No. 28 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…to consider. Even if the Jew were ready for it — a very large supposition — how can one imagine that the people who will not tolerate us as neighbours would unite with us as members of their families? And when I speak of the remedy of intermarriage, it rests on the supposition that this remedy should develop into a universal policy, and not remain confined to isolated cases of intermarriage. But before the remedy of intermarriage could prove effective, the whole condition of the Jews would have to be different; at the least they would have to be regarded throughout the world with other feelings than those which prevail to-day; and on the day on which the world should recognise the true worth of the Jews in so high a degree, it would also recognise our worth as a distinct entity and give us the right to exist as a distinct people, by granting us our rightful place among the nations of the world.
Either we should intermarry before the world is ready to receive us, and, by sharpening feeling against our entry into non-Jewish circles, only conjure up mischief; or we should do so when the world is ready to receive us. But then there would no longer be any occasion for it, for it would mean the destruction of a people which the world has learned to acknowledge and respect and should strive to preserve. I have for a moment discussed the subject on the assumption that our people were inclined to intermarry. But there is nothing to which the great majority of our people clings more than to the sentiments to which marriages are subject. Intermarriage is not regarded with aversion — not even by the Orthodox — when the person who enters into a mixed marriage with the Jew or Jewess likewise becomes a Jewess or Jew. There remains, therefore, the solution which I indicated in my pamphlet "Der Judenstaat." Naturally I should not now wish to write again what I wrote then in its entirety, in the same words or in its individual points. At that time no Congress of Jews had taken place; since then there have been five. At that time I wrote without knowledge of what I have since learned from conversations with Jews; at that time I wrote in no official position. But the principle has remained upright. The solution of the Jewish question lies in the recognition of the Jews as a people, and in their finding a legally recognised home, whither Jews from those parts of the world in which they are oppressed would naturally migrate; for they would arrive there as citizens, precisely because they are Jews, and not as aliens.
As a result, the stream of emigrants would thereby be diverted from this country and from America, where they become a burden as soon as they grow to a perceptible number, to a land where the best interests would be served by finding room for the greatest possible number. If the Jews are there granted their legal position as a people, I am convinced that they will develop a specifically Jewish culture, national character and national aspirations, which would conduce to the elevation of mankind.
Perhaps it is not for me to direct the attention of the Commission to this branch of the subject, which possibly lies wholly outside the present inquiry; but I am firmly convinced that the problem which the Commission is called upon to investigate and report upon cannot be solved otherwise than by the adoption of the principle that the stream of emigrants, which must continue in increasing measure from Eastern Europe, is to be diverted.
The Jews of Eastern Europe cannot remain where they now are; where are they to go? If they are not wanted here, then a place must be found to which they can emigrate; otherwise the problem is created with which you are here occupied. These problems, however, do not arise if a home is found which is legally recognised as Jewish. And I submit to the Commission — whether it can influence the solution of the question or not — that it should not omit to take this solution into consideration and to bestow upon it the high value of its opinion. So far as the Jews are concerned, I have no hesitation in asserting that the solution is practical and feasible. It is, above all else, the one which the unhappy Jews themselves would welcome. This solution would receive their most earnest co-operation, because their hopeless misery is the cause of disturbances with which they themselves, but also this Commission, have at present to deal.
*
In supplement to his principal evidence before the Commission, and in answer to various questions of the members of the Commission called forth by his remarks, Dr. Herzl added that the force which brings the Jewish immigrants into this country is moral rather than material in nature. They seek here a refuge from the persecutions which drive them out of their native lands. Men with families do not leave the land of their birth of their own free will. An Englishman cannot comprehend the fearful conditions which prevail in Roumania and Galicia. The Jews there live in continual, paralysing dread, and literally go about in fear for their lives. Their persecutions are not merely the outcome of the hatred of the ignorant people in whose midst they live; they are administrative as well as legal. In Roumania a Jew is excluded from the civil professions, and naturalisation is not granted him, even if his forefathers were born in the country. The Jew is treated as an alien and can be naturalised only by a special Act of Parliament. Of 250,000 Roumanian Jews, according to Dr. Herzl's information, only 300 have been naturalised. It is therefore only natural that they seek a home in a free country such as England is, whose name is to them synonymous with freedom. They follow the line of least resistance. The danger is that with the perceptible increase of the alien population in this country antisemitism would arise. And antisemitism would be good neither for this country nor for the Jews. Local remedies in the East End of London will not, he believes, remedy the evil. Distribution of the aliens into the various parts of the country would lead merely to a multiplication of the evil. Besides, if help is given to the aliens in order to remove them from the overcrowded East End of London, this would lead to their seeking assistance in the future. He does not believe, however, that charity is the way to administer; though undoubtedly good in itself, it destroys self-reliance. Further, he considers that the solution of the question cannot be found in assimilation either; even if the Jews were willing to intermarry, their Christian neighbours would not. Wherever assimilation has attained a certain extent, there antisemitism is all the greater, as France and Spain bear witness. The only remedy is nationalism, or Zionism. That would most effectually divert the stream of immigration. The Jew would then have a home which is dear and precious to him through a thousand historical ties; a home into which