No. 26 — "Die Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…siderably reduced, which was confirmed even by the representatives from Palestine.
Further, we learned already upon the way that for the settlement of a part of the colonists some 60,000 Dunams of land had been purchased, which are to be used for the establishment of colonies as soon as the formalities bound up with the purchase shall have been completed.
Finally, we must with a feeling of deep sorrow mention one circumstance more, and that is — the mistrust towards the colonists and labourers, which we encountered in such a degree that we were extraordinarily grieved thereat. We look upon this mistrust as one of the consequences, perhaps the saddest, of the former régime with its system of falsehood and unceasing abuses. We are deeply convinced of the groundlessness of this view, but here too we had to reckon with this circumstance.
Summing up now what has been said above, we may characterise the conditions which we found here as follows: the embodiment of power in one person; prejudices against the colonists and the conviction of the necessity of the administrative régime; a considerable mitigation of the latter in the colonies; and the purchase of a great stretch of land.
Such a concurrence of circumstances showed from the outset what we could expect. Yet, mindful of that which had been laid upon us, we set forth in their full extent, in a memorandum drawn up and presented by us, the demands which had been framed by the Odessa Meeting and which, even though they did not wholly fit the altered conditions, nevertheless retain, in our deepest conviction, their entire justification.
These demands run as follows:
"I. As the fundamental evil from which the colonies have suffered the whole time there appears the régime of administrative tutelage. Mitigated under the new administration, it remains in its essence what it was, and, according to our deep conviction, it threatens to render fruitless all the exertions and sacrifices that are now being brought to the transformation of the colonies.
We are therefore of opinion that it is necessary, in the interest of the cause, to renounce the system of administrative curatorship and to leave it to the colonies to order their modus vivendi upon the basis of full independence.
II. No detailed plans for the organisation of the colonies and the settlement of the labourers contain within themselves guarantees of their expediency and practical execution if they are framed by individual persons without the active participation of those concerned therein.
We believe, therefore, that for the investigation, the solution and the realisation of the questions bound up with the final settlement of the colonies, a commission must be appointed in Palestine, to consist of the representatives of the institutions occupied with the colonisation of Palestine and of the delegates of the colonists and labourers.
Among the functions of this commission belongs, among other things, the working out (upon the spot) of a method whereby the regular employment of the assigned sums and their accurate payment at fixed dates would be guaranteed.
III. In view of the fact that the composition of the commission sufficiently guarantees its competence, and that the position of our cause requires the assurance of the speediest possible execution of its resolutions, we are of opinion that its appointment must be preceded by the following two conditions:
a) The colonists and labourers bind themselves in advance to submit to all the resolutions which are taken by the commission;
b) The bodies composing the commission must guarantee in advance the possibility of carrying their determinations into effect.
Considering that the labours of the commission we have planned are complicated and of long duration, it is necessary, so long as the results of the commission are not made clear, to take care that the existence of the colonists and labourers be not undermined."
In a whole series of meetings and conversations which we had with Baron Rothschild and the representatives of the "Ica", we endeavoured to establish all the points mentioned above, as well as the thesis developed at length in the memorandum, that as the sole means of a radical and just solution of the labour question there appears the settlement of the labourers upon the soil of Palestine. We shall perhaps shortly publish the exact course of our negotiations and deliberations. For the present, however, we confine ourselves to a brief communication of the results under the several heads.
I. Plainly and openly we say that the concession of a full independence of the colonies has not now been attained by us. Our conviction that one cannot colonise without asking the colonists met with an equally firm opinion that the transformation of the colonies would be unthinkable if the colonists were to be asked. Further: individual members of the Palestinian Commission, when they discussed the question with us privately, did not even hold it possible to convene an official sitting upon this point.
Yet although in principle they parted from us in this question as regards the present, the leaders here conceded the full reasonableness of our demands for the future, which in their opinion will arrive at the moment when the colonies shall have been brought to the possibility of an independent existence and of the payment of their debts. Their aim, they declared, is to strive thereafter, and then the colonies will be left wholly to their own fate, however it may shape itself in the sequel. Until then, however, the administrative régime must continue to exist; it will only be restricted to what is most indispensable; every needless interference will be avoided. The internal self-government of the colonies, and even their organisation into a union, which is indeed not yet sanctioned, appear as factors whose usefulness and significance are acknowledged here also, although the provisions bear no obligatory character.
II. Far more favourable news can we communicate concerning the fate of the colonies which stand under the Baron's protection. It was promised us by all who are concerned in the matter that the colonists of these colonies will all be settled, and that in the manner which they all now recognise as the most rational, that is to say, as agricultural labourers upon arable soil. Considerable corners of land have already been purchased; land will yet be bought in addition, and our colonists will remain in our land. The attainment of independence on the part of these colonies — so the president of the "Ica", N. Levin, declares to us — is now a point of honour for the "Ica".
III. As regards the taking over of the grapes, it has been declared and confirmed to us that from Rothschild's colonies all the wine-grapes will be taken over, and from the others — within the limits of possibility. Unfortunately the prices will probably be depressed still further, since it is not possible to leave altogether out of account the unfavourable conditions now ruling in the market.
IV. Far less consoling news must we communicate concerning the position of the labourers. Unhappily we must state that here no moral obligation with regard to the labourers is acknowledged, and that there is no wish to retain them in the land with all one's might, as a necessary element, in greater numbers than the current economic conditions allow. Nevertheless, already at the close of our negotiations, Baron Rothschild declared to us his intention of placing the great area of Choran (about 65,000 Dunams) at the disposal of the labourers for the establishment of colonies, as soon as the formalities necessary for the settlement shall have been completed — yet without means for their establishment.
The carrying out of these formalities is a matter which claims a considerable time. Moreover we must add, with a feeling of pain, that the "Ica" feels neither the duty nor the wish to give the means necessary for the establishment. As the only positive declaration on its part there appears the promise to seek ways of giving the labourers productive work, as, for example, at the farm, in tobacco-growing, in the silk-spinning works at Rosch-Pinah, or else by the establishment of some industry. With regard to the labourers they will undertake no obligations. As for industry, however, they will of themselves undertake something only in the last extremity; it is their wish that the initiative and the beginning of the undertaking be seized without them.
In this way all these data appear as a solution of the question perhaps only for a part of the labourers, namely for that part which shall arm itself with patience and be endowed with the power to live even under the hardest conditions.
Such, then, was the state of things as it became manifest to the Delegation after all the meetings and interviews. Summing up now the result, we institute above all a comparison with the chief tasks given us by the General Meeting. These are set forth in the following points:
Point "a": The Delegation must strive that to all colonists and labourers the possibility be given of remaining in Palestine.
Point "d": The Delegation must strive that in the settlement of the colonists and labourers the system of tutelage be abandoned, and that the possibility be given them of shaping their existence themselves.
Neither the one task nor the other can now be regarded as solved. Before the Delegation there arose the question: What can it and what must it still undertake?
Touching the first task, we could avow that the matter, with respect to the colonies at least, is upon the way to solution. We had further to admit that, under the present conditions and with the direction which from the beginning in