Page 8. — "Der Weg" — No. 45.
(continued from page 7)
…knows well enough how to keep off its neck. This example must be imitated by the Jews as much as possible. If they can acquire compact landed property, and attain real majorities in whole districts, comitats or provinces, then the process of regeneration, which after all presupposes only quiet and security of life, is guaranteed in a still higher degree. Under all circumstances recruiting is thereby made easier for the time to come.
But in other respects also the Jewish population must defend its skin better. I picture to myself, for example, that raving louts of the quality of Gregorig and Schneider let the filth of their heart run over their tongue in their own fashion in a Hungarian parliamentary body, as happens in Vienna: upon how many kicks and by no means moral boxes on the ear would these two-handed swordsmen have had to reckon, in the very first week, on the part of their Jewish colleagues? I am truly no friend of the parliamentary law of the fist, but I must confess that, in face of such individuals, only the Hungarian method of the boot-heel seems to me in place. This belongs, according to my conception, to Zionism as well, whose final goal cannot indeed be attained without a previous thorough steel-cure of the Jewish people, degenerated in long misery. To criticism let criticism be opposed, but to the insult the insult; that the gentlemen Jewish representatives of the people may take to heart, even if in so doing they perhaps expose their physiognomy to more disagreeable argumentations. Better to be beaten than to be spat upon. One must not let oneself be abused, if one does not wish to bear, besides the hatred of one's enemies, their contempt as well. Is there none among the Jewish parliamentarians in Austria who has his heart and his hand in the right place? If not, then there follows from it all the more impressively the lesson that the Jews stand in need not of assimilation, but of regeneration.
A Rejoinder.
By L. Motzkin.
(Continuation.)
In order to hush up a grave evil, Herr Bambus has clung to words, not to the matter, and has moreover constructed out of it an essential untruth on my part. When I spoke at the Congress, I was thinking chiefly of the evil — which, moreover, was mentioned by me very mildly — and I may have erred in the official designation of the activity of those girls. The relation of the preacher of Rischon-Lezion to the school system was unknown to me, whereas I did indeed know that in Sichron-Jacob H. Rapaport stands in some relation to the schools there — for all I care, exercises the supervision. But it is a matter of indifference whether the girls formally exercise the supervision or only exert their bad influence as principals and teachers. It is not a question of the supervision, but of the determining influence. If, for example, in Petha-Tikwah, where I have not come to know the school conditions more closely, the wife of the administrator is, according to the statement of Herr Bambus in his work "Palästina, Land und Leute" of the year 1898, directrice of the administration school, then it is surely a matter of course that she alone has the ordering and managing in her school. The question is this: does there exist in the school system of the administration colonies, to use the mild word, a grave evil, called forth by the influence of those girls, an evil of which the school system is positively sick? yes or no? Have not the Friends of Zion been fighting against it for years already? But to this Herr Bambus will not answer directly at all. In order to arouse no misunderstanding, I add further that I am by no means of the opinion that women are not equally capable with men of co-operating in the school education of Jewish children. In the case under discussion, however, the matter stands quite otherwise. It is to be hoped that in the future the Palestinian women teachers in the colonies will be truly prepared for their calling and animated by another spirit, so that they may formally be permitted to exercise the supervision as well.
- I have said that it is precisely the small colonisation which seeks to create what is exemplary. But as a former secretary of the society "Esra" I ought to know that the lack of means alone has prevented the small colonisation from so much as wishing to establish anything exemplary. A strange knowing untruth, which is positively laughable; one can only laugh at it. A view which in the opinion of some is false is stamped as a knowing untruth. How often, moreover, has it been declared that one wishes to create in Palestine models of Jewish industry, of Hebrew spirit. This thought has been uttered by countless persons in speeches and essays; as of a typical example I may speak of myself also: always, during my propaganda for the small colonisation, I longed and hoped for it. Such a will made the small colonisation far more justified and more attractive; it grew ever more powerful as the thought of the solution of the Jewish question retreated ever further into the background. Thus is explained the interest in those thousands of Jewish settlers in Palestine, in every school, every institution that was founded over there. A model home it was to become for a small fraction of Jewry, an institution of education. Meanwhile one may also be of another opinion about it; I shall not on that account accuse any one of a knowing untruth. A propos, when I speak of colonisation I think least of all of the society "Esra", whose means stand in no relation whatever to the sums expended altogether.
Far worse still, it is said, is the assertion that the present colonisation brings about the contempt of the Jews on the part of the other population, on account of the humiliations which the Jew has to endure because of the infiltration. It is well known, so it is said, that since the prohibition of immigration of 1891 the colonisation has carried on no infiltration at all, that neither Rothschild nor the colonisation societies have induced European Jews to immigrate. "Certain "political" Zionists, by a piece of juggler's sleight of hand, set infiltration and colonisation as equal and make the adherents of the present colonisation responsible for an immigration against which those same persons have always warned."
Has one words! exclaims the Berliner in such a case. This is really new. How great, I ask, is the percentage of really Palestinian Jews who have been employed for the colonisation? Well, it is true, the Jews were not drawn down into the colonies straight from the steamers, but the colonisation always directed its attention to the foreign Jews. For that reason many went by the way of infiltration, without troubling themselves that only the rich were advised to go to Palestine. What joy we all felt, as often as we heard of even but a small number of newly arrived. Let one only recall the circumstance how many associations were founded precisely by colonisers in various countries for the purpose of removal to Palestine. Could this be brought about otherwise than by means of infiltration? By infiltration, moreover, something more is understood than landing; the whole remaining activity is likewise infiltration, by which term one usually designates the well-known irregular work amid the abnormal conditions of the bakshish system.
(To be continued.)
Tribune.
Vienna, 7th November 1898.
Much esteemed Herr Editor!
We politely request the kind insertion of the following lines:
A small number of Jewish girls, we founded two years ago a literary and social society. We had experienced in ourselves the effect which the reading of Jewish history exercises. It had made us proud of our race and of its past, and we wished most ardently that others also, many, indeed all Jewish girls should think and feel as we do. To become acquainted with the heroes and lawgivers of our people and with its literature, almost wholly unknown to us, was the sole aim of our society; of Zionism and assimilation we knew little or nothing at all.
It goes without saying that we turned above all to Jewish teachers and theologians. Unhappily we found here but little readiness to meet us. There was, with a single exception, among all these teachers and theologians not one who would have been willing to sacrifice a few hours of his precious time to our society.
If our lectures nevertheless afterwards aroused interest by their content and their form, we must ascribe this to a quite different factor — to Zionism. In the room which a man of business made over to us free of charge for a whole year, we heard for the first time, with astonishment, of the sufferings of our brethren, of the great tragedy of the so-called Jewish question. We had lecture upon lecture,