Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 29 · 18 July 1902
4printed page
scan 4 of 16

Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 29


(continued from page 3)

…day pressure. A man who does not know what it means to be a free man says: "I am not persecuted," so long as his head has not been beaten sore. He understands by persecution what would be truly terrible for us.

Major Gordon: Do you mean that it is the economic conditions of the 16 provinces which form the Pale of Settlement of the Jews in Russia that produce this oppression, or is it a consequence of the persecution that the Jews in Russia are concentrated in the 16 provinces?

Dr. Herzl: The Jews of Russia live in a state of fearful misery. To this is added the fact that they cannot improve their situation, for they are not permitted to go to another town where they might find work. Besides, the Jew lives in perpetual fear.

Major Gordon: I believe that another cause brings them here. I find that there is a tendency to fetch over their relatives and acquaintances.

Dr. Herzl: If you have a friend, and you come into better climes and conditions, you will write to him: "My friend! Here I am happier than I was yesterday." Whether one can call that fetching, I do not know. Moreover, we have newspapers to-day, and all these people read their newspapers and know what conditions of life exist here.

Major Gordon: You say that to send the people back to their country would be persecution?

Dr. Herzl: It would be cruel.

Major Gordon: You state in your evidence that a considerable number were sent back by the Jewish communities.

Dr. Herzl: I do not believe that it was done out of wanton cruelty. They were so unprepared. They did not believe in what took place at the First Zionist Congress in the year 1897. We received from Roumania alone 5258 petitions from 37043 persons, who implored us for help, as they found themselves in the direst need. That was in 1897. — Only in the year 1900 did the emigration of the needy and the starving begin. The cry for help was thus three years old when they set themselves in motion. The charitable bodies of the Jewish communities did not take that cry seriously enough; they were wholly unprepared, they were perplexed.

Major Gordon: Have you any proof that we have an anti-Jewish feeling or current here?

Dr. Herzl: I gathered it from the evidence that has been given before this Commission.

Major Gordon: Would you call a restriction of the number persecution?

Dr. Herzl: It depends upon the way you take. It is a loyal self-defence if you defend yourselves in a lawful and humane way.

Major Gordon: Has anyone ever thought of withdrawing the least privilege which the Jews possess in England?

Dr. Herzl: I have heard nothing of it.

Major Gordon: Is not what we consider necessary in order to prevent an unrestricted accumulation of the poorest part of your people fully compatible with the greatest freedom of the Jews?

Dr. Herzl: I should not wish to be King's evidence against Jews in any matter.

Major Gordon: The Jewish community was the only restricting body; it was the community which sent Jews back from these countries, from better into worse conditions. You surely will not maintain that the Jewish community is in any way Antisemitic?

Dr. Herzl: Certain things which you may do or say to members of your own family would be an insult coming from others.

Major Gordon states that the inquiry began merely with the Jews and has continued to concern itself only with them because the majority of the immigrants are Jews. That does not yet mean that the other immigrants are not also being taken into consideration. It is a fact, and must be a source of grievance, when our people are driven from their homes by strangers come from afar who offer them competition. A cry for restriction of immigration would be raised just the same if, for example, a great number of Chinese were to appear here. You regard this from a purely Jewish point of view, but have we Englishmen not the same duty towards our own people as towards the poor oppressed of other countries?

Dr. Herzl: No doubt! But what makes the question so painful is that all other peoples have a homeland to which they can go back, and the Jews have none.

Major Gordon: But that is to some extent discounted by the fact that some hundreds of Jews are sent back every year by the Jewish people themselves to the homeland that is none.

Dr. Herzl: It was, in my opinion, a great mistake on the part of the Jewish communities to do this, and it is avenged in that you, Major Gordon, or another gentleman can now say: If the Jewish community has done it, shall we not do it?

Major Gordon: You say in another part of your evidence that these people cannot live in the places from which they come. I maintain that the fact of their being sent back there proves that there are places where they can live, because they do live there.

Dr. Herzl: There are differing views about the conditions under which a man can live.

Major Gordon: Another point connected with this is that some of these people make a point of being sent back. How is it compatible with what you have said, that a man should demand to be sent back to where he is persecuted?

Dr. Herzl: Assuredly I do not say that all these Jews are angels or gentlemen. That brings us to the question of the schnorrers. They look about to see where there is a charitable shelter, and make the detour so as to be able to stay there for some time.

With reference to the black cloud rising in the East, of which he made mention in his evidence, Dr. Herzl says that the state of things there is now much worse than at the time when he wrote his pamphlet. In Galicia 700,000 Jews live in a state of the deepest misery. The housing conditions there are far more dreadful than the worst in the East End of London. Often 4 families live and sleep there in one small room. The immigration into England of such people, who have the aptitude to rise economically,