No. 51 — "Die Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…Jewry from my own experience. During my travels abroad I made the acquaintance of rich and poor Jews, entered into closer relations with them and showed interest in their life. In answer to my simply human conduct I was met with nothing but kindness, sincerity and truth. But I also visited the Jewish Pale of Settlement in Russia and came to know Russian Jewry thoroughly as well. The Jewish proletariat, the artisans and all the elements that form the people are sympathetic, upright, industrious and modest people, who everywhere awaken only the best feelings. Despite their lack of schooling they are not ignorant. On the contrary: they astonish by their high intelligence, by their high capacity for absorbing a higher culture. And these good, but poor and unhappy people are subjected to the whole weight of riots and oppressions ..."
While Father Petrow thus gives the Jewish people so brilliant a testimonial, he passes an unfavourable judgment upon the modern Jewish intelligentsia, which believes it finds its salvation in apostasy from its people . . . .
The state of things, as Father Petrow holds, was bound by natural necessity to call forth a movement promising the Jews a way out of their intolerable situation. The Zionist movement, therefore, is not only justified in its existence but is even an inescapable necessity. Yet Father Petrow does not believe in the practical realisation of Zionism. This unbelief of his he grounds on the following arguments, whose untenability, however, should be plain to everyone. He said, word for word: "The participants in the first Crusades at first described Palestine as an earthly paradise, but after three or four expeditions this land was turned into a desert. On the other hand, it is hard to believe in the realisation of Zionism because the Jews are very much attached to the land in which they live. The German Jews love Germany, the English England, the French France, and so on. Even the Jewish emigrants from Russia do not cease, in America, to remember their former fatherland in words of the deepest love and with tearful eye. They therefore employ every means to help and assist a Russian who has been cast upon America. Can one therefore suppose that, with this patriotism of the Jews, the movement towards Palestine will assume more or less extensive dimensions? Zionism has quite another value in the moral respect. And in this sense there is for young Jewry no worthier task than Zionism.
These observations of the Russian priest, who is universally revered in Russia, offer a twofold interest. First, they prove, more than abundantly, that Zionism seriously occupies all serious non-Jewish circles in Russia, and that as a problem called to give rebirth and freedom to an entire people. Secondly, they indicate that even the objections to Zionism raised by serious circles are nothing but imagined obstacles, which vanish at the slightest contact with reality. What was the case at the time of the Crusades need not come to pass in the present. The latest researches have long since placed the value of Palestine as a land for colonisation beyond doubt.
But the second argument of the honourable Father Petrow is also untenable. The patriotism of the Jews is indeed beyond doubt, but this should surely not hinder them from founding a home of their own, where they will be withdrawn from the oppressions whose existence Father Petrow himself admits. And in the moral force of Zionism, too, there lies a practical success.
Zionism and a Philosophy of Life.
II.
"This way of ours of regarding things must not be called transcendental. This 'thinking-out-beyond' the present surely comes from our having unlearned how to reckon with the moment. In those times when it was impossible to improve our present situation, we fed ourselves on ideals of the future and so deceived ourselves about our hunger for work in the present for so long that we lost all sense of it. Thus we share with all the weak the roaming into the distance where the good lies near at hand. That is décadence."
These words were written to me by a dear comrade in conviction after he had read the first of my essays on the above subject.
Is this objection really justified? With the so-called acquired characteristics it is an awkward matter. One must usually rest content with the assertion that a characteristic has been inherited, for an exact proof is impossible here. But in the present case we have, after all, a basis for judgment: namely, the consideration of the time before we were in the Golus. And there we see exactly the same traits of character which are now, very wrongly, described as decadent. Moses, the Prophets, the whole Bible show us that our people thought otherwise than the other nations, even than all the other Semites. We were no people of traders or of craftsmen, no tribe eager for conquest and no people of scholars. The whole of public life was filled with thought upon time and eternity, upon God and the world, ethics and social ideas. Yet the contemporaries of Elijah and of the Maccabees were surely not decadent. And the Ghetto did not escape from a sorrowful present into the future — no, into the past. Haman's death and the Exodus from Egypt awakened feelings of happiness. It would also be psychologically incomprehensible that a wretched, oppressed man should develop universal ideas of humanity in order to escape from himself. It is precisely the sufferer who is occupied with himself, and if today, though national Jews, we can nevertheless already think once more of the generality and give our nationalism the old-Jewish cosmopolitan direction, that proves reawakened strength of soul, not weakness. We ought indeed to think of ourselves, but not only of ourselves. That leads to chauvinism, and this course of development ought to be combated in good time by all who have insight.
If, then, the national-Jewish idea displays the peculiar direction mentioned, the path that our policy must follow in order to remain in harmony with the national thought and to lead it to its highest development follows of itself.
The essence of a good policy consists in proceeding according to a fundamental principle arising from inner considerations, and carrying it through without leaving real conditions out of account. We read in Bismarck's Reminiscences, page 166, the words of Gerlach:
"The search for the principle is of the greatest importance to me precisely because, without having found one, I hold all political combinations to be faulty, insecure and in a high degree dangerous."
By what fundamental principle, then, has our policy been guided?
