Page 12 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 3
The first strophe in Bodenstedt: "The men of Dsighé are mourning, Song sounds and plaintive playing: For the fairest of the people of the Adighé, Pschugui, the fearless, has fallen! etc."
Herr Albert Katz has prudently left out, and likewise the identically worded second half of the last strophe. (Compare thereto the note of Max Hecker to his article "The Mountain Jews in the Caucasus" in No. 6 of the "Jüdische Turnzeitung.") A few small alterations do not amount to much: there have been substituted, once for "Moskow" [p. 23, l. 4] "enemies," a second time [l. 18] "Edom," for "soft hair" [l. 22] the garbled "locks of hair," for "Allah" [l. 26] "God to Thee," and finally for "the multitude" [l. 30] "Judah's tribe." Otherwise it is copied verbally. The hero Mamre (cf. p. 25) Katz has taken from the repeatedly mentioned novel of Nemirović-Dančenko (p. 111). We Jews are a people far too rich in poetry to have need of enriching ourselves from strangers. It does not belong to us! Our hands are clean!
There follows only one more short Section V, from the foot of p. 23 to the top of p. 27. Here the author now uses a new source, namely R. v. Erckert: The Caucasus and its Peoples. Leipzig 1887. How closely he has looked at this work may be seen from the fact that he consistently calls the author Eckert. Right at the beginning of this section Katz gives the numbers of the Mountain Jews according to Erckert and Hahn, both of them wholly otherwise than these scholars in whose names he transmits the figures (see thereto Hahn: From the Caucasus p. 181 and Erckert loc. cit. pp. 298, 299.) On p. 24 a long quotation from Erckert is given. This quotation is falsified in that he glues together three unconnected passages (see loc. cit. pp. 303, 300, 302.) He thereby transfers what v. Erckert says by way of anthropological hypotheses about the Russian Jews quite in general, in Erckert's name, to the Mountain Jews, and in this new connection removes Auapa, Kertsch and Olbia into the Caucasus. That on this occasion the printer's devil should just again have picked out three foreign names, Chorene (Chorone), Anapa (Knappe) and Olbia (Olbid), is downright malicious of the said devil. After a little more Nemirović-Dančenko had been mixed in with v. Erckert, and Erckert (compare against this v. Erckert loc. cit. p. 239) had to serve for the similarity of the Zachuren to the Jews, striking in their manner of life, there comes a conclusion of 35 lines which is to be regarded as Katz's own addition. I will not pass judgment upon it.
That is, in the most compressed brevity, an analysis of the sources of "The Jews in the Caucasus" by Albert Katz. But in this criticism I find myself in an evil dilemma: for if I pronounce a critical judgment, then Herr Katz, with the help of two advocates, brings an action for defamation on the ground of § 185 of the Penal Code for the German Empire; and if I were to print the copied passages of his work together with the corresponding sources as proof of my criticism, then I may confidently expect that he will set on foot a press action against me on account of the unauthorised reprinting of his book, that is to say, on account of plagiarism.
A note, the printing of which at the place in question in the Calendar had to be objected to and withdrawn, is, apart from the local placing of the passage and from the expression withdrawn in my declaration, objectively to be maintained. Even before the court Herr Katz persisted in it that Der wahre Talmudjude (The True Talmud Jew) is not a translation of Suvalsky's חיי היהודי על פי התלמיד (The Life of the Jew according to the Talmud), but a product of his own mind and knowledge composed with a slight leaning upon that book. With reference to § 185 of the Penal Code for the German Empire I declare only that Herr J. S. Suvalsky, in the presence of other delegates, personally on the 1st September 1898 at Basle bitterly and in moving words lamented his grievance to me, that Katz had published his (Suvalsky's) book under Katz's name. Katz writes on page XIII of his preface that he had made use of the little work (sic!) of Suvalsky. It remains to be awaited whether Herr Katz will bring an action against Suvalsky also on the ground of §§ 185—187 and 200. Herr Katz caused his representative, Justizrath Bry, to call my review a "literary warrant of arrest." I therefore repeat in this place that the
*) This "at times" is added by Katz, while he leaves out the following clause, in which N.-D.'s whole anti-Jewish disposition expresses itself, as very often elsewhere, harshly and spitefully.
bookseller Herr Albert Katz is quite indifferent to me, but that the author Katz must put up with it if a skin is stripped from him which does not belong to him.
And now to the conclusion! In the "Israelitischer Volkskalender" for the year 1894 — 5654 there is a tale: "The Czar and the Rabbi." From the Russian (!) by Albert Katz. Who is the author? — In the same Calendar for the year 1895 — 5655 there is again a tale: "A Fast-Day." A tale from Jewish popular life. Freely from the Polish by Albert Katz. And who is the author there? Both tales, with two kindred ones besides, are given without more ado and without the additions "From the Russian" and "Freely from the Polish," as the original intellectual property of Albert Katz, in the book: "From Old and New Times." Tales from the Life of the Jews in Poland, by Albert Katz, Prague, printed at Jacob B. Brandeis's. The title-page bears on its reverse the note: "All rights, including that of translation into foreign languages, reserved." It lies in the interest of Jewish literary history to establish who are the authors of the original novels in Polish and in Russian.
Let it suffice that to-day I bring forward only this material in corroboration of my objective judgment on page 37 of the "Jüdischer Volkskalender" (the work has also appeared separately from the publishing house of H. Bardorf at Charlottenburg). It is done in the interest of the freedom of objective criticism in the domain of Jewish letters. Now as before, such little unpleasantnesses will not hold me back from telling the truth when I know it.
Tribune.
(For the form and content of this column the Editors assume no responsibility.)
We receive the following communication:
Vienna, the 12th January 1901.
Highly Esteemed Editors!
We would most politely request you to admit the following lines:
The "Reading and Debating Hall of Jewish University Students" has been considerably enlarged by the extension of its premises and by the accession of numerous new members, and looks forward to a steady advance. Only the condition of our library still leaves much to be desired; and on the other hand, by the fresh acquisition of books no such rapid advance can be made in this respect as in the other affairs of our society. We therefore turn to our patrons and friends with the request that they support us, so far as is possible, by gifts of books, since only by a thorough improvement of our library can we fully and entirely fulfil our task of becoming an intellectual rallying-point of the Jewish university students.
Respectfully,
The Committee of the "Reading and Debating Hall of Jewish University Students"
Vienna, IX., Währingerstrasse No. 24.
Review of Periodicals and Books.
The international review "L'humanité nouvelle," appearing in Paris, brings in its September number of 1900 an essay from the international revolutionary student socialist group which was laid before the Socialist Congress of 1900 as a report. The article, which is entitled "Anti-Semitism and Zionism," says nothing new. What is there said about the penetration of Jew-hatred, especially into the middle class and the great landed proprietors, is as hackneyed as it is flat. For Zionism, naturally, not the faintest understanding is to be found. But let one sentence be singled out; it teaches what our Jewish workmen have to hope from Social Democracy. "We are no Zionists, because the emigration of the Jews would diminish the active proletarian mass.
