity. If the first basis of the State is the family, the estates are the second." Marx inherited the thought of the master and developed it further. According to Marx, the class is a historical category. Not an aggregate of persons with like conditions of life, but a historically developed, necessary social phenomenon, which has appeared at a certain stage of historical life — this is for Marx the class, which, itself a historical product, then becomes the motive, generative, history-making force.

This concept of class, which Marx does not always adhere to, and which he very frequently confounded with the unscientific, empirical one dating from the blessed days of the utopian Socialists, as Sorel has shown (cf. "Revue internationale de Sociologie", 1901: "Les interprets du marxisme: passim"), we also meet with in some sociologists who, though they do not think in the Marxist spirit, nevertheless accept the fundamental hypothesis of historical materialism. So, for instance, in the celebrated Italian sociologist Prof. Achille Loria (cf. "Le basi economiche della costit soc.", 1902; L'analisi della propr. capit.", etc.).

Whether with Marx we derive the origin and succession of classes from the accumulation, the heaping up of capital in the hands of the few, and the exploitation and expropriation of the poorer and weaker masses of the people which it makes possible; or with Loria, and in part also George and the German land reformers (Flürscheim, Damaschke, etc.), from the appropriation of the soil, of the arable surface of the earth, by a few strong men, and the consequent dependence of the remaining, formerly independent, labourers — in either case every doctrine of social reform is necessarily founded upon the concept of classes that have arisen historically and gradually taken shape.

Let us now see, to return to our problem, whether a class struggle is going on in the midst of our people, whether we have passed through the same stages of development in social evolution, whether we have the necessary premises for arriving at the point on which Social Democracy now stands. It will no doubt seem to many like an echo of the old, antiquated belief in the "privileged position" of the chosen people in the history of the world, in the famous "mission" of the Jews which they were to fulfil here below, if, instead of recognising a priori and without further ado the law of historical development valid for all civilised nations as holding for the Jews as well, we set a question-mark and thereby single out the Jewish people and set it apart. But in proceeding thus we are acting precisely in the spirit of scientific Marxism. According to Marx there are no abstract — a priori — economic laws which would be applicable without more ado to all forms of civilisation. Different laws prevail at different times among different peoples; for it is not the laws that call forth life, as Hegel taught, but the reverse. (Cf. Guillaume de Greef: "Progrès et regrès social".) And it must surely be admitted that not a single people of the civilised world has behind it so peculiar, so wondrous a history as the Jewish.

All the other civilised nations of the earth have travelled approximately the same historical course, which might be represented schematically thus: in hoary antiquity, even before their entrance into history, the nomads settled upon the arable lands and became sedentary; then over the peaceful mass of tillers there swept a stream of foreign, mighty warriors, who subjugated the inhabitants. And then one of two things took place: either the strangers amalgamated with the inhabitants and continued the old manner of life, or they formed a military State in which a few were rulers, masters and owners, while the mass of the people was enslaved and disinherited. But these conditions, once established, persisted long, passed into the flesh and blood of the people, and led to a gradual, slow but sure transformation, to the negation of themselves, to new forms. In this way a historical formation of classes also became possible.

How different with the Jewish people! When we look back into hoary antiquity, of which period indeed very little is known to us concerning the social conditions of the Jews, we first meet the Jews, in the twilight of their history, on the march from a land where they lived as bondmen to a land whither they went as conquerors. The nomad people becomes an agricultural one; but the very circumstance that, in consequence of their religious or perhaps racial isolation, they entered into no closer contact with the other neighbouring peoples, that they did not appropriate the land without first having driven out the old inhabitants, but, after the Oriental custom of war, either exterminated the natives root and branch or drove them away — this sufficed to prevent the rise of an opposition between a ruling and a ruled, a possessing and a propertyless class. The legislation of Moses, which is one of the most humane and perfect in social respects, was possible only among such a people as presented a homogeneous, patriarchal mass of kindred stock. For in every patriarchal society — be it in the class of the Highland Scots, the Swiss Allmenden, the Russian "Obshchina", etc. — in a society where foreign conquerors have not yet brought bondage with them, the keynote, the first thread of legislation and social order, is a strongly communistic one. Neither in the Bible nor in the Prophets do we observe a division into classes such as existed, for example, in Rome or in Sparta. Indeed, the foundation of the whole political order remained "the old pre-political condition of aggregated communes, held together only by the religious national feeling". (Wellhausen: "Israelitische und jüdische Geschichte", 1895.)

(To be continued.)

A. Coralnik.