No. 49 — "Die Welt" — Page 7
Dr. Sänger even contemplates a taking possession of the Holy Land. Thus he writes in No. 32, page 745:
"The curse which rests upon this land has further the effect — which perhaps was even meant to be its purpose — of laying no over-great hindrances and difficulties in the way of the future claims which the Jewish people may raise. Whether the Jewish people will raise these claims? . . which seems to the modern Jew so exceedingly laughable and absurd, since in his opinion we dwell in 'promised lands,' since instead of the one Jerusalem and instead of the one Temple we are so happy as to possess, by the latest count, several Jerusalems (Stuttgart, Berlin) and several Temples (Hamburg, Berlin)" . . .
Yes indeed, the greater part of the Jewish people raises these claims in the Zionist movement. But who is it that now treacherously falls upon it from behind, and in no very seemly fashion seeks by all manner of machinations to frustrate this plan? They are not only modern Jews, but orthodox ones as well, of the stamp of the "Israelit," who seek to outdo one another in combating Jewish national endeavours.
After the first Congress this paper cried out in warning:
"And for Zion's sake and for Jerusalem's sake we may not keep silence and may not rest until we have shown that in Zionism there lies no furtherance, but a fearful danger, for our holy religion."
In the year 1874 Dr. Sänger came to the opposite conclusion. He holds an acquisition of the Holy Land to be downright necessary in the interest of the Jewish religion. He writes, namely, in No. 33, p. 772:
"His doctrine, to which he (the Jew) is bound for all time, and without which he ceases to be a Jew, demands a soil of its own; it demands, for its complete fulfilment, an independence which no State can grant without creating exceptions for those of the Jewish confession. And this it cannot and may not do, having regard to the majority of its subjects."
And further in No. 34, p. 796:
"To-day, under these so 'happy conditions,' it is exceedingly hard for us to be Jews, harder almost than in the earlier centuries. But if we could live in a land of our own according to our laws, it would be exceedingly easy to keep the Sabbath, to observe the dietary laws and a hundred others which to-day fall so hard upon us through circumstances. Hence every Jew who would gladly live according to his law would regard that land which made such a thing possible for him as the happiest, and would prefer it to all other 'happiest conditions.'"
That is to say, in other words, that a home of their own, legally secured, is necessary for the Jews precisely from the religious standpoint. But Dr. Sänger establishes the necessity of such a home in yet another way. The Jew is compelled, on account of his religion, to take up a special position in his country. Thus the Sabbath and the dietary laws — to say nothing of the marriage laws, which maintain an eternal wall of partition between us and those of other faiths — all too often stand as an obstacle in the way of discharging the duties of a public office, or make it altogether impossible to hold any public office at all. Can we ascribe the blame for this to the State? That the State should take special account of us, should enact special laws in our favour because the laws ordained from the standpoint of the general course of law do not suffice for us — that would be a demand which no State is bound to fulfil. However free the laws we may have, an equality of the Jew is impossible by reason of the requirements of his religion.
Here Dr. Sänger has in view only those countries in which the Jew enjoys equal rights at least upon paper. But he thinks also of those States in which this is not the case. Thus it runs in No. 34, p. 796:
"That a Messiah would come so wholly unwished-for to-day we should not, for the rest, care to assert so unconditionally. There is, for example, a country Roumania, whose Jewish inhabitants assuredly desire nothing more ardently than a saviour and deliverer out of their Pharaonic bondage."
That was in the year 1874. How the conditions have altered since that time! The position of the Jews has grown worse in all the countries of Europe. The Jewish distress is indescribable. One need only think of the two persecutions of the Jews in Russia, of the disturbances in Galicia, Bohemia and Roumania, of the names Tisza-Eszlár, Xanten, Konitz, Polna, Dreyfus, etc. It is not only the 250,000 Roumanian Jews, but 5 millions of Jews in Russia besides, 3/4 of a million in Galicia, and a hundred thousand others who dwell in countries where the Jews enjoy equal rights upon paper, who would fain be freed from their present position and would count that day the fairest upon which they should find a lasting home in the land of their fathers.
When, however, the author writes: "The realisation of the Messianic hope we do not truly conceive under Turkish rule, so that we should stand under Turkish dominion," we may reply thereto that the position of the Jews in Turkey to-day is incomparably better than elsewhere. The relation between Turks and Jews is indeed a very good one. The Sultan, as already upon countless occasions before, again gave proof last summer of his particular goodwill towards the Jews, in that he assigned land in Anatolia to the Roumanian fugitives and granted besides, out of his privy purse, pecuniary support for its cultivation.
Will the present editor of the "Israelit" now cease his baitings against Zionism, after it has here been shown how one of his principal contributors formerly, from the orthodox standpoint, directly advocated a legally secured settlement of the Holy Land such as Zionism strives for? We hardly believe it. It suffices us to have shown that his objections hitherto, "from the standpoint of law-observant Judaism," will not hold water.
On the Psychology of Anti-Semitism.
By Rabbi Dr. J. Rülf (Bonn).
Who coined the winged word "Anti-Semitism is the Socialism of fools" and first set it in circulation I am unable to say; but it has long been known and has come into currency. Sometimes such a word finds entrance and echo merely for the sake of its paradox, even though it may contain but little that is true; and in this word we are likewise unable to find so much as a grain of a right and fitting designation.
In the first place, Anti-Semitism is no Socialism. Socialism is the endeavour after the equalisation and the removal of all the too glaring contrasts existing in the economic life of men and of nations; the
