Page 14. — “Die Welt” — No. 41.
(continued from page 13)
…to put this question, which will probably never be capable of being answered conclusively.
“Even a Jewish State would not do away with the whole of the Jewish sorrow.
There are three possibilities: national regeneration, spiritual regeneration and dissolution: I am inclined to accept all three and to offer a threefold solution of the over-long historical tragedy.
Those who hold Israel's isolation to be an unhappy superstition should consciously merge into their surroundings. Those who accord to Israel a mission that is better served by dispersion than by concentration in a State of its own should everywhere form centres of mission and proclaim their ideals aloud and without timidity in civil and national life. For the orthodox and oppressed masses in the half-barbarous lands a State would signify a benefaction.”
This answer offers a solution which, to develop further the expression of a well-known German proverb, is trebly stitched. Closely regarded, it need look for no objection from the Zionist side. In his “Judenstaat” Dr. Herzl himself says that those who do not agree with us need not go with us. Zionism has no need to enlarge the host of its adherents in the manner in which men were formerly pressed for the army. To the theorists of the Mission the Zionist says: Convert your theory into reality. And to the adherents of assimilation he says: In our opinion you are indeed condemned from the outset to a bankruptcy of your intentions, but we are gladly ready to acknowledge every serious attempt that brings you nearer to the goal. The real difficulty is scarcely grasped by Mr. Zangwill. Of the three solutions mentioned above he holds that “they are ideal possibilities, none of them easy to translate into reality, least easy of all the idea of the Jewish State.”
That may be true in itself, but Zangwill does not there hit the kernel of the matter. It is this: apart from an isolated attempt in the religious field which has moreover emerged only by way of discussion, of the representatives of those possibilities the Zionist is the only one who does anything for his cause. The opponents of the Zionists, however, do nothing at all; they simply use their theories in order to stifle the Zionist movement. Now one thing in Zangwill's article is clear. He holds the Zionist idea to be good enough for the venture of a trial, and therefore he defends it against all attacks. It is thus perhaps hazardous to describe Zangwill as a Zionist. If, however, one weighs against one another the arguments he brings forward, it appears in the end that his heart stands on the side of Zionism.
Zangwill begins his exposition with the establishment of the Jewish misery, whose causes he traces. “After the honest exertions of noble-minded Christians to grant the Jews a free field of labour, it is saddening to have to confess that there is no country in the world in which it is not a misfortune to be a Jew. Max Nordau exaggerates but little when he asserts that the Jew must be three times as clever as anybody else in order to have the same chances of success in the struggle for existence. Never among the masses, or even among the better classes, is “justice for the Jew” given with the force of a spontaneous instinct. “Liberty, Equality, Fraternity” have never been more than a gleam that ran over the hearts of the great, than a formula that ran over the lips of the little minds. Even in the universities of Europe, where, if anywhere, one ought to presume the exclusive dominion of mildness, light and justice, the hands of the most brilliantly gifted Jew who competes for a teaching post are bound with all refinement and insidiousness. Not even in England and the United States is the Jew proof against social prejudice. In most other countries he lives indeed within the uncanny range of a volcano whose eruptions come at irregular intervals, but come inevitably. In the much-lauded capital of civilisation the exhibition of “justice for the Jew” has but just now aroused the moral indignation of the whole world. Moreover antisemitism, like other diseases terrible in themselves, is of an epidemic nature. Hindered by no quarantine, it wanders from land to land.
Whence, then, comes this persistent hatred of the Jews? In part it is doubtless a survival from the dark days of the Middle Ages, a religious antagonism which is still nourished by the Christian prayer-book; in part racial antagonism, an episode in the long struggle between the East and the West. Economic competition and commercial jealousy contribute their part to the mixture. And then one must not forget that there is a sheer delight in wickedness... Nothing pleases the mob more than to comprehend a complex phenomenon under a simple name, and the word “Jew” is always at hand to explain the never-failing morbid symptoms of public life. Since it has found this employment, the word “Jew” has been loaded quite astonishingly with historical hatred, bigotry and antipathy...”
The nationalist question Zangwill states with characteristic brevity: “The view that the Jew is a foreign body in the midst of his surroundings is rooted so deep that it is not to be driven out even with the pitchfork. The Jews may call themselves Englishmen, Frenchmen, Germans or Italians; the question, however, is not what they call themselves, but what the English, French, Germans or Italians call them. They may give themselves up, one generation after another, body and soul to the fatherland — always will a Goldwin Smith arise and ask: Can the Jew be patriotic? And so will every nation of the present as of the future get its sudden spasms of pseudo-racial feeling and demand absolute concentration — Pan-Slavism, Pan-Germanism... and whatever else they may be called, these Pan-isms, which throw the Jews into panic terror by the tumultuous demand for the immediate elimination of the Jewish element...”
The article now turns to a detailed discussion of the remedies already mentioned. The solution of the Jewish question in the sense of assimilation, which is recommended by some of the best among the Jewish intellectuals, Zangwill holds to be not so easily set on foot as it has the appearance of being. “Religious regeneration, conceived as a resolute advance upon the basis of an eventual emancipation of Judaism from the soil of Palestine or from the longing for Palestine, sets itself against Zionism as an alternative solution, but is not in itself excluded by Zionism.”
The assertion that political Zionism is irreligious because its leaders are irreligious Zangwill meets with an adroit sally: “In order to learn how men stand towards religion, one must not turn to their utterances or philosophical opinions, but only to their practical attitude towards life and towards their fellow-men. And upon such a test — I fear — one will catch the religious quite as often in lip-service as the irreligious.”
In many points Zangwill proves so exact a knowledge of our movement that one asks with regret
