Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 41 · 11 October 1901
3printed page
scan 3 of 16

No. 41. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.

(continued from page 2)

…theory" is in part also only a Chaluka theory translated into the modern. The Chaluka men too would form in Palestine a "homestead for the Thora". But the Thora did not flourish in Palestine; it flourished in Lemberg and Lublin, in Vilna and Cracow, in those homesteads of the economically working Jews. The "priest-Zionists" would solve the economic side of the Jewish question chiefly in America; Palestine, on the other hand, is to be only the "homestead for the Jewish spirit". There the chosen pilots, "the priests", are to live and to rejuvenate the old home by the cultivation of the soil and by other cultural labour. I abstract at once from this peculiar view of the world, which would divide the spirit from the body in a people, which would have the homestead for the body in America and one for the spirit in Palestine. One thing is clear to me. A spiritual centre can only be a centre, that is to say, be in the midst of a great national community. Either the "priests" in Palestine will accomplish as much in the cultural field as the Chaluka Talmudists have accomplished in the Talmudic, or the "priestly youths" — even though institutions of higher learning be founded in Palestine — will emigrate to America, in order in America to solve the economic question for themselves individually. In America, however, they will think just as much about the "Jewish spirit" as their remaining "economic brethren" who live in America.

I was obliged to enter upon culture-Zionism before I would treat of the economic. Here, in a newspaper article, I can only touch upon these questions. I wish, moreover, only to explain my own standpoint, the economic one. For me the Zionist movement is in its main substance an economic movement. It is clear to me that in a Jewish community now to be founded the economic organisation will in general be no other than in all other civilised countries. The thought of founding socialist colonies would be a Utopian one. Socialist society could only be an international one. It goes without saying that I desire — and I presuppose this desire in all thinking Zionists — that Jewish colonies be organised and conducted according to the most modern postulates of social policy. Zionism is for me an economic movement in so far as its causes are to be traced back to economic grounds,

Historical events have divided the Jewish people into two classes, which however live not side by side, but independently of one another. In Eastern Europe there lives the mass of the Jewish paupers, in Western Europe a more or less well-to-do burgher class. As I already indicated at the I. Congress, and as I purpose to treat this question more fully in another place, it is out of the question that in Eastern Europe a proper factory proletariat should be formed out of the mass of the Jewish people. I therefore find, apart from other grounds already, no contradiction between Zionism and Socialism. Among the mass of the paupers in Eastern Europe the very preconditions for the rise of a modern labour party are wanting. Though here and there conditions for the rise of Jewish workmen's associations may be present — and no obstacles are to be laid in the way of their formation — yet the mass of the Jews of Eastern Europe, the 80 or 90 per cent., can be helped by no workmen's associations; this mass can find help only through a systematic emigration. And these masses do emigrate: every year from 30,000 to 40,000 Jews leave Eastern Europe.

Then came the anti-Semitic movement. In my report at the first Congress I characterised also the fundamental causes of the anti-Semitic movement. The Jews have always been treated as a foreign commodity, whose importation is favoured so long as no native industry has arisen. The Jewish intelligence now perceived that its "civil rights of man" were to be withheld from it, that its freedom in trade and in handicraft, in the choice of calling and of place of settlement, was restricted — and the intelligence discovered its Jewish heart. The intelligence perceived that it must one day cease to be a "foreign" and begin to be a "native commodity"; it perceived that it could become so only in a Jewish society; it saw too the great emigration movement among the Jewish masses, and here there arose in it the thought of Zionism. In Western Europe things still go tolerably well with the Jewish burgher class. The Jews do not yet feel the economic pressure in the sense in which it is felt in Eastern Europe. The Jews of Western Europe, therefore, will not yet be Jews; they are "Israelites", citizens "of the Mosaic faith", and so forth. We behold in Western Europe the curious spectacle that rabbis, who would certainly regard a man as a "heretic" were he to interpret symbolically the precept of the Tefilin or the commandment of eating Mazzoth at Passover, lend themselves to interpreting symbolically the clear and plain passages of the Jewish prayers concerning the return to Palestine. So far has dependence upon the economic conditions of life brought the Jews of Western Europe and their priests, the rabbis. Only isolated individuals, whose Jewish heart is afflicted with no economic fatty degeneration, think otherwise.

Economic grounds, then, are in my view the causes of the rise of the Zionist movement. However that may be, it is clear that, in order that any Jewish centre whatever may arise, the necessary precondition thereof is that about the centre there be a great Jewish community. It is clear, further, that a great community can settle only if at the place of settlement it finds the means of sustaining itself. In all circumstances, therefore, we come back to the bread question.

Proceeding from this point of view, one should have supposed that, when in Zionist circles economic questions are spoken of, the questions treated would be those standing in the closest connexion with Zionism. But what did we hear? There was talk of Jewish societies, of productive and credit co-operatives, of the strengthening of the middleman's trade, and of consumers' unions.

Upon the idea of Jewish trade unions I will express myself more fully in another place. With my attitude towards Zionism I cannot promise myself much from them. I will now pass on to the remaining proposals. In all these proposals one chief point of view has been overlooked. namely this: that the misery of the Jewish masses is to be traced back, not to general economic causes, but to specific ones, and that this misery can be relieved only through a systematic emigration. I will grant that from the standpoint of agitation it would be advisable to strive also, if possible, to relieve the misery now. But no means will be able to help; they will be palliatives, which lead to nothing and which will moreover make the masses distrustful later on.

As concerns the productive co-operatives, it is clear that they cannot raise the economic position of the Jews. Productive co-operatives have been recommended for handicraft as a means of combat against great capital. I leave out of account at once that this means is a hopeless one. An organisation of the worker-producers will indeed bring about a better division and combination of labour; the organised worker-pro-