Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
304printed page
scan 318 of 434
Facsimile · scan 318 of 434
Scan of p. 304
English · AI translation, not yet checked

304

That is their affair. But there is a certain number of Jews of the category that I called the privileged, who, like us, have a different conception of our duties. We do not deny our fathers, and that imposes upon us the duty to recognize all descendants of our common ancestors as brothers. But this also implies that we recognize other obligations towards them.

The Zionist movement was not invented by us. It arose in the circle of the Jews of the backward countries.

Our brothers down there are suffering and cry: "Help!" We hurry to their aid.

They are a chaotic mass. We organize them.

They stammer their complaints in a gibberish incomprehensible to cultivated people. We lend them the civilized languages.

They push forward impetuously, without orientation. We show them the path they must take.

They have an indefinite longing. We formulate it.

They are seized by an almost frenzied enthusiasm. We moderate it. Then again, when their enthusiasm does not immediately lead to the goal, a new despair seizes them. We console them and lift their spirits.

I now ask you if you in fact consider our attitude, the attitude of the Western Zionists, less worthy, less commendable than that of the Jewish millionaires and decadents?

You doubt whether the Jews are a race, and you dispute that they are a people.