Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 29 · 18 July 1902
5printed page
scan 5 of 16

No. 29 — "Die Welt" — Page 5.

(continued from page 4)

…may be disagreeable for their neighbours, but for the community as a whole it can only be of advantage.

Maj. Gordon: Do you believe that a Jewish question has arisen in this country?

Dr. Herzl: I think the difficulty exists, since you find yourselves obliged to discuss it.

Maj. Gordon: What, in your forecast, will be the result of laissez faire?

Dr. Herzl: I do not like to prophesy.

Maj. Gordon: You maintain that the question is only in its initial stage, and that the tendency exists for more and more of your people to come into this country.

Dr. Herzl: Certainly! So I think.

Maj. Gordon: Unlike the heads of the several Jewish communities in the various countries, you regard this great question from the standpoint of Jewish nationalism.

Dr. Herzl: Certainly!

Maj. Gordon: That is the difference between you and the others.

Dr. Herzl: Certainly!

Maj. Gordon: In your opinion, does Jewish nationalism bind together those Jews who share your views?

Dr. Herzl: In what sense?

Maj. Gordon: Devotion to the Jewish nation and to the Jewish idea.

Dr. Herzl: Certainly.

Lord Rothschild: Would it not be best to ask Dr. Herzl what his views are about a Jewish nation?

Maj. Gordon: Would you not state briefly what your views on Jewish nationalism are?

Dr. Herzl: I will give you my definition of a nation, and you can add the adjective "Jewish." A nation, in my view, is a historical group of men of a recognisable cohesion, held together by a common enemy.

Maj. Gordon: Who in this case would be the common enemy?

Dr. Herzl: Antisemitism.

Maj. Gordon: Under these circumstances, and with people who share these views regarding the Jewish nation and are politically devoted to the Jewish State — do you consider complete assimilation with the English community possible?

Dr. Herzl: Certainly! I believe that assimilation is quite possible, although I do not say that it is desirable. You have the historical example of the Huguenots, who emigrated to Germany on account of the persecutions of the Protestants in France, and you have many families with German names — I need only remind you of General Zurlinden — which have become completely assimilated in France.

Maj. Gordon: I believe there is no analogy between the Huguenots and your people. The Huguenots were people who intermingled by marriage, and through these mixed marriages have been wholly absorbed by the German population surrounding them. With the Jews this is not the case.

Dr. Herzl: Then it is thereby proved that the Jews do not wish to be wholly assimilated.

Maj. Gordon: Do you believe that the support and hospitality shown to the oppressed Jews from Roumania and Russian Poland involve any danger, through competition, to the working classes in England?

Dr. Herzl: No, I do not believe so! Why should charity bring harm to others?

Maj. Gordon: Nor do you believe in the remedy of dispersion?

Dr. Herzl: No!

Maj. Gordon: You believe that the efforts of the Jewish Board of Guardians (Jewish Charity Office) and of the Russian Committee here are in vain?

Dr. Herzl: They are not able to cope with the distress.

Maj. Gordon: Baron Hirsch left great endowments for the Jewish people?

Dr. Herzl: Certainly!

Maj. Gordon: Have these endowments increased or diminished the evil?

Dr. Herzl: I believe that they are pretty well indifferent to it.

Maj. Gordon: They have had no effect in either the one direction or the other?

Dr. Herzl: None! In relation to the enormous question they are nothing. A drop in the ocean. At most they provide for schools and for a few small agricultural stations.

Maj. Gordon: Do they not do some good, or is the money wasted?

Dr. Herzl: Pretty well wasted.

Maj. Gordon: The money is used to send a part of the Jews to the Argentine?

Dr. Herzl: Certainly!

Maj. Gordon: And a part to Palestine as well?

Dr. Herzl: No!

Maj. Gordon: Has nothing been given to the Zionist movement?

Dr. Herzl: Oh, no!

Maj. Gordon: Has the attempt to settle the Jews in a country reserved for them failed?

Dr. Herzl: It is a failure, because such things cannot be done with money alone. To found a great settlement one must have a flag and an idea. These were not present; therefore no success could come.

Maj. Gordon: I have been told that the Baron Hirsch endowments rather have the effect of increasing the number of those whom you call schnorrers?

Dr. Herzl: I believe so indeed! People know that there is money there, and they come flocking.

Maj. Gordon: And have a way to it?

Dr. Herzl: Certainly! That is so natural; I believe it is not merely Jewish.

Maj. Gordon: I agree with you. Do you know of any pressure that has been brought to bear upon the Russian Government to improve the conditions of existence of the Jews who live under that Government?

Dr. Herzl: Certainly. There exists in this country a current, which you here call public opinion, that has this aim. Since the times of antiquity there has been no example of helots, but the Jews in Russia are in fact helots or pariahs.

For the rest, Dr. Herzl prefers, as to various questions put to him whereby his