Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 28 · 12 July 1901
7printed page
scan 7 of 16
Facsimile · scan 7 of 16
Scan of p. 7
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 28 — "Die Welt" — Page 7

(continued from page 6)

…year had to dismiss him — for reasons which will appear of themselves from what follows.

As for Dr. Kent, he is well-nigh inaccessible to Jewish patients, since the throng of fellaheen before his consulting-room is always so great, and indeed so dangerous to life, that it is impossible for the Jewish patients, and above all for the women and children, to make their way forward. The fellaheen take their places in the queue as early as midnight and wait nine hours in the crush until the place is opened. In this, of course, the Jewish patients, with their for the most part very feeble bodily constitution, cannot join.

There would remain for them, then, Herr Dr. L. Rothstein. He is a very interesting person, with whom we propose to make a somewhat closer acquaintance. We have, moreover, already had the questionable pleasure in the "Welt" of making this gentleman's acquaintance. For before he became a duly established oculist in Jerusalem, he played in Alexandria, as "emissary of secret Russian Zion societies," a by no means dubious part. Upon this we find in No. 26 of the "Welt" of the year 1898, p. 11 f., in a correspondence from Alexandria, the following interesting disclosures: "We do everything possible to assure everyone who will hear it that Zionism . . . pursues its loudly and plainly declared aim by means which it has made known to all the world, and that it has no 'secret' plan of any kind. These secret plans have often been thrown in our teeth; when we asked people how they had come by such an opinion, they usually answered that they had spoken with a certain Dr. Rothstein, who, when our agitation began, gave himself out here as an emissary of 'secret Russian Zion societies.' Naturally we have declared this man to be what he is: a swindler who fishes in troubled waters and pursues nothing but dirty private ends."

For "secret societies" and similar mysteries Herr Dr. Rothstein has in general a great predilection. In Jerusalem he founded a Jewish-religious secret "Order" under the mystical name תלמידי תשבי ("Disciples of the Tishbite"). When certain highly suspicious particulars from the inner life of this "Order" came to the knowledge of the public, the Chacham-Bashi, in conjunction with the Rabbinical College, published in the Palestinian papers a "warning" against joining this secret league.

But the "purely human" side of Herr Dr. Rothstein interests us less than his medical activity. The oculist systematically ruins the eyes of his patients by painting them with solutions of lapis of 20 per cent. and upwards. In this manner he lends nature a helping hand and procures for himself ever fresh "material" . . . . The writer of these lines himself saw an original prescription of Herr Dr. Rothstein's in which the latter prescribes a 20 per cent. solution of lapis. It is asserted, however, on trustworthy authority that in certain cases he orders solutions even of 40 to 50 per cent. With this let there now be compared the opinions of two eminent Viennese specialists, which we here subjoin word for word:

I.

In reply to an inquiry concerning the treatment of trachoma, I willingly declare that I hold treatment with solutions of lapis exceeding 5 per cent. — containing, that is, 30 or 40 per cent. — to be exceedingly injurious and dangerous. I myself for the most part use 1 per cent., rarely 2 per cent. (Argentum nitricum).

  1. VII. 1901. University Docent Dr. Topolansky.

II.

In reply to an inquiry upon this subject I declare that in my practice I never employ any other than a two per cent. solution of lapis; that I hold it to be impermissible and criminal to employ a 30 to 40 per cent. solution of lapis in diseases of the eye of whatsoever kind; and that in all Europe there is, so far as my knowledge reaches, no oculist of repute who would employ a solution stronger than 3 per cent. at the utmost.

Vienna, 5th July 1901. Dr. S. Klein, Docent at the Imperial and Royal University, Head of Department at the Polyclinic, Oculist to the Hospital of the Israelitish Community, etc., etc.

*

Under such circumstances it is not to be wondered at that those Jewish sufferers from eye disease to whom it is in any way possible prefer to undertake the long, toilsome, and costly journey to Europe rather than let themselves be treated by such a charlatan. But how many poor sufferers there are for whom a journey to Europe belongs among the impossibilities! The various Jewish associations of fellow-countrymen (כוללים), as well as individual private persons in Jerusalem, have several times already made vain efforts to interest the Jewish philanthropists of Europe in these conditions, and with their material and moral support to secure a capable European specialist for the Jewish sufferers from eye disease in Jerusalem. Perhaps these lines may give the impulse to the taking, at last, of serious steps in this matter. M. Z.


H. Stewart Chamberlain and his Estimate of Judaism.*)

By Bernard Tag.

IV.

Assuredly, my friend, it is a quite definite authority that I had before my eyes in that place; an authority to whom we are all wont, upon every important occasion, rightly and by preference to appeal: Goethe. Nothing can be more welcome to me than that Chamberlain, in his attempt to make his conception of religion and the religion of Judaism vivid to the reader, should attach himself to a significant remark of Goethe's. In the fourth book of "Dichtung und Wahrheit," in that section where Goethe, setting forth the course of his youthful studies, speaks of the effect which the Bible exercised upon him, he weaves into his plain rendering of the plain Biblical narrative the following reflection: "The universal, the natural religion properly requires no faith; for the conviction that a great, producing, ordering, and guiding Being conceals itself, as it were, behind Nature in order to make itself comprehensible to us — such a conviction forces itself upon every man; nay, though he should now and then let go the thread of it which leads him through life, he will yet be able at once and everywhere to take it up again. It is quite otherwise with the particular religion, which announces to us that that great Being takes the part of one individual, of one tribe, of one people, of one region, decidedly and by preference. This religion is founded upon faith, which must be unshakable if it is not to be destroyed at once and from the ground up. Every doubt against such a religion is deadly to it. To conviction one may return, but not to faith." In this we shall be, quite without reservation, with Chamberlain in agree-


*) See "Die Welt" Nos. 22, 24 and 26.

In the essay in No. 26 the following corrections are to be made: p. 10, column 2, line 14 should read, instead of "oldest and newest expression" — "oldest and most naïve expression"; line 39, instead of "the world of the Jews" — "the world of the Indians"; line 49, instead of "disciple of Diogenes" — "disciple of Dionysos."