Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 41.
(continued from page 3)
…ducers, however, will not possess the means to procure themselves the machines, and the machines are precisely the worst enemies of handicraft. From all this I refrain at once. But does Jewish handicraft suffer under the competition of great industry? By no means. The Jewish handicraftsmen of Eastern Europe go hungry because there is a superfluity of handicraftsmen. In the district of Minsk, for example, there falls one master handicraftsman to every seventh town-dweller. Here no productive co-operative can be of use.
There was talk also of the strengthening of the middleman's trade and of the founding of credit unions. I will leave out of account at once that it in no wise lies in the sense of the Zionist movement to breed the type of the Jewish middleman. I will leave out of account also that, on the contrary, the purpose and task of the Zionist movement ought to be, not only to call a Jewish society into life, but also to bring about the alteration of the economic mode of life of the Jews, to make out of the Jewish people of petty traders and handicraftsmen a people working in agriculture and in industry. From this too I refrain. But can the middleman's trade be strengthened at all? Is not the misery of the middlemen to be traced back to this, that to every two houses there is one shop? And the credit unions? To whom are they to grant credit? To the handicraftsmen or traders who, in consequence of the relative over-population, have no sale for their goods? Has not the history of the industrial and people's banks hitherto, in the far better situated Western Europe, shown us that the banks must either come to a crash if they concern themselves with the little people, or must develop into great-capitalist institutions if they wish to exist.
There remain, then, the consumers' unions. How consumers' unions can help the Jewish masses is unintelligible to me. The consumers' unions are to protect the consumers, and in particular the workers, from exploitation by the middleman's trade, the purpose of the consumers' unions is to abolish the trader's profit from the world. And now for once the consumers' unions are to help the Jewish traders! Are they perhaps to protect the Jewish handicraftsman or worker from the Jewish middleman? With that I might in the end declare myself in agreement. But what will the great mass of the Jewish middlemen say to it?
Certainly I grant that, so soon as Jewish colonies were founded, it would have to lie in the interest of a sound social policy to organise the colonists as producers in the agricultural, as consumers in the consumers' co-operatives; that every colony should have its savings and loan fund, and that the union of all the funds should form the collective people's bank. But the present Jewish misery can in no wise be relieved by co-operatives. The economic questions which ought to occupy us are of a quite different kind. We must above all procure for ourselves exact knowledge of the land in which colonisation is to be carried on. We must further study the conditions quite exactly, in order to know what produce can be produced, but also whether for these products a market would then be at hand. We must be clear concerning the mode, the manner and way of the colonisation, concerning all the important questions of economic and colonial policy.
To be sure, these questions can be solved by no commissions, even though the commissions were to be permanent committees composed of experts. For the solution of this question a permanent authority is necessary, a ministry of national economy sui generis, a Jewish colonisation secretariat. Upon this I will express myself in a next article.
(Note of the Editors. We give these interesting expositions of our Zurich comrade in conviction without wholly identifying ourselves with their content.)
Contributions to the Knowledge of Palestine.
By A. Aaronsohn and Dr. S. Soskin (Zichron-Jacob). (Communications of the "Agronomic and Cultural-Technical Bureau for Palestine".)
Led by the wish to become more exactly acquainted on the spot with the Arab cultivation of the vine, we betook ourselves to Es-Salt, the most important place of its production. Es-Salt and Transjordania in general are so seldom deemed worthy of a visit by tourists, and especially by Jewish ones (if indeed such exist at all), that we believe we are meeting a want in here depicting our impressions of travel for the Zionist public, keeping the practical interest above all in view.
Our journey comprised four great stages: we went from Zichron-Jacob first to Nabulus; thence we turned to the Transjordanian region, namely Es-Salt; then, after our return from Es-Salt, we descended from Nabulus into the region of Beisan, in order from there to take the homeward way to Zichron-Jacob.
In view of the fact that few readers of this journal are likely to belong to our profession, we shall in the course of our expositions employ as few specially technical expressions as possible. Of the flora we shall indicate no more than what belongs to the characterisation of the district, while at the same time bringing forward those representatives of it which deserve particular attention by reason of their present usefulness, or through the important part which may lie before them in the agricultural future of our land.
In the same way we shall prefer, where needful, in the exact description of the soil structure of the districts visited by us, to set forth in detail the characteristic properties of the soil rather than to operate cursorily with geological and mineralogical termini. Our articles will perhaps lose thereby in scientific quality, but they will certainly become accessible to the understanding of most readers. We will, however, confess at the outset as well: we should often be in embarrassment if we had to designate by their geological names the soil formations of which we propose to attempt an exact description.
Even though it be the duty of the agronomist to know the characteristic properties of the kinds of soil which have arisen through this or that geological formation or stratification, yet one may not demand of him the knowledge of the specialist, who alone is called to undertake a geological classification.
For the greater part of the European countries there exist very detailed geological maps. The task of the agronomist appears greatly lightened. By the help of the said maps he studies the formation to which belongs the district in which he is called to work, the various soil-forming strata, the rock which characterises them, and so forth. Nothing remains for him but to draw the conclusions to which his special knowledge entitles him.
In no wise, however, does this hold good for Palestine. Even though it be true that a very great, perhaps too great, number of works upon the geology of Palestine has been published, yet it is not to be forgotten that it is the remarkable basin of the Dead Sea which forms the point of departure for all these works. That basin alone has been well explored, while the rest of Syria and Palestine has been taken in only in so far as appeared necessary for a more exact understanding of the Dead Sea and its immediate surroundings. The land in