— 80 —
expropriators" belongs once and for all among the "foundations of scientific socialism." Here too the so-called common sense — which, as is well known, has nothing in common with the critical spirit — plays a great part. That scientific socialism has, in the agrarian question — theoretically and practically — brought forth only negative results, that it has proved its inability to draw up a scientifically grounded and practically feasible agrarian programme, that Zionist colonization has to reckon with entirely new conditions, that competition in Oppenheimer's sense is absolutely not identical with that now prevailing in the capitalist economy — all this "sound common sense" cannot and will not grasp. With both opponents it is very hard to contend theoretically, as indeed generally in the field of the social sciences, where objective thoughts are very easily replaced by subjective wishes. Only facts can there take effect. For these everyone has respect. The Marxists could be impressed only by a successful colonization on the basis of the co-operative association. This we Zionists can unfortunately not yet offer.
To the defenders of private-enterprise colonization after the long-established fashion, on the other hand, we can even now offer facts. Even though these are of a merely negative nature, they yet instruct us about much — namely: they show us how one must not colonize.
We should like in this article to report on the results of the investigations into the Jewish agricultural colonies in Russia.¹) There we see best whither private-enterprise colonization leads and must lead, independently of the bad or good will of men, but thanks to the natural — that is, the unalterable — development of things.
Already in the year 1804 the Russian government made the first attempts to found Jewish agricultural colonies. In the course of some years it also succeeded in settling 600 families in so-called New Russia. But soon the whole undertaking came to a standstill. In the year 1835, however, the colonization began anew, which unfortunately in the year 1859 was again interrupted. Since that time various regulations were issued by the government which made impossible not merely any
¹) Last year there appeared a two-volume work (in Russian), issued by the J. C. A., on the "Economic Situation of the Jews in Russia."
