Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 4
(continued from page 3)
…also convincing, and I do not hesitate to assert that the franchise would if anything make the position of the Jews in Roumania worse still. The Jew could never decide for any party whatever; he would simply run the risk of being lynched by the adherents of the opposing party of the moment, which, in view of the Roumanian masses, always inclined to public excesses, is to be taken literally. At best, however, they would come into the situation of the Bohemian Jews, for whom the election has become a torment, or even into that of our Galician brethren of the race, who as unwilling accomplices of the Schlachtzizen make a little creditable use of their "political rights."
What, then, are we to do? How in particular are we European Jews, to whom the paper emancipation has now once for all fallen, to handle our political rights? The counsels which Nordau imparts are acceptable only sub specie aeternitatis, from higher and general points of view; but they afford as yet no information as to how we — I have in the first place the Austrian Jews in view — are to place ourselves towards the countless nationalities and parties, towards the political and social questions of the day.
The answer is quickly to hand. Zionists of the strictest tendency and moderate Jewish Nationalists will promptly propose: "Let us pursue Jewish-national politics." The young and the youngest, to whom the political song still sounds right melodious and who do not catch the "ugly" discord at all, will of course at once take the field with the whole apparatus in order to demonstrate that Jewish national politics is the best of all political tendencies, for… there now follows a reference to Bohemia and Galicia, where the Jews find themselves in the "cleft stick," then a total rout of the wretched assimilationists, and finally the long chain of reasoning will die away in an enthusiastic laudatory syllogism upon human dignity in general and upon Jewish self-respect in particular. Quod demonstrandum erat.
The "cool thinkers" take the matter up with less enthusiasm, but unfortunately likewise do not arrive at the soundest conclusions, for the simple reason that the chief premiss, of which I shall shortly come to speak, is false. These are the so-called "real politicians." They lay down the principle that Jewish-national politics consists in this, that the Jews as politicians do homage to the device "do ut des" and, since the Jews form no compact mass, vote for that party which promises — the most. That, to be sure, is plainly spoken. But apart from the fact that this — let the hard word be forgiven me — huckstering politics does not differ much from that contemptible political satellitism which we have learned to abhor in the assimilationists; quite apart, too, from the fact that there are certain higher principles to which we must do homage without regard to our advantage or disadvantage, if we are not to disavow ourselves and our history — the politics of the "do ut des" is in the long run simply impracticable. On what grounds, shall be set forth at once. In the first place, there is in this direction no united Jewish electorate. The Jew in the flat country has other material interests than the townsman, and I can very well imagine the case that one part of Jewry will vote for an agrarian, another for a manufacturer, and a third part for a free-trader. European Jewry is in its daily needs far too much differentiated for one to be able to say: all the Jews will decide against or for a particular candidate, that is to say, the Jewish-national party will negotiate in a body with a second. At the present moment there may indeed be a guiding line: in any case, against the anti-Semites! But let it be considered that the choice is made hard for one when one sees that almost all the Aryan candidates feel more or less anti-Semitically, and that, if things go well, one comes into the position of choosing the "lesser evil." Do ut des! What is to be given us for our alliance from case to case? A livelihood for the hundreds of thousands of Jewish proletarians? Official posts for the sons "of the better houses"? Honour and riches? … Let one name me a single concrete demand which we could make upon a party as the price of our political following? Is the party in question perhaps to abolish anti-Semitism from the world? Upon that we have surely long been clear, that an anti-Semitic party may well be reared up — by favouring, still more by suppression — but that with "defence" one soon becomes bankrupt. I have therefore every ground to fear that for the article of commerce "Do ut des" there will be — no purchasers. From this whole stock-exchange politics I can descry not a single true advantage, but rather the not very consoling prospect that we shall make ourselves ridiculous before the other parties; for as the last, but not the weakest argument, let it further be adduced that in by far the greater number of electoral districts we are simply outvoted by the other parties, and that where we do form "the tongue of the balance" we are all the more in embarrassment as to which way we ought to play over; for that party which promises the Jews the least may reckon upon the majority of the votes, and the tongue is soon relieved of its honourable function.
These are theoretical objections, whose number, moreover, I can double or treble on demand. In practice the matter looks far worse still. Precisely in those countries in which the Jews form a considerable part of the population and accordingly have the best prospect of pursuing "real politics" (Do ut des), they are, in their daily earnings, in their whole existence, so utterly dependent upon those who must remain the holders of power for decades to come, that all programmes must at once fall into the water the moment the Herr District Captain expresses a "wish." That indeed is the deeply sorrowful thing in our position, that we cannot properly handle our so-called political rights; but alter it we can in the very fewest cases.
This premised, I venture, even at the risk of giving offence on the friendly Jewish-national side, to declare: There is no Jewish national politics in the Diaspora. Jewish national politics is Zionism. Without Zionism there is technically no Jewish nation. The two most important requisites of a nation are language and land. Take from the Jewish people the idea of Zion, and there is no nation there, and therefore no "Jewish-national" politics either. When the Czechs pursue national politics to-day, the whole quarrel turns upon the language question and perhaps also upon the social phenomena that accompany it. But if we wished to follow a Jewish-national policy in Austria, we should at once be asked: "Will you have the Hebrew tongue in office and school?" What shall we answer?
Jewish-national politics is synonymous with the endeavour to make a nation out of the Jewish people, more plainly: out of the Jewish masses, to give the people land and language. What is that other than Zionism? A Jewish national politics without Zionism is a contradiction in itself. Those who would make Jewish-national politics without Zionism start precisely from a false premiss and arrive
