Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion, Jerusalem Edition · 1919
108scan
of 139
Facsimile · scan 108 of 139
Scan of scan 108
English · AI translation, checked against the Hebrew

Mount Tzvi

…in such a case. And how is it possible to say that, following their own reasoning, they perhaps explained the words of Rabbi Yohanan as concerning incense? Surely Rabbi Yohanan explicitly holds like the Rabbis who dispute with Rabbi Shimon, and according to Rav Hamnuna there in Menahot, this is the reason, that one who consecrates it to slaughter it outside is liable to excision. And if it should enter your mind to say that they establish it with incense for this reason, because with a slaughtered offering he did not make his freewill offering in the manner of those who make freewill offerings: but since the consecration does not take effect, there is no excision either, for they are merely unconsecrated animals! Rather, certainly, it is not because Rabbi Yohanan holds that one who consecrates in this time is not in the manner of those who make freewill offerings. And as for his leaving, as needing great investigation, the method of Tosafot in Pesahim, that the concern is that he consecrated it in its lifetime and it is not in the manner of those who make freewill offerings, so that it does not accord even with Rabbi Yohanan, for Rabbi Yohanan too holds like Rabbi Shimon that if he did not make his freewill offering in the manner of those who make freewill offerings there is no vow here at all; thus far. At first sight, according to what Tosafot wrote (Menahot 103a), that even according to Hizkiyah, by whom Rabbi Yohanan holds like Rabbi Shimon in the case of one who says "I take upon myself a meal-offering of barley", that he is exempt, nevertheless in the case of one who says "I take upon myself a burnt-offering, that I shall offer it in the House of Onias", he disputes Rabbi Shimon and the consecration takes effect (see there well), it is a matter that stands to reason that this dispute of Rabbi Shimon and the Rabbis concerning one who consecrates in order to offer outside does not depend on their other dispute concerning one who says "I take upon myself a meal-offering of barley". And so it appears from the words of Tosafot (there, 109a), who wrote: "there is no place here for 'hold to the first expression' and 'the last'" etc.; which implies that in truth it is a single expression, and nevertheless they dispute; and for the Rabbis, even though it is not in the manner of those who make freewill offerings, nevertheless the consecration takes effect. And that case of one who says "I take upon myself a meal-offering of barley" is different, for even for Rabbi Yohanan there is no room for his vow to take effect except if we say that we divide the utterance and hold to the first expression, or because a man does not utter his words in vain; and therefore from the outset his intention was for a meal-offering without specification; because without this it would be a vow whose release is with it, for a meal-offering he did not take upon himself, and how should he be bound by a thing he did not vow? Which is not so with one who consecrates a burnt-offering to offer it outside: when we come to judge of the consecration itself, that the animal should be seized by the sanctity of a burnt-offering, it has full room to take effect by force of the language of his vow; and as for its not being in the manner of those who make freewill offerings, on this the Rabbis dispute with Rabbi Shimon and say that the consecration is not held back on that account; and so Maimonides ruled, like the Rabbis who dispute with Rabbi Shimon. What emerges from all that has been said is that what the Hatam Sofer wrote, permitting offering in this time by force of "either way", because even for Rabad there is no need to fear on account of holy things outside: behold, it has been made clear that these words of his have no foundation, according to what we hold, that even one who consecrates explicitly in order to offer outside is punished with excision, and all the more so in such a case as ours, where he consecrates without specification. And even for Rava, who holds that one who consecrates a burnt-offering, "that I shall offer it in the House of Onias", is not liable to excision for slaughtering it outside, and for him it is not holy at all (see Menahot 109), nevertheless in our case there is room to discuss this. For behold, Tosafot (Ketubot 56a) asked: in the case of one who says "I am a Nazirite on condition that I shave in the House of Onias" etc., surely he is making a condition against what is written in the Torah, for there is no shaving except in the Sanctuary! And Ri said that we do not say that one who makes a condition against what is written in the Torah, his condition is void, except where he intends to uproot what is written in the Torah; but there he supposes that there is a commandment in the House of Onias as in the Temple, and he does not intend to uproot it. And according to this there would be room to argue in our case, by the method of Rabad, that one who consecrates the Passover offering to offer it outside is not making a condition against what is written in the Torah, and his condition stands. However, Tosafot in Nazir answered in another way, and these are their words: "And one may say that the meaning of his language is two things: it implies a proper Naziriteship etc., and it implies also that he intends only to afflict himself etc.; and the Naziriteship stands suspended etc."; thus far their words. And according to these words of theirs, the main reason the Naziriteship does not take effect is because from the outset he revealed his mind in language that can be understood two ways, and if he shaved outside, it is revealed retroactively that from the outset he did not intend Naziriteship at all; which is not so in our case, of one who consecrates a Passover offering to offer it