Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 34
(continued from page 3)
…replied with a smile: "You are mistaken, friend; the world is not coming to an end, I see only a little fox drowning!"
Let us beware of playing the part of the fox in this fable. It would be too cruel if the mocking words of the peasant were the only answer to our cries for help. He who comes to another with the subjective argument: "But I must live!" always exposes himself to the answer: "I do not see the necessity." No other person ever sees this necessity. But one must oneself comprehend it and act accordingly. (Thunderous applause and clapping of hands.) Cries for help are an insufficient means of preserving life. One must make one's own exertions to ward off death, else one becomes its prey. (Thunderous applause and clapping of hands.)
So here too I speak not so much to the European Governments and peoples, although it would naturally afford us the highest satisfaction if men were willing to hear us. I speak here rather, in the first place, to the Jewish people. (Thunderous applause and clapping of hands.) The Jewish people shall know how it stands to-day with Jewry, what new strokes of fate have fallen upon it. The Jewish people shall know that no one will help it if it does not help itself. (Thunderous applause.)
Here then we must above all ask ourselves: How does the Jewish people bear itself towards the Roumanian catastrophe? What has it done, what is it doing, to avert the worst consequences of that catastrophe? How does it stand by the unhappy brethren who through no fault of their own have been cast out of the European social contract, out of the sheltering enclosure of civilisation, and now wander about without rights like the beasts of the wilderness?
I will not dwell upon the most abominable traits of Jewish depravity, at which I have already hinted. Shame, disgust, indignation would overwhelm me, and yet it is absolutely necessary that we keep cool blood. I console myself with the thought that the wretches who denounce their expelled Roumanian brethren to the police and have them turned out, where their influence can effect this, are a small minority, and I will rather turn my eyes to more consoling sights.
Of good will there is in fact no lack. Men wish to help the Roumanian victims. What is lacking is an organisation which should gather the scattered forces together and employ them uniformly towards a definite end. But without organisation, without concentration, without uniformity in the employment of these scattered forces, they are worthless, and with all the individual exertions almost nothing comes of it on the whole.
Of money, too, there is no lack. Many Jews have again done honour to the old repute of Jewish beneficence. The poor Jews give beyond their strength. The well-to-do Jews give according to their strength. Even many Jews of millions have not wholly closed their hands. Individuals, it is true, bestow 20,000 francs more readily for the pleasure-trip of an anti-Semitic singing society than the fifth part of that sum for the Roumanian wanderers, who do not travel for their pleasure and are not yet anti-Semites either, although occurrences of this kind might in time make them such. Individuals, it is true, would rather buy themselves old Gobelins for their drawing-room at 600,000 francs than come to the help of the Roumanian wanderers with the hundredth part of that sum. But on the whole men have not knocked in vain at the door of the millionaires. The misfortune is only that the very considerable sums which flow together are not employed in the right manner and therefore can bring forth no lasting benefit. They serve, that is to say, for the realisation of no definite plan. No uniform idea, indeed no idea at all, determines their employment.
How is the money spent? In the most primitive, the most unorganic manner: by the handing of alms from hand to hand. For this, to be sure, no particular exertion of mind is needed. Here are wives and children left behind by Roumanian fathers of families who have emigrated: one buys them bread that they may not die of hunger. Here are groups of wanderers whom the one country will not tolerate and the other will not receive, and who lie miserably at some frontier or other, hemmed in by bristling bayonets: one buys them tickets to the next country, to the next port of embarkation, to America. I will not inquire whether these gifts of railway-tickets do not in many cases represent a kind of beneficence which the givers exercise rather towards themselves than a beneficence which they exercise towards the Roumanian Jews. I have no right to try the heart and reins, and must hold to the visible facts. But the visible fact is that the distress requires momentary alleviation, and that an alms does in truth for the moment alleviate the worst distress in some degree. Therewith, however, the effect of a mere alms is also completely exhausted. It helps over the moment by hook and by crook; of the next hour no one appears to think.
The Roumanian emigrants are sent to America. In this way one has got rid of them. One no longer sees them before one. One is separated from their cries for help by the whole breadth of the ocean. But what is to become of them in America? Are they to be allowed to go under there? Are they to perish there one by one? Is a man who starves in America any less dead than a man who dies of hunger in Roumania or between the Roumanian frontier and Rotterdam? Will alms be handed to them further in America also? Then the weak characters would at once be turned into professional beggars, and even the more capable would soon succumb to the temptation to have themselves permanently maintained as patented paupers. Or is it the intention in America to point out to the new-comers suitable places for settlement, to lead them over into fixed callings, to advance them to economic independence? That would require a powerful organisation, and I do not yet see the faintest beginnings of such an organisation. Mere planless occasional beneficence is ridiculously insufficient, or, more correctly, is terrifyingly insufficient for the demands which the situation at present makes upon the Jewish people. And even this headless, automatic distribution of alms will one day suddenly cease. Has it been reckoned, then, what sum it requires? In America no Roumanian Jew may land who does not prove the possession of 125 francs. With the fare and the cost of maintenance as far as the port of embarkation, that requires for each single person at least 300 francs. If only 100,000 of the 270,000 Roumanian Jews claim this beneficence, we already arrive at a minimum amount of 30 mill. fr., to which must be added the costs of administration and other unfruitful yet unavoidable outlays.