Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
392printed page
scan 406 of 434
Facsimile · scan 406 of 434
Scan of p. 392
English · AI translation, not yet checked

392

He was a writer of great talent, and if he had been able to concentrate, to dedicate himself entirely to his art, he would have risen high in German literature. He could have achieved a top rank. But I do not know if he would have become the first writer of his era.

He was an excellent orator: calm, witty, simple, moderate, and always tasteful. He commanded a form of impeccable elegance, even when improvising. His presence of mind never failed him. Completely master of himself, he thereby became master of the most agitated assemblies and the most passionate debates. But he distrusted himself and preferred the written preparation of his speeches to improvisation, which he read aloud, a practice that naturally diminished their immediate success somewhat, and his clever, moderate, persuasive words rarely had that powerful breath which sweeps along and intoxicates even the skeptic.

He had a fertile, creative imagination that could devise solutions for all difficulties and conjure up images of great beauty. But for all his imaginative power, he did not surpass Georges Eliot, whose “Daniel Deronda” is preferred by some to “Altneuland.”

He had a sharp, practical mind and proved it through the organization of the Zionist movement, the congresses, the Jewish Colonial Trust, and the National Fund. But even in this respect, the great Jewish financiers, industrialists, merchants, and administrators can be regarded as his equals.

Less of a poet than Heinrich Heine, a lesser orator than Disraeli, less imaginative than the Christian Eliot, a smaller administrator than Baron Hirsch, he was