No. 29. — "Die Welt" — Page 9.
Professor Dr. David Kaufmann and George Eliot.
"In the hall of fame of the Jewish people, among all the homages that have been rendered to it in the succession of the ages by its own of every century, Daniel Deronda will occupy a place of honour as the proudest testimony of English recognition." Exactly 20 years ago these words were written by one of the most eminent Jewish scholars of our time, Prof. Dr. David Kaufmann, upon "Daniel Deronda," the magnificent book of the brilliant George Eliot. The comprehensive study which the Jewish scholar published two decades ago upon the English authoress in Frankel's Monatsschrift has met the same singular fate as the novel itself to which it was devoted; it possesses to-day a timeliness such as it scarcely possessed at its appearance, for it works to-day with an emphasis and an insistence that dwelt in no literary labour, but only in a political deed. Kaufmann's expositions, which we propose to reproduce here in extracts, will best prove the correctness of this assertion. The ideas which Kaufmann develops concerning the present and the future of Judaism are so full of spirit and so original that their reawakening will certainly arouse general interest, even though we communicate them only in aphoristic form.
At the beginning of his review Prof. Kaufmann speaks not of the work that lies before him, but develops his own opinion upon the task of Judaism, and here he says: "But more than the riddle of this marvellous preservation, the question of the future of the Jews challenges public reflection. One would hardly believe how many minds this care seriously occupies. Is the goal and the outcome of their glorious history to be their absorption among the peoples of the earth? To what end then all love's labour, to what end the chain of sufferings, to what end the streams of blood and tears? Is this much-reviled minority, which has sent forth from its midst the religions that are conquering the globe, perhaps called once again to instil consolation and uplifting into the despairing world from the grave of its daughters?"
"Are the Jews still a national whole, an ailing body into which health and Jewish strength may enter again, or pale, scattered bones?"
"How, to begin with, do the Jews themselves think about it? It is the mark of a healthy bodily frame that its members are active without consciousness of their work. Thus no accusation against the Jews will be derivable from it if the assertion be set up that they have on the whole hitherto clung to their doctrine in unswerving fidelity without a distinct consciousness of their national calling ..... But more than merely a religion Judaism assuredly was to its confessors at all times ... Beside all attachment to the particular land of their birth, there lived in their hearts the feeling of the lost homeland, towards which a quiet longing drew them in songs and prayers welling from the heart, but never in rebellious and treasonable cravings for liberation, in wishes and hopes, but not in deeds and attempts ..."
*) In our last number we brought the tidings of the sudden decease of the great Jewish historian and professor at the Budapest National Teachers' Seminary, Dr. David Kaufmann. The above article affords an interesting insight into the manner of thought of the deserving scholar. (The Ed.)
"... In this inquiry one must not overlook that the idea of nationality has revived in its antique sharpness only in this century, and that at the close of the last century it still passed for the flower of development to have overcome national narrowness through the intimation of a universal humanity. The Middle Ages, which in the old world reach beyond the time of the French Revolution, were not national in our sense; one cannot therefore demand of the Jews what was wanting to their whole environment."
"... Only in this century have hatred, and afterwards science, begun to recognise a nationality in the Jews as well."
"... One may boldly assert: the Judaism of to-day is in the act of awakening and strengthening its national self-consciousness..."
"... But what follows from this awakening? Will the state-forming urge of nationality, which within a short time has so marvellously transformed the map of Europe, sweep the Jews also into making earnest of their hopes thousands of years old, and into turning their tame longing into an impetuous action?"
"Jewry has split into two camps over this question. To the one, the hope of the restoration of the ancient State is a boyish enthusiasm deserving of a smile, the wish for a return to Zion an empty lie ... But in spite of all blustering and all wrangling, the fact cannot be denied that to the greatest part of the Jewish people upon earth Palestine is more than a geographical conception, that all the disaccustoming of the centuries and all the good sense of the modern age have not availed to banish the longing for this land from the heart and to bring it into oblivion for men's minds."
"Who will presume to say what may one day issue from this high tide of hovering feelings within Jewry; who will dare to assert that the imponderable mass of indefinite intimations, of dark urgency, which in the course of the centuries has rather increased than diminished in the Jewish national soul, will evaporate without effect?"
"... Did not the wiseacres of the Babylonian captivity grin with scornful laughter at the fire of the prophets and look down with pity upon the piteous figures who suffered from the whim of wishing to raise up the Temple again? Yet from the circle of these sufferers proceeded the spirits who created for Judea its new blossoms, for Judaism its imperishability."
"Have they bled in vain, the defenders of Jerusalem, the heroes of Bethar? Should there not follow for all time, out of the lion-hearted uprising of Judea, out of the peacefully marvellous home-coming of the banished from the Babylonian exile, at the least this lesson: that the yearning for the possession of Palestine in the heart of the Jewish people is more than an antiquated piece of adventurousness, a barren enthusiasm? Feelings which are cherished in a national soul and preserved in resistance to the influence of the times,
