— 50 —
In any case, we repeat it, an experiment in this respect is necessary.
In conclusion we recall once more how very careful one must be when one would launch an undertaking which was apparently unknown among us.
PALESTINE AND NEIGHBOURING REGIONS.
The Colonization of El-Arish.
From No. 1, 1905, of the Italian monthly "L'Idea Sionista" we take the following expositions by Prof. Dr. Claudio W. Guastalla on the territory of El-Arish, on which he had reported in detail in the December number, 1904, of the Italian review "L'Italia Coloniale." We remark expressly that we do not share the optimism of the author with regard to the possibility of settling the territory in question. Likewise the author appears to us to have taken up, in his introduction, a somewhat singular standpoint.
Prof. Guastalla writes:
Toward the end of August 1903 the sixth Zionist Congress, sitting at Basle, discussed the offer of the English Government for the establishment of a Hebrew colony with autonomous administration, under the high English protectorate, in a territory of equatorial Africa near Lake Victoria.
The British proposal aimed not only at directing a fruitful emigration toward a province of the Empire, but also at checking the influx of the poor Hebrews who — in flight from Russia or Roumania — sought life and liberty in London or New York.
But even if the Zionist movement derives its chief strength from an economic necessity, it nevertheless also intends to unite the scat- tered members of the Hebrew people in their old, promised land under the rule of their old, melancholy God: a pardonable religious aspiration for a race trodden underfoot and made a mockery for so many centuries. Hence it came about that the idea of directing the Hebrew proletariat to a colony of equatorial Africa found many vehement opponents, and it was precisely the most oppressed and most destitute who would not accept the place of refuge offered by England, not even as a provisional arrangement and in expectation of better times, because it diverted them from the road to Jerusalem.
The opposition maintained: "Jewish immigration must be directed toward the town of El-Arish, which lies so near the borders of Palestine," and accused the Actions Committee of not having occupied itself earnestly enough with this pro- posal and of having let it drop without sufficient studies. The Committee justified itself in reply by setting forth "that it had received from the Egyptian Government a favourable decision regarding the draft scheme of the granting of a charter over a strip of land of the territory of the Sinai Peninsula. But after a Zionist commission had examined the district,
