No. 46 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 9.
(continued from page 4)
…which there passed to Egypt was a piece of Palestine! A thousand square kilometres of Palestine are more than the thirtieth part of the whole country. If Palestine should be capable of receiving three million people, then, at an equal density of population, this piece would be large enough for a hundred thousand! And if it were large enough for only ten or five thousand Jews, that too would already mean something — we are not rich enough in people and in land to give away light-heartedly, or to leave out of account, thousands of human beings, or a piece of Palestine upon which they might live. The thousands who might live there — in security, in sufficiency, and with a future for themselves and their children — these thousands are lost to us to-day to Canada or to Argentina, or go to ruin in the misery of Eastern Europe!
This piece of Palestine, of whose existence no one knows — these thousands of Jews, of whom no one will know anything — these factors yield the long and ardently desired possibility for the beginning of Zionist action!
*
The land lies — seen from Turkish Palestine — before the Nachal Mizrajim, the narrower boundary of Erez Israel. It begins midway between Gaza and the "Brook of Egypt", at the place Tel-Refah (Raphia), and forms a coastal strip of over 40 km in length which reaches some 25 km inland. This gives — 40X25 — about 1000 km². The territory is at present very thinly peopled. Upon the Nachal Mizrajim, which to-day is called Wadi-el-Arisch, but upon the side towards Egypt, lies the town and fortress of El-Arisch, which is the seat of an Egyptian governor and has 3000 inhabitants — for a region so poor in men, a great city!
The land is not very fertile. But it has been fertile, and will become so again. We need only think of the colonies in Palestine. At present hardly 1000 Bedouins and fellaheen will be dwelling there. The barley land of Gaza reaches into the territory; upon the larger maps (for example those of the "Palestine Exploration Fund" of 1890) a number of villages, ruins, watercourses, wells and groups of palms are marked. The Turkish telegraph line and the great pilgrim road lead through it.
They do not lead through it by chance. And therein lies the great significance of this "piece of desert", as it will be called by those who have never known anything of it, but who are afraid of the beginning of the action. This piece of "Egyptian Palestine" is the only bridge which connects Africa with the rest of the old world — with Asia and with Europe. As the pilgrim road and the telegraph line do to-day, so in a few years will the connecting railway roll across this bridge — the railway which must and will link the great African continental line Capetown — Cairo with the Euphrates railway, and further with the Orient Express and the Trans-Siberian line. This intercontinental connecting railway, however, is of importance not only as such, but as the most important railway line of Palestine. It joins all the coast places between Beyrout and Port-Said; it will multiply the tourist traffic, which to-day is extraordinarily hampered by the unfavourable harbour conditions of Jaffa; it will give the colonies, which all lie in great nearness to the coast, new outlets for their goods; and it will help our "Egyptian Palestine" to an undreamed-of importance, for this territory lies between the great Syrian and Egyptian markets and is predestined to supply them — with the help of Jewish industry, which has proved itself brilliantly in New-York and London and in many other places — with manufactured wares. All that has been said of the industrial and commercial possibilities of Palestine in general holds good of this forgotten part of the country in particular, and for the present almost exclusively. Here immigration is permitted; nothing stands in the way of the erection of factories. The markets are near, transport is cheap, wages can be low, the customs duties are — in part at least — to go, bakshish is unknown. The Egyptian government is progressive, the security sufficient, autonomy of the individual settlements provided for in the law of the land.
Industrial colonisation — at least alongside the agricultural — is the great problem of the immediate present.
The question of Jewish migration, the policy of colonisation forced upon us, has to reckon with great masses of men for whom only very little land is to be had. An extensive agriculture, such as is carried on in Argentina, cannot for these and for other reasons come into consideration for the Orient at the present time. But even a more intensive husbandry, as in Palestine, can be drawn upon only in a small degree for the solution of the question. It is well known how few Jews can be helped by the way of agricultural colonisation in Palestine with, let us say, a million francs: — some 50 families!
That is no sound proportion. With the high value of money in the Orient these 50 families could live upon the interest of this million francs, if not very luxuriously. With the same sum 50 merchants might already carry on business to a considerable extent. As independent artisans a far greater number of Jews could be established for the same money; — by far the greatest multitude of men, however, could earn their livelihood with the assumed sum by the way of industrial colonisation. Cases are not rare even in Europe in which, in an industrial undertaking, one workman and more falls to every 1000 francs of working capital.
The question as to the most suitable kind of colonisation thus answers itself entirely, if only one has formulated it rightly, namely: By what way is the greatest number to be helped with the least means?
Industrial colonisation has yet this other great advantage over the agricultural, that by far the most Jewish emigrants were either already industrially employed in their native lands, or work their way into these callings in a surprisingly short time, as daily experience in the hitherto countries of emigration, England and America, has taught. Besides, we do not, as is well known, lack industrial and commercial experts, while of such in the agricultural field there prevails a painful dearth.
In natural development agriculture does indeed precede industry in time. But we no longer live in such primitive times, and it now happens often enough that a country is first opened up industrially, and that only in consequence of the influx of men does agriculture pay better than the covering of the demand from abroad.
If, then, we concede the eminent fitness of industrial colonisation, there would remain no ground for holding this piece of "Egyptian Palestine" to be of less worth than the Turkish parts of the country — even if the importance of the tract for communications, as well as the circumstance that it stands under Anglo-Egyptian administration, did not speak loudly in its favour.
In conclusion, however, it seems to me fitting to point out once more that at the present time, just as then, when the first Palestinian colonies were founded, the first question that must be asked is whether a piece of land is to be had, and only then whether it be also fertile. For fertility can be compelled where it is absolutely needful. One of the most fertile little lands of the earth is the island group of Malta, which our cousins, the Phoenicians, at the time when Israel was still ruled by Judges, found as a naked rock. These culture-engineers of the grandest style covered the rock with earth imported from Sicily, and to-day the island group, with 175,000 inhabitants upon its 323 km² of surface, is the most populous land in the world!
For the three times larger "El Arisch" we need cherish no dreams of the future of that kind in order to make there to-day a well-prepared beginning; but made it should be, as swiftly and as earnestly and as comprehensively as possible.
A Zionist Debate in the London Maccabaean Club.
The Club had invited Dr. M. Bernstein to speak upon the theme "The Menace to Jewish Society in England through the Persecution of the Jews in Russia and Roumania". The lecture took place on Sunday the 3rd inst. After Dr. Bernstein had described the conditions, he came to the discussion of the possible solutions: "I say that another asylum for the Jews is needful, an asylum as a last resting-place, a place of their own, a home, a land of their own. I am grieved over the chameleon-like assimilation of our people, and everyone who still harbours a glimmer of self-respect within him,is so with me. To assimilate oneself to Arabs, Germans, Slavs, Celts, Poles, to assimilate oneself to Roumania, to become a Hungarian or an Argen-
