Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
305printed page
scan 319 of 434
Facsimile · scan 319 of 434
Scan of p. 305
English · AI translation, not yet checked

305

One can debate this point academically without end. The anthropologist hesitates for a very long time before he scientifically defines the concept of race. But the street urchin on the outer boulevards, who shouts his "Down with the Jews" under the nose of the passerby he recognizes as a Jew, testifies that for him this difficulty does not exist.

And his ethnographic diagnosis, if it is not infallible — that of the scholars is probably not always infallible either —, deceives him only very rarely. The certainty of the street urchins' gaze alone is enough to establish that the Jews are indeed a race, or at least a variety or, if you will, for that matter, an ethnographic sub-variety.

Are they a people?

At least eight million of the Jews will answer you resolutely with "Yes." That is decisive. I grant you that among many Western Jews the Jewish-national sentiment is very much weakened, that in others it has disappeared down to the last trace, and that in some others it has turned into a wild and ignoble hatred against everything that is Jewish. But the apathy, the degeneracy, or the absence of the Jewish-national spirit in a small minority of denationalized Hebrews cannot be an argument in the face of the living, even exalted, nationalism of the immense majority of the people of Israel.

A final word. If the Jews want to return to Palestine, it should not be to submerge into Asiatic barbarism, but to free themselves from the barbarism of the ghetto.

20