Altneuland · Vol. II, No. 3 · March 1905
79printed page
scan 19 of 36
Facsimile · scan 19 of 36
Scan of p. 79
English · AI translation, checked against the German

— 79 —

standpoint of medical interest, nor from the emotional standpoint, but in its real significance for the practical work in Palestine, it recedes entirely into the background, as everyone will surely admit after the orientation set forth above. If, therefore, in our article on trachoma in Palestine (No. 6, Year I, 1904, of this journal) we had to warn against an underestimation of the significance of that eye disease for any extensive colonizing work in Palestine (without, to be sure, losing sight of the favourable chances of combating that plague), then for the (admittedly incurable) leprosy the very opposite holds: one must warn against an overestimation of its practical significance.

JEWISH AGRICULTURAL COLONIES ON THE BASIS OF PRIVATE ENTERPRISE.

By Privatdozent Dr. D. P a s m a n i k, Geneva.

The proposal of O p p e n h e i m e r, to build up the future Jewish colonization on the principle, developed by him, of the agricultural labourers' productive co-operative, which naturally develops into the settlement co-operative, meets with contradiction from two opposite sides: to the one the proposal is too far-reaching, to the other not decided enough. The one party thinks that one must not, forsooth, try out new principles and forms of economic life on the Jews; one should follow only the methods of the long-established economy, since the whole world nowadays knows only private enterprise. "Sound common sense," precisely, knows only reality, and shrinks back from plans for the future, be they ever so exactly grounded economically. "We are to colonize as the whole world colonizes," say these clever people. No, nothing new, nothing unknown.

To the others the proposal of O p p e n h e i m e r is not to their taste, because it speaks nothing of the class struggle. An economic system which does not rest on class struggle, which moreover recognizes competition as the fundamental force of social life, smells suspicious — somewhat bourgeois-like. The "expropriation of the