Page 16. — "Die Wage" — No. 27.
(continued from page 15)
…now become current such turns of phrase and abuse as nowhere, save in Parliament, might be employed. The immunity of deputies is a fine thing; — but only from the intervention of the public prosecutor should the utterances of the people's representative be shielded, not from the unwritten law of civilised decency. What of late has here been allowed gradually to creep in is nothing less than the immunity of vileness. (Murmuring. Cries: "You insult the House," "Withdraw it!") What? A hundredweight of vilification against a whole class of fellow-citizens — vilification advanced without factual grounds, merely as an expression of malice — is to go unrebuked, while the unvarnished naming of the kind actually practised in the House is to be punishable, is to be withdrawn? Among my notes I find, among other utterances of like worth, the sentence: "The Jews live half again as long as human beings, and multiply after the manner of rabbits." Is such language statesmanlike, or scientific, or noble in tone and sentiment, or is it not simply — indeed deliberately — vile? To refute such things, or to repay them in the same coin? No, that one cannot do. Only such erroneous opinions deserve to be refuted as the other party advances in good faith, believing them to state what is true; but here — always as party tactics — things are said which the speakers themselves know quite well do not correspond to reality; their motive is wrath and malice, their purpose incitement and injury. Once again it is that fatal error of thought and feeling, "that the end sanctifies the means," which prompts the people who believe that Jewry can bring some economic or religious harm — to make use of any means to destroy the supposed enemy — that is the morality of war. And the others, who are not themselves antisemites, listen quietly and let the bad means — namely the truthless arguments and the incitement to hatred — quietly proceed, because they too have an end, be it the strengthening of their own party, the avoidance of crude attacks, the endeavour not to fall out with the popular current, or with the clergy, or with the high circles, in short, some end for the sake of which they too set themselves above the wickedness of their means — namely the means of keeping silent on such occasions. If a Gregorigo or a Schneider really lives in the mediaevally dark belief that the Jew is no human being but a contemptible, sub-human creature, capable of every crime, that "torments" Christian society — well, then he is, by the uttering of this belief, truly less blameworthy than one who is without prejudice, who himself knows many Jews whom he esteems and respects, whose hands he shakes in their own houses, and who here in this "high House" quietly lets them be reviled. Would you, gentlemen, look on just as calmly if someone set fire to the house of a Jewish scholar whom you hold in high regard, or gave a slap in the face to a Jewish lady whom you revere? And are these not spoken, stenographed, and printed in a hundred papers — very firebrands and boxes on the ear? How easily could every such word be paralysed here by vigorous counter-words, by energetic calls to order, whereas by the absence of contradiction it is as good as confirmed. Which is the more damnable — the ignorant fanaticism of the fire-raisers, or the cowardly and foolish conduct of those who will not put the fire out? Foolish — yes; for one cannot with impunity let the poisons of malice and vileness seep into an institution. The tone here struck and tolerated will, if it can, grow sharper still, will spread to every field of deliberation, and will — if it is not rooted out in good time, whether by way of the rules of procedure or by the general indignation that awakens at last — be the death of parliamentarism. The people themselves will no longer suffer that excesses which are inadmissible in the street or in a private house should become daily practice in the House of the people's representatives. Shirt-sleeve airs may still pass on the skittle-alley — there, after all, it is only a matter of well-aimed throws — but here, where the task is to create laws and institutions which determine the weal and woe of society, here one might at least demand that we be among gentlemen. (Cries: Oho!) So it is only "being human" that one may here deny to some without rebuke?
Believe me, an infallible criterion of the legitimacy of a thesis, of the profitableness of a proposed measure, is the method by which thesis and measure are defended, is the high or low standing of the mental and moral cultivation of their defenders. Only the noble avails, even though the ignoble may triumph. Whether the vileness be really contained in the sentiments of the advocate, or used merely as a coarse weapon — the cause is in any case ill served thereby. Nature has given us senses that are offended by what is harmful and thus warn and protect us. What is ugly, what is rough, what is cutting, what tears the ears, what smells foul — that harbours some defect, danger, decay, and filth . . . Our souls too are furnished with such warning senses: what is unaesthetic and unethical, what morally wounds and disgusts, what hurts and means to hurt, is surely reprehensible and fraught with corruption. He has not truth and salvation on his side — however much success he may have — who, for his ends, must appeal to the lower rather than the higher instincts of men, who, instead of awakening clear insight, a sound sense of justice, bright enthusiasm, gentle love, strives to pander to superstition, to the lust for violence and persecution, to fan envy and hatred. Of hurting I spoke just now — of deliberate hurting. That has been done here. In this body, whose sole envisaged aim should be the common good, pain is being wilfully inflicted upon a part of the population, including some here present. Does no fellow-feeling stir?
Gentlemen, in me you behold a man whose motto runs: "A check to torment." The saddest, the most hateful thing the world contains is inflicted suffering, and to free the world of it appears to me the way to salvation. Nothing good, nothing useful can spring from deliberately imposed pain, from injury done. Yet even if the perpetrators of those injuries give themselves out for judges and avengers and saviours, or hold themselves to be such — which may still be some excuse —, what excuse have the silent onlookers, who yet know that the injured have committed no crime and threaten to commit none? None! I cannot find even an explanation for it. It remains incomprehensible to me that here, where with the weight of words destinies are decided, one should let words sink into the one scale which must wound feeling so deeply, without hurling into the other scale the counterweight of indignant contradiction.
Well then, I have now uttered it, this impassioned counter-word, and will first — —"
President: "Deputy, you have long ceased to speak to the point; and you must yourself perceive that you no longer possess the attention of the House — I therefore find myself compelled — to my regret — to withdraw your right to speak.
The World of Books.
Mutter Eva. Three novellas by H. York-Steiner. A little preface. Written in prose, but a world away from all the prose of the everyday. And at the close of this preface the whole content summed up in a single sentence, which at the same time gives expression to York-Steiner's own striving and aspiration. Why does he write, why does he create, why does he live? "You ask why? That love may come into the world. This love, which hallows all things." — — — And so, in the three novellas, he tells of father and mother. — A breath of wistful resignation lies over these three tales, so full of intimacy and truth. "Der Dorspoet" is the title of the first novella. A man who loses to an unscrupulous individual the woman he idolises to the point of madness, and his child, because he will not betray his poor, oppressed, and despised people. In its terse, somewhat abrupt form this tale is one of the most deeply felt among those we owe to Steiner. The second novella, "Die Aerztin," does not want for a certain harsh strain. A piece of the woman question plays itself out in the tragic fate of the heroine. "Plain heroism" is what Uhland calls such a fate in his poem. And the last tale: "Mater dolorosa!" A Jewish mother who sees her child die wretchedly — a child to whom she "without complaint, without superfluous phrases, with a matter-of-course assurance sacrificed her whole existence." Her only child, who had estranged itself from her and from its people. And still the mother shields her dead child, shows it a thousandfold love beyond the grave — "this love, which hallows all things." — — — What York-Steiner offers us this time, offers so directly out of his heart, is more than the worthy continuation of his earlier tales. Hermann Bahr lately asserted in his "Conférence" that nowadays with us every author must write for the theatre, else he will not get on. No wonder if no one wishes any longer to write poems or novellas. For York-Steiner this does not hold. He has not let himself be led astray — and he has proved that he was right in so doing. Dr. W.
Publisher: Paul Aschäner. Responsible editor: Dr. Siegmund Werner. Printed by Jacob Dur, Vienna, VIII., Laudongasse No. 57.
