Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion · 1862
33scan
of 43
Facsimile · scan 33 of 43
Scan of scan 33
English · AI translation, checked against the Hebrew

Essay on Holy Things

…and the others are content with the merit of their brethren. At any rate it is proven that shekels on behalf of Israel suffice. And on the matter of tekhelet (the blue) and purple, I have already refuted it before our master: either that it is not needed at all, or that even if it is needed it is not indispensable, and if not, nothing. Thus far the substance of my words to him. I was not privileged to receive any further reply from him on this, for it pleased Yahweh to afflict him with sickness, and he fell to his bed until he went up on high to the bond of life, for He took him from us, for our many sins. And behold, our master, of saintly and blessed memory, copied out for me only the substance of the reply of our brother, the pious Gaon of Pressburg; and now we have been privileged to have his holy book Hatam Sofer, and there is written his reply to my father-in-law, our master, of blessed memory, and it is the very one he gave him according to the words of the exchange of letters that took place between them. See the book mentioned above, section 236, where he replied to his father-in-law the Gaon, our master, of blessed memory, in the words mentioned: that there is permission to offer sacrifices, and that there is no concern over priests of attested lineage or the priestly garments. And behold, Rabbi Hayyim of Paris wished to offer sacrifices, but his opinion is to permit only Passover offerings and not the other public sacrifices, on account of the shekels, as above. And I have already written above a clear proof that even without the shekels of all Israel all the public sacrifices can be offered, and a further clear proof will be explained shortly.

  1. A further clear proof I wrote to the great Gaon, our teacher Rabbi Hirsch Chajes, who was head of the rabbinical court of the holy community of Kalisch, may God protect it, and of Zolkiew, when I saw his book, the Responsa of Maharatz, section 76, folio 82, that he too wrote there a permission to offer sacrifices, but that there is proof only for the Passover offering and not for the other sacrifices, because they come from the shekels, and the shekels are in force only while the Temple stands. And I wrote to him that there seems to me a clear proof that it is not so. First, for there is an explicit passage in Rosh Hashanah, folio 7, that it is established that they are valid from an individual, provided that he hands them over to the community; and so Maimonides ruled, chapter 8 of the Vessels of the Sanctuary, and the Mishneh le-Melekh there and in chapter 4 of Shekalim cites several more passages that indicate so. And as for the passage in Bava Metzia 118 concerning the watchman, Tosafot wrote in Rosh Hashanah that a watchman is different, and the Mishneh le-Melekh wrote that he did not understand their view, what difference there is in this. And it seems to me that the individual must hand them over to the treasurer, who takes possession of it on behalf of the community, for every conveyance requires another person, as is found in the Asheri, chapter Ha-Gozel Kamma, paragraph 18, that a man does not convey what is his to another unless he conveys: one may act to a man's disadvantage in his absence. And in the case of the watchman, who acquired by looking, and afterwards the community reap from the field, it did not then come from his hand into the hand of the community, and acquisition does not apply, for the ground is not the watchman's, and the crops did not come into the watchman's hand that he might hand them over to the treasurer to acquire on behalf of the community; and this is correct in the method of Tosafot (and if perhaps they did not intend this, the thing is correct in itself). And the passage in Yoma, folio 35, about the priest whose mother made him a tunic, one must say that the mother made it for the honour of her son, and certainly she minds that no other priest should serve in it, for that is no glory to her son; therefore it disqualifies only for the Service of an individual, but when the individual gives it to all the priests by a complete conveyance, it is permitted. And that is the ruling of Maimonides, that it is established that they are valid from an individual. And further, even if the law were to forbid it at the outset, nevertheless after the fact it certainly does not invalidate; as Maimonides ruled that if there are no new shekels they bring even at the outset from the old, although it is written "each month in its month", as is found explicitly in the Talmud, Rosh Hashanah, there; and so it is there concerning an individual who donated of his own. If so, besides what we wrote above, that a minority are agents of all Israel, there is no doubt in this; and it is a wonder about the Gaonim mentioned above, that this escaped them, a plain matter in the Talmud and in Maimonides.

  2. I further took sweet counsel on this (by way of letters) with the Rabbi, the Gaon, the perfect sage, and God-fearing, our teacher Rabbi Nathan Adler, may his light shine, head of the rabbinical court of the holy community of London. And in the course of his argument, which he argued with wisdom, he set up for me a marker from the words of Rashi on Sukkah 41a and Tosafot on Shevuot 15b, s.v. "There is no building", implying that the altar and all that belongs to the Sanctuary, Rashi: He will establish them from heaven, from the fire above. And on the question of the sage mentioned above, I copied out before him what I had written, with Yahweh's help, in my novellae on Rosh Hashanah, and these are my words: For many years I have had a difficulty with the passages of the Talmud (Rosh Hashanah 30 and Sukkah 41): the Mishnah, that the whole day of the waving should be forbidden. What is the reason? "The Temple may speedily be rebuilt, and they will say, 'Last year etc.'" And it objects: "If it is built, when? etc. Rather, that it is built on the fifteenth etc. It is needed only at night." And Rashi raised the difficulty: but the Temple is not built at night, nor on a festival! And he answered: the future building will come complete, built and perfected; and so wrote Tosafot. And it is a wonder to me how, regarding such a people, we should fear that they will not know the law, since, when the Sanctuary of God comes from heaven, the earth will already be full of knowledge as the waters cover the sea; and who will come to error? And on this matter we find in Yoma 5: "How does he clothe them? In the time to come?" And it objects: "In the time to come, when Aaron and his sons come and Moses with them, will they not know? Rather, it is to understand the verses." See there. Evidently