Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 46.
(continued from page 3)
…one must in the end reckon it among the scientific impossibilities.
The use of the conception of culture has indeed sprung very far away from its original meaning. By this time we understand by culture neither more nor less than the whole life of the soul in all its forms of expression. In the end everything belongs to it, from the highest forms of art down to the taste which expresses itself in fashion; from the deepest currents of the sciences down, for aught I care, to the manner in which one handles knife and fork at table. So infinite, so inconceivably wide is the conception of culture even in itself.
And now, above all, the boundaries of a "national" culture. Where is one to stake them out? Where is one to stake them out in particular to-day, all culture has become an article of export and import of the first rank? Whatever has entered, so to speak, into the great exchange of the world-market has from the outset given up much of its distinctive character. Beyond doubt: through the incessant international exchange of cultural contents and cultural forms the boundaries of the several national cultures become very shiftable. Meanwhile, as has been said, it does not occur to me to deny the existence of pronounced national cultures. But I maintain that the conception of a national culture is to be reached only from the conception of race. I must first know the distinctive character of a race in order to find out the characteristic marks of the distinctive character of its culture. In no other way can one get at the matter.
Years ago I already expressed the fundamental problem of Zionism as a culture-creating factor in this way: that Zionism, in giving us a nation consolidated upon its own soil, will thereby urge us precisely to the forming of a culture of our own. And that is what we lack. The Jews are beyond doubt in great numbers men of culture of the very first rank, but only in the sense of a choice and abstract Europeanism. The earthy savour of autochthony is entirely wanting in the contents of their culture. Whoever among Jewish men of culture — of the higher style — denies this has looked too little deeply into his own soul.
Certainly Lublinski is right in asserting that he "bears in his soul" more German education, and for aught I care German culture pure and simple, than any brutal fellow "who is descended in a direct line from Hermann the Cheruscan." But therewith he has already, quite involuntarily, expressed the profound difference: that coarse fellow bears little in his soul, but his soul is borne. The Jew takes culture into himself from without; with the primitive German it grows organically from within outwards. The fundamental error in all these self-deceptions lies in the confusion of education with culture pure and simple; more precisely, of superstructure with root. This root, precisely, must come from Hermann the Cheruscan, if not in a direct, then at least in a collateral line. For herein race, blood and the other "dark powers" are exclusively determinative.
And truly, when I call Lublinski to mind — how years ago he would discuss half nights and whole nights through with me, after we had left the sittings of "Jung-Israel"; how by fits and starts and hotly he speculated upon general problems, as though he bore both Talmuds, with all that hangs upon them and about them, in his brain — then I could almost swear that of us two neither was a German, although we had in us more German education and educational interests than many a beer-sodden primitive-German fellow who at once — without much reflection — recognised the Jews in us and for that reason railed at us.
No, Lublinski's whole spiritual habit is not of primitive German cultural descent. Decidedly not. But that so weak, so transparent a self-deception can suffice for a Lublinski to fall away inwardly from Zionism is one of those anomalies of the soul which prove again and again how little deeply many a West European Jew absorbs Zionism into himself.
Egyptian Palestine.
By B. Ebenstein.
The forthcoming Congress is likely to become a working Congress such as none of the previous ones has been. The opening of the Bank, the weaker attendance conditioned by the season of the year, an improved order of business, and much else make possible a more matter-of-fact treatment of the questions that arise, so that at least all the preliminary conditions are given which can lead to more serious results. One of the most important themes of the coming Congress may here find a sort of preliminary discussion.
It is to be hoped that those of whom it must be expected will bring with them to the Congress an adequate knowledge of the country and of its conditions. Certain, however, it is that the great mass, which hitherto had seen Palestine only with the feeling, to which the mere name of the ancient home was a sweet sound and for which the present condition of the territory was of quite subordinate importance — that this mass will hear astonishingly new things.
For the first time within Zionist memory the question will be discussed before the great public: What is Palestine, what are its boundaries, under whose sovereignty or administration does the country stand, with whom have we to negotiate?
At the first glance it will seem as though these questions had long been answered — in reality they were never put. And now, when the question is put loudly and clearly, we shall receive wholly new answers.
First of all the question: Was Palestine always the same country, bounded in the same way? Here we already come to a stand. There is and there was scarcely a little country, scarcely a world-empire, that was at all times of the same size and had the same boundaries. How have Greece, Rome, the German Empire — how have these countries been small, grown great, grown smaller again, and again increased, in the constant change of history? And is Palestine alone to be a territory that has remained the same, to be a designation at which everyone can think only of the same boundaries? We know: it is not so — we know that there are several boundaries — we know that the customary conception marks off a territory which at no time, in precisely this extent, was the historical Palestine.
But we do not wish here to bring forward any purposeless disquisitions. We do not wish to speak to-day of the boundaries as they are to be found in the promise to Abraham; for when we speak of the Nile and the Euphrates as boundaries we lose ourselves in the — at least for the moment — impracticable. Still less do we wish to speak to-day of the boundaries of the Jewish land which existed in the last times of our national history, when the Jewish people, through dispersion and emigration into the neighbouring countries and through a renewed access of strength and a peaceful expansion, had become a compact national whole which had grown far beyond the boundaries of the small ancestral land that had become too narrow — to the Palestine of the customary conception we will confine our discussion to-day, and here make discoveries!
Palestine borders upon Egyptian territory. Between the two countries there lies no other lord's land, nor any ownerless land either! Where the boundary of Palestine is, there too the immediate possession of the Sultan ceases. The Turkish and the Palestinian boundaries are at this point approximately identical. Only approximately — not entirely! Entirely identical they were down to the year 1887. In that year a very insignificant regulation of the boundary took place. Egypt received about 1000 km² of Turkish territory on the sea-coast; a somewhat larger piece of hitherto Egyptian territory, which lay more in the interior, became Turkish in exchange. As has been said, a very insignificant regulation of the boundary — at least for two countries like Egypt and Turkey with their immeasurable territories.
For us the matter looks otherwise. The piece of Turkey
