Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 51
We, the opponents, said to them: You may be irreproachable men who have no law to shun and no judge to fear: the worst you have committed certainly still lies within the bounds of the civil norm. You have exploited to the full the power that was given you; the State, no doubt, gave the power that it might be used; you have done too little for our poor: the State asks no more of you; you have let the little ship of religion drift as it would: the State will not be angry with you on that account; you have broken no paragraph of the law and you are certainly no criminals. Only point now to your merits. If you look closely, you will find that you have now done as much as the laws prescribed to you, just so much that you satisfy the regulations of the State. We have told you so, as opponents, time and again: in preserving the present state of things you deny the past and destroy the future; you call yourselves the Conservatives, and your conduct means the surrender of the little that still exists. But we, the subverters, wish to preserve and to build up. Therefore we fight against the tricks and dodges that every conservatism holds ready for warding off a change. Are the artifices which the ruling party practised in electoral matters to strengthen its following and to weaken the opponent — are these Jewish artifices? No. Rather, they learned them from the non-Jews. And just as the non-Jewish community had to defend itself against such practices, so the Jewish community too, whose needs we believed we recognised, had at the very least to say what it suffered. For the guides of our communal history formerly believed, perhaps — perhaps! — that all they did was good. Now they know the wishes of the multitude, and if they do not fulfil them, let them know that they do wrong. It was our duty to speak.
What we had said as opponents, the enemies, to be sure, then repeated. What we had described as un-Jewish, as harmful to Judaism, and against which, precisely out of our Jewish feeling, we had raised protest with all plainness — that antisemitism then described as Jewish, that it sought, as an adversary, to lay at the door of Judaism. How often indeed has it happened that the reprehensible deeds of one Jew have been scored up against the whole community. Have not the spokesmen of Judaism always rightly resisted the generalisation? Have they not often enough themselves been able to demonstrate by examples the method of these imputations? Have they not always drawn a sharp distinction between the Jews and Judaism? Well then, these were the same gentlemen who today condemn us because the antisemites have played their old game once more. Let them, then, distinguish between Judaism, which its enemies reproach, and the individual Jews who deserve these reproaches. For that they themselves happen to be these individual Jews gives them no right to turn their own logic inside out.
It has always been refused to identify oneself with those who brought shame upon Judaism. We have declared again and again that we wish to have no fellowship with the people who by their manner of life compromise their people more than any member of an alien name could. We know best of all that a solidarity for the protection of the evil-doers among us exists only in the imagination of our enemies. Why, then, does this official Judaism, which never practised the duties of such a solidarity, now wish to enjoy its rights? Why does it follow antisemitism so very readily along that line of thought which studiously refuses to see the distinctions? It is convenient to let one's own faults be hypocritically set down to the account of the whole community, and then to prove that the community is wronged. But that proves too much, and therefore nothing at all. It was harder to bring proof against our more narrowly defined assertions, and it was therefore scarcely even attempted. That has taken its revenge. In the place of the opponents stepped the enemies and struck with sharper blows: they are not choice in their means and hit wherever they chance to strike.
To the remonstrances of the Jews they remained deaf; the invectives of the antisemites now ring shrilly in their ears. The voice of conscience only the enemy could awaken. And if a turn for the better springs from this, the antisemites will have been of service to the Jews Certainly against their will. But that they only now feel is a disgrace to those who formerly would not hear.
d.
A Russian Priest on Zionism.
The Russian priest Grigorij Spiridonowitsch Petrow is counted among the eminent and popular personalities of modern Russia. Years ago Petrow published an interesting book under the title "The Gospel as the Foundation of Life," in which a profound love of mankind was preached. All his later publicist writings, too, bore the stamp of a singular and matured talent devoted to the welfare of man. Father Petrow turned especially great attention to the Jews. In order to learn to know the Jews in their everyday life, Petrow travelled through Russia, Galicia and even America, and studied in particular the Ghetto of New York. A few months ago the noble priest published a longer article on the Jews in Galicia, which was vividly commented upon by the Russian daily press. In this article, entitled "A Jewish Empire," Petrow endeavoured to portray truthfully the situation and the characteristics of our brethren in Galicia, and to protest energetically against the Jew-baiting which is everywhere gaining in extent.
With this popular priest an editor of the Petersburg "Nowosti" recently had a conversation on Zionism and its ever-increasing successes.
What Father Petrow said, on the ground of his long experience and observation, concerning the worth of the Jewish masses is calculated only to encourage the adherents of Zionism in their struggle for the realisation of the great idea, and to disarm the opponents of Zionism. And even the few objections which Father Petrow raises against the practical side of Zionism speak in favour of the idea.
Father Petrow said, among other things, the following: "The Zionist movement is known to me in general and broad outline. The moral, universally human side of this movement interests me in the first place, just as in the Jewish question generally it is chiefly this side that interests me. As a man, as a Christian and as a priest I am deeply grieved by the persecution that has been opened against an entire nation. Our judgment of the Jews is superficial and short-sighted. I know
