Essay on Holy Things
…to me that there is a clear proof that it is not so. First, that there is an explicit discussion in Rosh Hashanah, folio 7, that communal sacrifices are valid when they come from an individual, provided that he hands them over to the community; and so Maimonides decided, chapter 8 of the Laws of the Vessels of the Sanctuary; and the Mishneh la-Melekh there and in chapter 4 of the Laws of Shekels brings several more discussions that teach so. And as for that passage in Bava Metzia 118 concerning the watchman, Tosafot wrote on it, in the passage beginning "A watchman is different", and the Mishneh la-Melekh wrote that he did not understand their opinion, what difference there is from this. And it seems to me that the individual must hand them over to the treasurer, that he may acquire it on behalf of the community; for every conferring of title must be done through another, as is found in the Asheri, chapter Ha-Gozel Kamma, halakhah 18, that a man cannot confer what is his upon another unless another acquires it, and one may acquire on behalf of a man in his absence. But with the watchman, who acquired by looking, and afterwards the community reaps from the field, then it did not come from his hand into the hand of the community, and acquisition does not apply; for the soil is not the watchman's, and the seeds did not come into the watchman's hand, that he should hand them over into the hand of the treasurer to acquire on behalf of the community. And this is correct in the plain sense of Tosafot (and if perhaps they did not intend this, the thing is correct in itself). And as for that passage in Yoma (folio 35), concerning the priest whose mother made him a tunic: it seems to me that the mother made it in honour of her son, and certainly insists that no other priest should serve in it, for that would be no glory to her son; therefore he serves in it only in the Service of an individual. But when the individual gives it to all the priests by a complete conferring of title, it is permitted; and this is the ruling of Maimonides, that communal sacrifices are valid when they come from an individual. And further, even if the law were that it is forbidden from the outset, nevertheless after the fact it certainly does not invalidate, just as Maimonides decided that if there are no new shekels, they bring from the old ones from the outset, even though it is written "month by month"; and as is found explicitly in the Talmud, Rosh Hashanah there; and so it is there concerning an individual who volunteered from his own. And this is clear, apart from what we wrote above, that the minority are the agents of all Israel; and there is no doubt in this. And it is a wonder to me at the Gaons mentioned above, that they exerted themselves over this, in a thing that is plain in the Talmud and in Maimonides.
- I further took sweet counsel on this (by way of letters) with the Rabbi, the Gaon, the wise and accomplished and God-fearing, our teacher Rabbi Nathan Adler, may his light shine, head of the rabbinical court of the holy community of London. And in the course of his argument, which he argued with wisdom, he set before me from the words of Rashi in Sukkah 41a, and Tosafot, Shevuot 15b, passage beginning "There is no building", the implication that the altar and everything that belongs to the Sanctuary Yahweh, blessed be He, will establish from heaven, out of the fire above. And on the question of the scholar mentioned above I copied out for him what I wrote, with Yahweh's help, in my novellae on Rabbenu Tam, and this is its language: "For many years the discussions of the Talmud (Rosh Hashanah 30 and Sukkah 31) have been difficult for me. The Mishnah: that the whole day of the waving shall be forbidden. What is the reason? The Temple may speedily be built, and they will say, 'Last year, etc.' And it objects: 'If it was built, when? etc. Rather, that it was built on the fifteenth, etc. It is needed only at night.' And Rashi raised the difficulty: but there is no building of the Temple at night, nor on a festival; and he answered: the future building will come from heaven, built and perfected; and so Tosafot wrote. And it is a wonder to me: how should we fear, concerning such a time, that they will not know the law? Surely when a Sanctuary of fire comes from heaven, the earth will already be full of knowledge as the waters cover the sea; and who will come to error? And something like this we find in Yoma 5: 'How does he clothe them in the time to come?'; and it objects: 'In the time to come, when Aaron and his sons come, and Moses with them, will they not know?' 'Rather, it is to understand the verses'; see there. Hence concerning such a time we have no occasion to raise any doubt. And how should we now decree a decree on account of so great a generation, who will already have become separated from those who err? Further, it is a wonder to me how Rashi and Tosafot decided that the future building will be only from heaven, when it is found explicitly in the Jerusalem Talmud, cited in the Tosafot Yom Tov, chapter 5 of Ma'aser (which we brought above), that the building of the Temple precedes the kingdom of the house of David, and that then the enemies will still have some dominion over us; if so, it will first be by human hands. And the words of the Jerusalem Talmud are compelled by the Mishnah, which says 'This implies'; for if the days of the true Messiah were to be together with the building of the altar, then there would certainly be a court
