Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 29 · 18 July 1902
3printed page
scan 3 of 16

No. 29 — "Die Welt" — Page 3

Dr. Herzl: I was myself an assimilated Jew, and I speak from experience. I think that the Jews have a natural tendency to assimilate. Then there comes a moment when they are well on the way to it, and precisely at that moment Antisemitism arises. History teaches us that the Jews never lived under happier conditions than in Spain before the Inquisition and the emigration. They attained everything they wanted and could have everything they wished.

Mr. Norman: A fundamental difference between your view and that of certain other influential Jews consists, then, in this, that they wish to hasten the process of assimilation, whereas you desire Jewish nationality.

Dr. Herzl: You must leave it to every man to decide for himself whether he will assimilate or not. It is not right to influence people, either by the putting forward of arguments or by compelling them to it by force.

Mr. Norman: You have frankly admitted that, as soon as these immigrants have reached a considerable number, they become a disturbance and a burden?

Dr. Herzl: There are economic causes at work in this, which have already been set forth by people who know the conditions intimately.

Mr. Norman: In your view, then, this growth causes a "disturbance and burden"?

Dr. Herzl: But not because they are Jews with special Jewish peculiarities. You may perhaps remember that in the year 1892 or 1893 in France the presence of a certain number of Italian workmen provoked serious riots against them, although the two nationalities are linked by close racial kinship. The riots arise merely from economic causes.

Questioned further upon this point, Doctor Herzl says: It is a fact that these immigrants, being cheaper workers, create economic difficulties. They can work more cheaply, since they come out of unspeakable conditions. The burden can be combated solely and alone by diverting the stream into such channels as will bring the people, not by compulsion, but in a manner suited to them, into better conditions of life. The question can be solved solely and alone at the source of the immigration. The means which are proposed to prevent an inundation are insufficient. And if the local question is cleared away in that manner, then only the symptom would be cured and not the disease. Only the following is possible: either you wish to protect native labour, which claims to be injured, or you shut the gates against the most wretched and pitiable of all men.

The Chairman: Will the witness accept the old Latin proverb: Melius est petere fontes quam sectari rivulos? (You must go to the source if you wish to stop up the brook.)

Dr. Herzl: Certainly!

Mr. Norman: You stated that the fact of this Commission sitting makes it indispensable that something should be done?

Dr. Herzl: Certainly!

Mr. Norman: Having begun self-defence, we should have to go further?

Dr. Herzl: In self-defence or in help? — And I think the best self-defence and the best help at once would be a generous and largely conceived measure, which I shall take the liberty of laying before you for your consideration.

Mr. Norman: You hold, then, that the circumstance that the Commission has been appointed is a great warning from this country to the immigrants, and that if nothing is done their number will grow more rapidly than before? Since we have now been appointed, it is therefore all the more desirable to do something.

Dr. Herzl: Certainly!

Mr. Norman: You think, then, that it was well that we were appointed, and you congratulate us upon it?

Dr. Herzl: Certainly! For in other countries, for example in free America, they have simply shut the gates, and I think you did well to endeavour first to grasp the situation.

Mr. Norman: You understand, consequently, that it is not from want of sympathy that I do not put questions of various kinds to you. I have been as brief as possible and turn my attention solely to the main points.

Dr. Herzl: Certainly!

Questions put by Major Gordon.

Major Gordon: With regard to the persecutions, I should like you to make clear to me what ground there is for asserting that the Jewish immigration into this country arises solely and chiefly in consequence of persecutions.

Dr. Herzl: It is not solely and alone persecutions that bring about the immigration. I think man has a natural tendency to cling to the soil, if he has soil. There are exceptions. These are young people, adventurers, merchants, who wish to discover or open up new parts of the world. But the average man tends rather to remain in his homeland. I cannot say that it is persecution alone which brings all the immigrants here, for among those who come there are also adventurers and young people who wish to see the world, just as young Englishmen go to India, China or elsewhere. But I believe that the fathers of families who come here come solely and alone when they find themselves in deep depression. A man who has a family does not lightly change his domicile.

Major Gordon: Have you ever been in the Russian Pale of Settlement?

Dr. Herzl: No! But I receive numerous letters from those parts, which give me all the necessary information.

Major Gordon: I should only like to know what persecutions exist at present?

Dr. Herzl: It is an economic boycott. If that is persecution, then they are persecuted. This question takes many forms. In one place they are persecuted administratively, in another with the help of the law. One sees local persecutions in one town, and in another the general conditions of life are intolerable. But everywhere the Jew is the scapegoat, the whipping-boy. And one day he will no longer be so, and seeks out another clime.

Major Gordon: Are you aware of the fact that the Russo-Jewish Committee, or its President Mr. N. S. Joseph, has stated that not in one case out of ten, in applications for relief, do the petitioners assert that they are persecuted?

Dr. Herzl: There are outbreaks of persecution, which occur only rarely, and then there is long, all-