— 219 —
rather declare Tr. durum, instead, as formerly, of Tr. turgidum. The thick- and long-eared emmer forms are said to be distinguishable from Tr. durum only by the longer awns. Moreover, a whole number of cultivated forms may be assigned with the same right to durum as to turgidum. As standing nearest to the cultivated Tr. dicoccum, and differing from it only by the toughness of the spindle, as well as by the easier detachability of the grains from the glumes, Körnicke believes that he can designate the form of durum complanatum.
In connexion with the Aaronsohn finds, the views of the veteran master of cereal science here communicated will awaken interest. Detailed particulars concerning the mutual relations of the long series of forms of these important bread-plants are to be found in the classic work of the Synopsis of the Central European Flora by Ascherson and Graebner. The problem in what country the origin of emmer cultivation is to be sought, where the first attempt was made to place wheat from free nature in the service of man, will be able to be brought nearer to its solution only when more sure points of support for judging the earliest development of peoples in the Euphrates lands and in Central Asia shall have been gained; when, to say it in a word, in place of the present equation with many unknowns a simplified calculation of all the factors of civilization that have here co-operated is permitted. These factors are, in the first place, agriculture, writing, and religion. Since in Egypt so many survivals of the oldest civilization point inevitably to the Euphrates lands, to ancient Babylonia, or rather to Chaldaea in the narrower sense, the assured establishment of a wild relict form of the parent species of wheat in a region lying between is of great importance.
Considerations of various kinds, whose setting forth must here be omitted, have led Körnicke to accord to barley, in the development of agriculture, the primogeniture over wheat (or emmer). But whether the primitive Babylonians (Sumer), who were probably Turanians and as such stood nearer than other peoples of Hither Asia to the origin of many useful plants spread far to the west in the course of the ages — whether these Sumerians brought with them from their land of origin already the prototype of the cultivated wheat, or only barley, or whether they substituted these cereals for other long-accustomed ones in the new home,
